Performance Evaluation of Precise Point Positioning for BeiDou-3 B1c/B2a Signals in the Global Range

Ershen Wang, Tao Yang, Zhi Wang, Yize Zhang, Jing Guo, Wansen Shu, Pingping QuSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive global evaluation of the new BeiDou-3 B1c/B2a signals for Precise Point Positioning (PPP). The study reveals that while BDS-3 B1c/B2a offers competitive performance, especially in convergence time, it still lags behind GPS in accuracy, particularly in the vertical component, likely due to issues with precise orbit and clock products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The BeiDou Navigation Satellite System (BDS) has recently launched its third generation (BDS-3), introducing new signals like B1c and B2a designed for improved compatibility and performance. While previous research has touched upon BDS PPP, a thorough global evaluation of these new B1c/B2a signals, especially in comparison to established systems like GPS, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by assessing the global PPP performance of BDS-3 B1c/B2a signals, comparing it with GPS and older BDS signals, and understanding its potential for global navigation.

Methods

The researchers employed the Precise Point Positioning (PPP) technique, a method that uses a single receiver to determine its position with high accuracy by processing satellite orbit and clock information. They utilized a Kalman filtering approach for state estimation, distinguishing between static and kinematic PPP modes. The core of their analysis involved processing observational data from 17 global stations over 20 days. They specifically focused on the ionosphere-free combination of BDS-3 B1c/B2a signals and compared its performance against GPS (L1L2), older BDS signals (B1I/B3I), and various combinations of these systems.

Datasets

The study used 20 days of observation data (December 1st to December 20th, 2020) from 17 globally distributed GNSS stations. These stations were capable of receiving GPS and both older (B1I/B3I) and newer (B1c/B2a) BDS signals. The precise orbit and clock products used were from the GBM analysis center.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • BDS-3 B1c/B2a is promising but not yet a GPS killer: The new BDS-3 signals show good potential, especially in terms of convergence speed, but GPS still holds an edge in overall positioning accuracy, particularly in the vertical dimension.
  • Orbit and Clock Data Quality Matters: The performance gap between BDS and GPS is attributed, in part, to the quality of the precise orbit and clock products. Using GPS PCO/PCV corrections for BDS may also introduce inaccuracies.
  • System Bias Exists: Static PPP for BDS-3 (B1cB2a) and combined BDS-2+3 (B1IB3I) exhibit noticeable system biases, especially in the upward component.
  • More Satellites = Better PPP: For kinematic PPP, the number of visible satellites has a significant impact. Combining GPS and BDS generally improves positioning accuracy and convergence due to the increased satellite visibility.
  • Antenna Models Less Critical for Convergence: While the number of satellites is crucial for convergence, the specific antenna model of high-end receivers doesn't appear to significantly influence the convergence speed for BDS B1c/B2a PPP.

Key Results

  • Static PPP Accuracy (BDS-3 B1c/B2a):
    • North (N): 6.9 mm RMS
    • East (E): 4.7 mm RMS
    • Upward (U): 26.6 mm RMS
  • Kinematic PPP Accuracy (BDS-3 B1c/B2a):
    • North (N): 2.6 cm RMS
    • East (E): 6.0 cm RMS
    • Upward (U): 8.5 cm RMS
  • Combined GPS + BDS-3 (B1cB2a) Improvement: 3D coordinate accuracy increased by 27% compared to static PPP.
  • Convergence: BDS-3 (B1CB2a) shows better convergence time than BDS-2+BDS-3 (B1IB3I) in both static and kinematic modes.
  • GPS vs. BDS: GPS-only static PPP horizontal error was 16.8% better than BDS-3 (B1cB2a), and vertical error was 46.3% better.
  • Multi-GNSS Advantage: Combining GPS and BDS significantly improves positioning accuracy, with 3D error increasing by 59% (vs. BDS-3) and 70% (vs. BDS-2+3) when combined with GPS.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the accuracy of BDS orbit and clock products, particularly the PCO/PCV corrections, is not as refined as GPS, leading to lower accuracy, especially in the vertical component. They also note that the number of available BDS satellites at some stations can be limited, impacting PPP performance. Future work could focus on improving BDS orbit and clock determination strategies and developing more robust PPP algorithms to mitigate these issues and further enhance global positioning capabilities. The paper suggests that with algorithmic advancements, the performance gap between BDS and GPS will likely narrow.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the construction and development of the BeiDou navigation satellite system (BDS), the precise point positioning (PPP) performance of the BDS is worthy of research. In this study, observational data from 17 stations around the world across 20 days are used to comprehensively evaluate the PPP performance of BDS B1c/B2a signals. For greater understanding, the results are also compared with the Global Positioning System (GPS) and BDS PPP performance of different signals and system combinations. The evaluation found root mean square (RMS) values of the static PPP in the north (N), east (E), and upward (U) components, based on the B1c/B2a frequency of BDS-3, to be 6.9 mm, 4.7 mm, and 26.6 mm, respectively. Similar to the static positioning, the RMS values of kinematic PPP in the three directions of N, E, and U are 2.6 cm, 6.0 cm, and 8.5 cm, respectively. Besides this, the static PPP of BDS-3 (B1cB2a) and BDS-2 + BDS-3 (B1IB3I) have obvious system bias. Compared with static PPP, kinematic PPP is more sensitive to the number of satellites, and the coordinate accuracy in three dimensions can be increased by 27% with the combination of GPS (L1L2) and BDS. Compared with BDS-2+BDS-3 (B1IB3I), the convergence time of BDS-3 (B1CB2a) performs better in both static and kinematic modes. The antenna model does not show a significant difference in terms of the effect of the convergence speed, though the number of satellites observed has a certain influence on the convergence time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021performance,
  author = {Ershen Wang and Tao Yang and Zhi Wang and Yize Zhang and Jing Guo and Wansen Shu and Pingping Qu},
  title = {{Performance Evaluation of Precise Point Positioning for BeiDou-3 B1c/B2a Signals in the Global Range}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21175780},
}
Figure