Performance Evaluation and Compensation Method of Trigger Probes in Measurement Based on the Abbé Principle

Guoying Ren, Xinghua Qu, Xiangjun Chen2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel calibration method for trigger probes, crucial components in precision manufacturing. By applying the Abbé principle, the method directly measures probe performance parameters, enabling accurate error compensation and significantly improving measurement accuracy in CMMs and CNC machines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Trigger probes are essential for quality control in precision manufacturing, found in Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMMs) and high-end Computer Numerical Control (CNC) machine tools. Their accuracy directly impacts the quality of manufactured products. However, traditional methods for calibrating these probes have limitations. They often struggle to accurately measure the trigger force in different directions and lack specialized devices to calibrate key characteristic parameters. This makes it difficult to precisely compensate for measurement errors arising from the probe's trigger force. While the Abbé principle is a known guideline for improving measurement accuracy by aligning the measurement target and scale, existing probe calibration methods often do not adhere to it, leading to potential measurement errors. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a method that directly measures probe performance parameters based on the Abbé principle, allowing for more accurate error compensation.

Methods

The core of this paper is a new calibration method that leverages the Abbé principle. The key idea is to directly measure the displacement change of the probe ball tip, thereby minimizing elastic deformation errors and Abbé errors. The proposed system involves:

  • Collinear Alignment: The measurement setup ensures the movement axis of the grating ruler and the axis of probe movement are collinear in the measurement direction, adhering to the Abbé principle.
  • Laser Displacement Sensor: A laser interferometer-based displacement sensor is used to precisely monitor the probe ball tip's displacement.
  • Grating Ruler: A precise grating ruler mounted on a push rod measures the displacement of the push rod.
  • Controlled Movement: A step motor drives a push rod to approach the probe ball tip at a controlled speed.
  • Signal Acquisition: The system simultaneously records signals from the grating ruler, a contact sensor, and the trigger probe circuit.
  • Mathematical Modeling: The paper develops a detailed mathematical model to analyze the probe's behavior, including rigid displacement, deflection displacement, and elastic compression displacement, under the influence of trigger force. This model allows for the calculation of pre-travel, trigger hysteresis, and repeatability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a novel calibration methodology and experimental verification using a specific type of trigger probe.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Abbé Principle is Key: Applying the Abbé principle directly to probe calibration is crucial for minimizing measurement errors and improving accuracy.
  • Direct Measurement is Superior: Directly measuring the probe ball tip's displacement, rather than inferring it through indirect means (like voltage or force changes), provides more accurate calibration data.
  • Anisotropy is Significant: Probe performance parameters, such as pre-travel and repeatability, exhibit anisotropic behavior, meaning they vary with direction. This necessitates directional calibration.
  • Trigger Force Impact: The trigger force significantly influences probe pre-travel, with deflection becoming a dominant factor at higher forces.
  • Material Selection Matters: For probe design, materials with high elastic modulus are preferred for the probe rod to minimize deflection.

Key Results

The experimental verification demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method:

  • Accurate Parameter Calibration: The method successfully obtains direct calibration errors of the probe's performance parameters, including pre-travel, trigger hysteresis, and repeatability.
  • Improved Measurement Accuracy: By compensating for the identified probe errors, the measurement accuracy of a standard sphere on a CMM was significantly improved. The error to the nominal diameter was reduced from -0.84 µm to -0.04 µm after compensation.
  • Low Measurement Uncertainty: The developed calibration system exhibits low measurement uncertainty, with the maximum error for displacement measurement being less than 20 nm.
  • Directional Analysis: The study revealed significant directional variations in probe performance parameters, with the smallest error ranges for repeatability and pre-travel observed in specific directions (e.g., 90°).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Specificity: The developed mathematical model and calibration method are primarily applicable to trigger probes with a specific mechanical structure.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to focus on reducing measurement uncertainty and improving calibration accuracy by further analyzing error sources. They also hope to provide a new reference for measurement methods for related researchers.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{ren2020performance,
  author = {Guoying Ren and Xinghua Qu and Xiangjun Chen},
  title = {{Performance Evaluation and Compensation Method of Trigger Probes in Measurement Based on the Abbé Principle}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20082413},
}
Figure