Performance Analysis of Global Navigation Satellite System Signal Acquisition Aided by Different Grade Inertial Navigation System under Highly Dynamic Conditions

Chunxi Zhang, Xianmu Li, Shuang Gao, Tie Lin, Lu WangSensors 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how different grades of Inertial Navigation Systems (INS) affect the performance of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) signal acquisition, especially under highly dynamic conditions. The authors demonstrate that using INS significantly reduces the search space for Doppler frequency and code phase, leading to faster and more reliable signal acquisition, with higher-grade INS providing better accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Acquiring GNSS signals, particularly in environments with high dynamics (like missiles or aircraft), is challenging due to large Doppler frequency shifts. These shifts expand the search range for signal parameters, increasing acquisition time and reducing reliability. While INS-aided acquisition is known to help, the precise impact of different INS quality levels on Doppler and code phase estimation errors, and consequently on acquisition performance under these demanding conditions, has not been thoroughly analyzed. This paper aims to fill this gap by theoretically deriving the relationships between INS accuracy and estimation errors, and experimentally verifying these findings with various INS grades.

Methods

The core of the paper involves:

  • Theoretical Derivation: The authors derive mathematical models to quantify the relationship between INS velocity and position errors and the resulting Doppler shift and code phase estimation errors. This is a key contribution, as previous work had not fully detailed these connections.
  • Simulation Platform: A software simulation platform was developed, incorporating a trajectory generator for high-dynamic scenarios, a dual-mode GNSS signal simulator (for GPS and BeiDou), an RF frontend model, and an INS computation module.
  • INS Simulation: Different grades of INS (MEMS, Civil, Tactical, Inertial) were simulated by introducing varying levels of constant bias, bias stability, and random walk errors to gyro and accelerometer data.
  • Acquisition Scheme: The paper utilizes a software receiver with a parallel code phase search method for INS-aided acquisition. The INS provides estimated Doppler frequency and code phase, which are used to narrow down the search space.
  • Experimental Verification: The simulation platform was used to test the INS-aided acquisition performance under a designed high-dynamic trajectory, comparing the results across the different INS grades.

Datasets

The paper does not use external datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it relies on:

  • Simulated Trajectories: A highly dynamic trajectory was designed and simulated, mimicking scenarios like those experienced by missiles and aircraft, including acceleration, uniform motion, turning, and climbing.
  • Simulated GNSS Signals: GPS and BeiDou signals were simulated using a dual-mode GNSS signal simulator.
  • Simulated INS Data: Data from different grades of INS were generated by simulating realistic error models (bias, bias stability, random walk) applied to true motion data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • INS Accuracy is Paramount: The quality of the INS directly dictates the accuracy of Doppler and code phase estimations. Higher-grade INS leads to smaller estimation errors.
  • Reduced Search Space is Key: By providing accurate estimates of Doppler shift and code phase, INS significantly narrows the search range for these parameters. This is crucial for fast acquisition in dynamic environments.
  • Quantitative Relationship Established: The paper provides the first detailed theoretical derivation and experimental curves showing the direct relationship between INS accuracy and Doppler/code phase estimation errors.
  • MEMS INS Viability: Even lower-cost MEMS-grade INS, when used in an aided acquisition scheme, can provide significant improvements in acquisition time and reliability compared to unaided acquisition, making them a practical choice for deeply coupled systems.
  • High Dynamics Magnify Errors: The impact of INS errors is more pronounced under high dynamic conditions due to the larger Doppler shifts and potential for greater position/velocity drift.

Key Results

  • Reduced Acquisition Time: INS-aided acquisition reduced the acquisition time from 12.87s (no INS) to 1.85s for all tested INS grades (MEMS, Civil, Tactical, Inertial) in the simulated high-dynamic scenario.
  • Error Reduction with INS Quality: The maximum Doppler shift estimation errors decreased significantly with improved INS quality. For example, the error for MEMS grade INS was around 200 Hz, while for Inertial grade INS it was less than 0.4 Hz. Similarly, code phase estimation errors showed a tenfold reduction for each tenfold improvement in INS accuracy.
  • Search Space Reduction: The frequency search range was reduced from ±5 KHz (no INS) to ±500 Hz (INS-assisted), and the code phase search space was reduced from 0.5 chips to 0.5 chips (though the number of search cells was drastically reduced).
  • MEMS INS Sufficiency: The study suggests that a MEMS-grade INS can offer comparable acquisition performance improvements to higher-grade INS in the simulated scenario, making it a cost-effective option.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-Based: The results are based on a software simulation platform. While comprehensive, real-world testing with actual hardware would be the next step to validate these findings.
  • Specific Scenario: The analysis focuses on a specific high-dynamic trajectory. Further research could explore a wider range of dynamic scenarios and environmental conditions (e.g., jamming, multipath).
  • INS Error Modeling: While the paper uses standard INS error models, more complex error behaviors or sensor failures could be investigated.
  • Deeply Coupled Integration: The paper hints at the suitability of MEMS INS for deeply coupled integration but doesn't delve into the full implications of this integration architecture beyond acquisition.

The authors suggest that a suitable INS can be chosen based on the required accuracy for Doppler frequency shift and code phase estimation, implying that future work could focus on optimizing INS selection for specific applications.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2017performance,
  author = {Chunxi Zhang and Xianmu Li and Shuang Gao and Tie Lin and Lu Wang},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of Global Navigation Satellite System Signal Acquisition Aided by Different Grade Inertial Navigation System under Highly Dynamic Conditions}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17050980},
}
Figure