Performance Analysis of the Combined Operation of Interconnected-BCCHP Microgrids in China

Zhao Luo, Wei Gu, Yong Sun, Xiang Yin, Yi‐Yuan Tang, Xiaodong YuanSustainability 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the benefits of interconnecting building-level combined cooling, heating, and power (BCCHP) microgrids in China. By simulating the operation of three interconnected BCCHP microgrids, the study demonstrates significant improvements in economic efficiency, reduced primary energy consumption (PEC), and lower carbon dioxide emissions (CDE) compared to isolated microgrids.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for energy and the growing concern over carbon emissions have led to a global focus on the "Internet of Energy" and smart grid technologies. In China, buildings are a significant source of energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions. Combined Cooling, Heating, and Power (CCHP) systems, and specifically Building CCHP (BCCHP) microgrids, offer a promising solution for improving energy efficiency and reducing environmental impact. However, most existing studies focus on single buildings. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the synergistic benefits of interconnecting multiple BCCHP microgrids within a localized area, investigating how this interconnectedness can lead to enhanced economic and environmental performance by leveraging complementary energy demands and supply capabilities.

Methods

The authors propose a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) economic dispatching model to analyze the performance of interconnected BCCHP (IBCCHP) microgrids. This model incorporates piecewise linear efficiency curves for various components, allowing for the accurate representation of their performance across different operating loads. The study compares the performance of IBCCHP microgrids against non-interconnected BCCHP (NBCCHP) microgrids across four operational modes, reflecting different government subsidy policies and grid interaction strategies. Key performance indicators evaluated include operational cost, primary energy consumption (PEC), and carbon dioxide emissions (CDE). A sensitivity analysis is also conducted to examine the impact of electricity and natural gas prices on operational costs.

Datasets

The study utilizes hourly energy demand data for one year, simulated using the EnergyPlus software for three distinct building types: an office area, a food service area, and a library area in Shanghai, China. The paper also references various parameters and equipment capacities derived from existing literature and specific Chinese energy market data, such as peak-valley electricity prices and natural gas prices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interconnection is Key: The core finding is that interconnecting BCCHP microgrids leads to substantial improvements in economic and environmental performance compared to isolated systems. This highlights the potential of a localized "energy internet" within urban environments.
  • Synergistic Benefits: The interconnectedness allows microgrids to share energy, balancing complementary loads and optimizing resource utilization. This leads to better overall system efficiency and reduced reliance on external energy sources.
  • Mode 3 and 4 Shine: Operational modes that allow for selling surplus electricity back to the main grid (Mode 3 and 4) demonstrate the most significant economic and environmental benefits. This suggests that policies encouraging grid interaction and energy export are crucial for maximizing the advantages of IBCCHP microgrids.
  • Battery Lifespan Improvement: Interconnection also leads to a reduced annual charge/discharge cycle number for batteries, thereby improving their overall lifetime.
  • Policy Implications: The sensitivity analysis underscores the importance of electricity and natural gas prices. The findings can inform policy decisions regarding subsidies, electricity tariffs, and the promotion of interconnected microgrid development in China.

Key Results

  • Reduced Costs and Emissions: Comparing IBCCHP microgrids to NBCCHP microgrids, the study found significant reductions across all operational modes. For instance, in Mode 1, annual operation cost was reduced by 1.7 × 10⁵ Yuan, CDE by 1.9 × 10⁵ kg, and PEC by 3 × 10⁴ kWh. Mode 3 showed the best overall performance.
  • Improved Battery Life: The annual charge/discharge cycle number for batteries was consistently lower in IBCCHP microgrids compared to NBCCHP microgrids, indicating an extended battery lifespan.
  • Sensitivity to Prices: The operational cost saving of IBCCHP microgrids is sensitive to the selling electricity price and natural gas price, with higher selling prices generally leading to lower cost savings, but the relationship is complex and depends on the specific mode and gas price.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Assumptions: The study makes several simplifying assumptions, including neglecting transmission losses for power exchange and heat exchange, and assuming instantaneous power exchange.
  • Focus on Specific Location: The case study is based on three buildings in Shanghai, China. While representative, the findings might vary in different climatic zones or with different building types and load profiles.
  • Benefit Assignment: The paper notes that current policies do not fully support benefit assignment for interconnected BCCHP microgrids, suggesting this as an area for future policy development.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the presented model can be a powerful tool for the fundamental design of BCCHP microgrids, especially when combined with other elements like benefit assignment mechanisms. Further research could explore more complex scenarios, dynamic pricing, and the integration of a wider range of renewable energy sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

From the Internet of Energy point of view, adjacent building combined cooling, heating and power with microgrids (BCCHP microgrids) should be interconnected, which will generate better benefits, both economically and environmentally, from scarce energy resources through intelligent coordination. The interconnected-BCCHP (IBCCHP) microgrids will not only support energy with each other but also bring better benefits compared to the non-interconnected-BCCHP (NBCCHP) microgrids. A mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) economic dispatching approach incorporating piecewise linear efficiency curves model is proposed to compares the performance of IBCCHP microgrids and NBCCHP microgrids. Three buildings with CCHP microgrids in Shanghai are studied as an example, and simulation results are presented to demonstrate that the primary energy consumption (PEC), the carbon dioxide emissions (CDE) and the operation cost of the proposed IBCCHP microgrids are better than the NBCCHP microgrids, and the overall lifetime of the complete battery is improved. Furthermore, a sensitivity analysis is presented to provide various policy recommendations to promote the interconnection among buildings with the change of electricity prices and gas prices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2016performance,
  author = {Zhao Luo and Wei Gu and Yong Sun and Xiang Yin and Yi‐Yuan Tang and Xiaodong Yuan},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of the Combined Operation of Interconnected-BCCHP Microgrids in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/su8100977},
}
Figure