Performance Bounds and Optimization for CSI-Ratio-Based Bi-Static Doppler Sensing in ISAC Systems

Yanmo Hu, Kai Wu, J. Andrew Zhang, Weibo Deng, Y. Jay GuoIEEE Trans. Wireless Communications 2024 · arXiv

Abstract

Bi-static sensing is crucial for exploring the potential of networked sensing capabilities in integrated sensing and communications (ISAC). However, it suffers from the challenging clock asynchronism issue. CSI ratio-based sensing is an effective means to address the issue. Its performance bounds, particularly for Doppler sensing, have not been fully understood yet. This work endeavors to fill the research gap. Focusing on a single dynamic path in high-SNR scenarios, we derive the closed-form Cramer-Rao Bound (CRB). Then, through analyzing the mutual interference between dynamic and static paths, we simplify the CRB results by deriving close approximations, further unveiling new insights into the impact of numerous physical parameters on Doppler sensing. Moreover, utilizing the new CRB and analyses, we propose novel waveform optimization strategies for noise- and interference-limited sensing scenarios, which are also empowered by closed-form and efficient solutions. Extensive simulation results are provided to validate the preciseness of the derived CRB results and analyses, with the aid of the maximum-likelihood estimator (MLE). The results also demonstrate the substantially enhanced Doppler sensing accuracy and the sensing capabilities for low-speed targets achieved by the proposed waveform design.

Introduction

In bi-static ISAC—where the transmitter and receiver are physically separated—clock asynchronism is a major hurdle. Because the two nodes use different oscillators, they suffer from Time Measurement Offset (TMO) and Carrier Frequency Offset (CFO), which create massive ambiguities in range and Doppler measurements. While the CSI-ratio model (calculating the ratio of signals across different antennas) is an elegant way to cancel out these common clock errors, its fundamental performance limits were previously poorly understood. Specifically, researchers lacked a closed-form expression for the CRB—the theoretical minimum possible estimation error. Without this bound, it was impossible to know if existing estimators were optimal or how to design waveforms to maximize sensing performance.

Theoretical Framework: CRB Derivation

This research establishes the first comprehensive performance bounds for Doppler sensing using the CSI-ratio model. By applying a Taylor series expansion to the non-linear CSI-ratio model under high-SNR conditions, the authors derived a closed-form CRB for Doppler frequency estimation.

Simplified approximations of this CRB reveal how physical parameters impact sensing performance. For instance, the paper identifies the "unobservable angle": if the dynamic target's angle of arrival aligns too closely with the "equivalent" angle of all static objects, the CSI-ratio becomes insensitive, and the CRB shoots to infinity. This highlights a fundamental geometric limitation of ratio-based sensing.

Waveform Optimization Strategies

Building on the derived CRB, the paper proposes novel waveform optimization strategies by intelligently selecting OFDM symbol indices to minimize interference. The authors identify two primary regimes:

  • Noise-limited: When the target is moving fast and far from static clutter, the optimal strategy is to pick symbols at the very beginning and end of the available time window to maximize the observation baseline.
  • Interference-limited: When the target is slow-moving (low Doppler), it gets "buried" in the leakage from static objects. The authors developed an iterative perturbation algorithm to design a symbol pattern that narrows the Doppler mainlobe and suppresses sidelobes, effectively "cleaning" the area around the target.
Figure 4: Structure of the optimized OFDM symbol pattern for enhanced Doppler sensing.

Results and Validation

The proposed methods were validated through extensive numerical simulations modeled after 5G NR (New Radio) standards (3 GHz carrier, 125 μs symbol interval). The derived CRB was compared against a Maximum-Likelihood Estimator (MLE) to ensure the theoretical bounds accurately predict real-world performance.

Figure 5: Validation of the derived CRB against the Maximum-Likelihood Estimator (MLE) for Doppler frequency estimation.

As shown in Figure 5, the theoretical CRB perfectly matches the MLE performance at SNRs above approximately 22.5 dB. Furthermore, the proposed interference-limited waveform design significantly reduces the CRB for targets moving at speeds between 0.5 m/s and 5 m/s. In one scenario, the "observable velocity range" was nearly doubled compared to standard symbol selection.

Conclusion

This work provides a theoretical foundation for CSI-ratio based Doppler sensing in bi-static ISAC. The derived CRB and subsequent waveform optimization strategies offer a path toward high-precision sensing even in the presence of clock asynchronism and static clutter. Future work will explore multi-target environments and hardware-constrained implementations in live 5G networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Bi-static sensing is crucial for exploring the potential of networked sensing capabilities in integrated sensing and communications (ISAC). However, it suffers from the challenging clock asynchronism issue. Channel state information (CSI) ratio-based sensing is an effective means to address the issue. Its performance bounds, particular for Doppler sensing, have not been fully understood yet. This work endeavors to fill the research gap. Focusing on a single dynamic path in high-SNR scenarios, we derive the closed-form Cramér-Rao bounds (CRB). Then, through analyzing the mutual interference between dynamic and static paths, we simplify the CRB results by deriving close approximations, further unveiling new insights of the impact of numerous physical parameters on Doppler sensing. Moreover, utilizing the new CRB and analyses, we propose novel waveform optimization strategies for noise- and interference-limited sensing scenarios, which are also empowered by closed-form and efficient solutions. Extensive simulation results are provided to validate the preciseness of the derived CRB results and analyses, with the aid of the maximum-likelihood estimator. The results also demonstrate the substantial enhanced Doppler sensing accuracy and the sensing capabilities for low-speed target achieved by the proposed waveform design.
BibTeX
@article{hu2024performance,
  author = {Yanmo Hu and Kai Wu and J. Andrew Zhang and Weibo Deng and Y. Jay Guo},
  title = {{Performance Bounds and Optimization for CSI-Ratio-Based Bi-Static Doppler Sensing in ISAC Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications},
  year = {2024},
}
Figure