Performance Analysis of Large Intelligent Surfaces (LISs): Asymptotic Data Rate and Channel Hardening Effects

Minchae Jung, Walid Saad, Young Rok Jang, Gyuyeol Kong, Sooyong ChoiIEEE Trans. Wireless Communications 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper presents a theoretical framework for analyzing the performance of Large Intelligent Surfaces (LISs) in wireless communication. By employing asymptotic analysis, the authors demonstrate that LISs can achieve data rates comparable to massive MIMO systems with improved reliability and significantly reduced physical footprint, especially as the number of antennas increases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding the practical performance of Large Intelligent Surfaces (LISs) in wireless communication. While LISs promise to revolutionize connectivity by leveraging existing structures, their performance benefits under realistic conditions—such as imperfect channel estimation, hardware impairments, and complex interference environments—remain largely unquantified. Existing research often simplifies these aspects, leaving a gap in our understanding of how LISs truly perform and how they compare to established technologies like massive MIMO.

Methods

The core of this paper is an asymptotic analysis of the uplink data rate for an LIS-based system. This involves:

  • Modeling a Practical LIS Environment: The system considers LISs divided into smaller "LIS units," each with a finite number of antennas. It accounts for realistic limitations like hardware impairments (analog imperfections, quantization errors), imperfect channel estimation, and spatially correlated Rician fading for interference channels.
  • Asymptotic Analysis: The authors derive mathematical expressions for the data rate and its statistical properties (mean and variance) as the number of antennas (M) and devices (K) tend towards infinity. This approach allows for analytical tractability and provides insights into the system's behavior under extreme scaling.
  • Channel Hardening Effect Analysis: The paper investigates the "channel hardening effect," a phenomenon where the fluctuations in the channel's mutual information decrease as the number of antennas increases. This is analyzed by examining the variance of the data rate.
  • Performance Bound Derivation: An asymptotic performance bound for the ergodic rate is derived, providing a theoretical limit for the system's achievable data rate.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation relies on Monte Carlo simulations with parameters defined in Table I.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LISs as a Viable Alternative to Massive MIMO: The analysis suggests LISs can offer comparable data rates to massive MIMO, but with a significant advantage in terms of physical space requirements.
  • Channel Hardening is Key: The channel hardening effect, where channel fluctuations diminish with more antennas, is shown to be prominent in LIS systems. This leads to a more deterministic and reliable data rate.
  • Interference Management: While LOS interference remains a factor, the impact of hardware impairments, noise, and NLOS interference becomes negligible as the number of antennas increases, simplifying the system's overall performance.
  • Scalability Benefits: The asymptotic analysis clearly demonstrates that as the number of antennas (M) grows, the system's performance improves, and its behavior becomes more predictable.

Key Results

  • Asymptotic Agreement: The derived analytical results closely match the exact mutual information as the number of antennas and devices increase, validating the asymptotic approach.
  • Negligible Impairments: With a large number of antennas, hardware impairments, noise, estimation errors, and NLOS interference become negligible compared to LOS interference.
  • Performance Bound Convergence: The ergodic rate of an LIS system converges to the derived asymptotic bound as the number of antennas increases.
  • Simulation Validation: Simulation results confirm the theoretical findings, showing that LISs can achieve performance comparable to massive MIMO with improved reliability and a significantly smaller footprint. For instance, in Fig. 2, the ergodic rate converges to the asymptotic bound as M increases, and in Fig. 6, LIS performance is shown to be higher than massive MIMO for practical M values.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized LOS for Desired Channel: The paper models the desired channel as a perfect Line-of-Sight (LOS) path, which is a simplification. While it acknowledges that NLOS paths can exist, their impact is considered negligible for the desired signal as M increases.
  • LIS Unit Overlap: While the paper assumes non-overlapping LIS units for simplicity, it acknowledges that in practice, LIS units might overlap, potentially degrading performance. The authors suggest resource allocation and scheduling schemes to mitigate this.
  • Specific Interference Modeling: The interference channels are modeled as spatially correlated Rician fading. While this is more realistic than independent fading, further research could explore other interference models.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their asymptotic analyses are invaluable for predicting LIS performance in system-level simulations and prototype development. Future work could focus on optimizing LIS unit size (L) and exploring more complex deployment scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

The concept of a large intelligent surface (LIS) has recently emerged as a promising wireless communication paradigm that can exploit the entire surface of man-made structures for transmitting and receiving information. An LIS is expected to go beyond massive multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) system, insofar as the desired channel can be modeled as a perfect line-of-sight. To understand the fundamental performance benefits, it is imperative to analyze its achievable data rate, under practical LIS environments and limitations. In this paper, an asymptotic analysis of the uplink data rate in an LIS-based large antenna-array system is presented. In particular, the asymptotic LIS rate is derived in a practical wireless environment where the estimated channel on LIS is subject to estimation errors, interference channels are spatially correlated Rician fading channels, and the LIS experiences hardware impairments. Moreover, the occurrence of the channel hardening effect is analyzed and the performance bound is asymptotically derived for the considered LIS system. The analytical asymptotic results are then shown to be in close agreement with the exact mutual information as the number of antennas and devices increase without bounds. Moreover, the derived ergodic rates show that hardware impairments, noise, and interference from estimation errors and the non-line-of-sight path become negligible as the number of antennas increases. Simulation results show that an LIS can achieve a performance that is comparable to conventional massive MIMO with improved reliability and a significantly reduced area for antenna deployment.
BibTeX
@article{jung2020performance,
  author = {Minchae Jung and Walid Saad and Young Rok Jang and Gyuyeol Kong and Sooyong Choi},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of Large Intelligent Surfaces (LISs): Asymptotic Data Rate and Channel Hardening Effects}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=LPFjHTs2QT},
}
Figure