Performance Analysis of UAV-Assisted Hybrid FSO/RF Communication Systems under Various Weather Conditions

Yan Wu, Dejin Kong, Qian Wang, Gang Li2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the performance of a novel UAV-assisted hybrid Free Space Optical (FSO) and Radio Frequency (RF) communication system designed for enhanced reliability and coverage. By analyzing the system's Bit Error Rate (BER) and outage probability under various weather conditions, modulation schemes, and system configurations, the authors demonstrate that the UAV-assisted approach significantly outperforms traditional hybrid FSO/RF links, especially in adverse weather.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional wireless communication systems are struggling to keep up with the ever-increasing demand for data, particularly with the rise of applications like VR and interactive gaming. While Free Space Optical (FSO) communication offers high capacity and security, its performance is severely hampered by atmospheric conditions like fog, rain, and turbulence. Radio Frequency (RF) communication, on the other hand, is more robust to weather but has lower capacity. Hybrid FSO/RF systems aim to combine the strengths of both, but extending their coverage and reliability, especially in dynamic environments, remains a challenge. This paper addresses this by proposing and analyzing a multi-hop, UAV-assisted hybrid FSO/RF system, which leverages the mobility and flexibility of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) to overcome the limitations of ground-based systems and improve overall communication performance.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the mathematical modeling and simulation of a UAV-assisted multi-hop parallel hybrid FSO/RF communication system. The FSO sub-link is modeled using the Exponentiated Weibull turbulence model, while the RF sub-link employs the Nakagami-m fading model. The system incorporates a selective combination scheme at each hop to choose the best performing sub-link (FSO or RF). The analysis considers various factors, including:

  • Modulation Schemes: The paper evaluates the impact of different binary modulation schemes (CBPSK, DBPSK, CBFSK, NBFSK) on BER.
  • Weather Conditions: The performance is analyzed under clear air, haze, light fog, and light rain.
  • Pointing Errors (PE): The study investigates the system's resilience to misalignment between the transmitter and receiver.
  • Aperture Averaging: The effect of receiver aperture size on performance is examined.
  • Relay Structures: Different configurations of UAV relays (number of hops and number of relays per hop) are analyzed.

The authors derive mathematical expressions for the end-to-end Bit Error Rate (BER) and outage probability, which are then validated through numerical simulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The performance evaluation relies on simulated data generated based on the derived mathematical models and parameters provided in existing literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • UAVs as Game Changers: The UAV-assisted multi-hop architecture significantly enhances communication performance and coverage compared to traditional hybrid FSO/RF direct links, especially under challenging atmospheric conditions.
  • Weather Matters (A Lot): Light fog and haze have the most detrimental impact on system performance, while clear air conditions yield the best results. Light rain affects both FSO and RF links, but the hybrid system still offers a considerable advantage.
  • Modulation Choice is Crucial: Coherent binary phase shift keying (CBPSK) generally offers the best BER performance across various conditions, highlighting the advantage of coherent modulation in environments with significant signal attenuation and distortion.
  • Aperture Averaging is Beneficial: Larger receiver apertures in the FSO sub-link lead to improved BER and outage probability due to the aperture averaging effect, which mitigates the impact of turbulence.
  • Relay Structure Optimization: The number of transmission paths (N) positively impacts performance by increasing diversity gain, while the number of hops per path (M) can lead to accumulated errors if not carefully managed.
  • Pointing Errors are a Significant Factor: While the UAV-assisted system shows resilience, pointing errors still degrade performance, and their impact is more pronounced at lower transmitted powers.

Key Results

  • The UAV-assisted hybrid system consistently demonstrates superior BER and outage probability compared to hybrid FSO/RF direct links across all tested weather conditions.
  • Under light fog and haze, the BER of the hybrid direct link can be significantly higher than under clear air or light rain.
  • Increasing the receiver aperture diameter from 10 cm to 20 cm leads to a noticeable improvement in BER.
  • The RF fading parameter ($m_{x,y}$) plays a crucial role; a larger value of $m_{x,y}$ results in a lower BER and outage probability.
  • For the UAV-assisted system, increasing the number of transmission paths (e.g., from N=1 to N=5) generally improves performance, while increasing the number of hops per path (e.g., from M=2 to M=5) can sometimes degrade it due to error accumulation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Channel Models: While the Exponentiated Weibull and Nakagami-m models are used, real-world atmospheric conditions can be more complex and may require more sophisticated models.
  • Parameter Selection: The study relies on parameters from existing literature. Further research could explore optimal parameter selection for specific deployment scenarios.
  • Focus on Specific Modulation: While CBPSK is identified as optimal, a broader analysis of other advanced modulation schemes could be beneficial.
  • UAV Mobility and Dynamics: The current analysis assumes static UAV positions. Future work could investigate the impact of dynamic UAV movement and its effect on link performance.
  • Energy Efficiency: The paper focuses on performance metrics like BER and outage probability. Future research could incorporate energy efficiency considerations for UAV-assisted systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wu2023performance,
  author = {Yan Wu and Dejin Kong and Qian Wang and Gang Li},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of UAV-Assisted Hybrid FSO/RF Communication Systems under Various Weather Conditions}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23177638},
}
Figure