Abstract
In this article the electromagnetic and thermal performance of an axial flux permanent magnet machine with anodised aluminium foil as stator winding conductor material is analysed and compared to enamelled copper wire. The influence of the conductor material on the DC and AC winding losses, and the torque density is studied. Additionally, the influence of the motor housing convective heat transfer coefficient is examined. It can be concluded that the anodised aluminium foil winding offers an attractive alternative for copper wire, especially in low speed applications where the thermal resistance of the winding body is dominant in the thermal path from heat source to heat sink.
Introduction
In the field of robotics, particularly for "quasi-direct drive" actuators used in legged robots and collaborative robots (cobots), torque density is a critical performance metric. Engineers strive to develop motors that minimize mass while maximizing torque output. Traditionally, enamelled round copper wire has been the standard choice for motor windings. However, copper's high density and the thermal bottlenecks created by the resin and air gaps between round wires limit performance. These gaps act as thermal insulators, trapping heat within the motor.
Anodized aluminum foil presents a compelling alternative. While aluminum has approximately 37% lower electrical conductivity than copper and can suffer from higher AC losses in foil form, it is significantly lighter. Furthermore, the insulation in anodized foil is a thin, thermally conductive ceramic layer (alumina) grown directly on the metal. This study investigates whether the thermal and mass advantages of anodized aluminum foil can outweigh its electrical shortcomings to produce a superior motor for robotic applications.
Methodology
The research utilizes a Yokeless and Segmented Armature (YASA) Axial Flux Permanent Magnet Synchronous Machine (AFPMSM) as the primary test bench. The YASA topology is particularly well-suited for foil windings because its segmented teeth allow coils to be wound individually before stator assembly.
The performance comparison involved several key steps:
- Electromagnetic Modeling: Analytical models were used to calculate DC and AC winding losses. These models were validated through the manufacturing of physical prototype tooth coils for both enamelled copper and anodized aluminum foil.
- 3D Thermal Finite Element Method (FEM): A steady-state thermal model of a quarter-tooth coil was developed. This model accounts for thermal anisotropy, recognizing that heat conduction is significantly higher along the foil/wire length than across insulation layers.
- Homogenization: To ensure computational efficiency, the winding was modeled as a homogenized volume using a thermal conductivity tensor.
- Cooling Analysis: Performance was evaluated under two boundary conditions: forced air-cooling and water-jacket cooling.
Results and Discussion
The study reveals that the thermal path is the deciding factor in low-speed, high-torque robotic applications. In these scenarios, the motor's torque is primarily limited by the stator's hotspot temperature.
Thermal and Mass Advantages
Anodized aluminum foil demonstrates a much higher equivalent thermal conductivity than round copper wire. The ceramic alumina insulation layer is thin and possesses high thermal conductivity (~1.6 W/mK), drastically reducing thermal resistance between the heat source and the sink.
On a mass-specific basis (Nm/kg), aluminum outperforms copper because it is nearly three times lighter. For mobile robotics, where reducing overall weight is paramount, this is a significant advantage. The aluminum foil version achieved an 8.5% higher mass torque density under forced air-cooling and a 13% increase with water-jacket cooling compared to the copper version.
Efficiency and Operating Temperatures
At low speeds, the efficiency of both winding types is nearly identical as conduction losses dominate. However, as shown in the efficiency ratio plot, the aluminum foil's performance relative to copper degrades at higher speeds due to increased AC losses (skin and proximity effects).
Thermal measurements showed that at a specific operating point (70 rpm, 12 Nm/kg), the aluminum motor's hotspot was 31°C lower than the copper motor's under air-cooling. This difference increased to 68°C under liquid cooling, highlighting the superior heat dissipation of the foil winding.
Conclusion
Anodized aluminum foil windings offer a significant performance boost for low-speed, high-torque axial flux motors used in robotics. The primary benefits stem from reduced mass and superior thermal management, which allow for higher continuous torque densities despite lower electrical conductivity.
However, the technology is less suitable for high-speed applications, such as electric vehicle traction, where AC losses in the foil become prohibitive. Future work should focus on integrating rotor loss analysis, developing scalable manufacturing processes for foil-wound segments, and investigating transient thermal behavior during the high-torque bursts typical of robotic movement.
Summary updated