Performance analysis of cooperative cognitive MIMO multiuser downlink transmission with perfect and imperfect CSI over Rayleigh fading channels

Xiangdong Jia, Dan Wang, Xiaochao Dang, Longxiang Yang, Hongbo ZhuEURASIP 2015 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, a comprehensive comparison analysis in terms of outage probability and average symbol error ratio (SER) is presented for cooperative cognitive multiple-input and multiple-output (CC-MIMO) multiuser systems with amplify-and-forward (AF) protocol. Specially, we consider two scenarios where the CC-MIMO multiuser systems have the perfect and imperfect channel state information (CSI). The CC-MIMO multiuser systems consist of one multi-antenna source, one single-antenna relay, and multiple multi-antenna destinations. At the secondary source and destinations, the maximal ratio transmission (MRT) and maximal ratio combining (MRC) are employed, respectively. For such CC-MIMO multiuser systems, we first obtain the exact closed-form expressions of outage probability under the two cases where the CC-MIMO multiuser systems have the perfect and imperfect CSI. Then, to reduce the implementation complexity, the tight lower bounds of outage probability and average SER are derived. Finally, to obtain insight, by using the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) approximation, the asymptotic estimations of outage probability are achieved. The numerical results show that the derivations are agreed with the simulations, which validate our derivations. At the same time, the results show that, for the systems without perfect CSI, the achievable diversity order reduces to one, regardless of the number of antennas at the cognitive source and destinations as well as the number of the cognitive destinations. Nevertheless, these key parameters affect the coding gain of the CC-MIMO multiuser systems. When the systems have the perfect CSI (or without feedback delay), the achievable diversity gain is determined by the minimum between the number of source’s antennas and the product of the number of destinations and the number of destination’s antennas. For the effect of PU’s parameters, our results indicate that primary systems only affect the coding gain but not the diversity gain.

Introduction

As wireless demand continues to grow, spectrum scarcity has become a critical bottleneck. Cognitive Radio (CR) addresses this by allowing "Secondary Users" (SUs) to borrow spectrum from "Primary Users" (PUs), provided they do not exceed interference limits. To enhance secondary link reliability, researchers often combine MIMO (multiple antennas) with Cooperative Relaying.

However, most theoretical models assume the transmitter has Perfect Channel State Information (CSI). In practice, feedback delays or time-varying fading often lead to "outdated CSI." This paper, published in the EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking, quantifies exactly how much this imperfect CSI hurts system reliability (outage probability) and data integrity (symbol error ratio).

System Model and Methodology

The authors model a downlink scenario consisting of one multi-antenna source ($N_1$ antennas), one single-antenna relay, and multiple multi-antenna destinations ($N_2$ antennas each).

CC-MIMO multiuser downlink model

Key technical components include:

  • Underlay Paradigm: The secondary source and relay must keep their transmit power below a threshold $Q$ to protect the primary receiver (PR).
  • Signal Processing: The system employs Maximal Ratio Transmission (MRT) at the source and Maximal Ratio Combining (MRC) at the destinations to maximize the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR).
  • Amplify-and-Forward (AF): The relay boosts the received signal and forwards it without decoding.
  • Mathematical Analysis: The authors derived exact closed-form expressions for outage probability and Symbol Error Ratio (SER) using Rayleigh fading statistics, validated by Monte Carlo simulations.

Key Insights: The Diversity Collapse

The most significant finding is that imperfect CSI acts as a fundamental performance limit.

  • Diversity Order Collapse: In a perfect world, adding more antennas or users increases the "diversity order" (the rate at which the error rate drops as power increases). With imperfect CSI, that slope flattens to a diversity order of one, regardless of hardware complexity.
  • Coding Gain vs. Diversity Gain: While imperfect CSI ruins the diversity order, having more antennas or users still provides "coding gain." This shifts the performance curve to the left (better performance), even if the slope remains shallow.
  • Primary User Independence: Interestingly, the parameters of the Primary User (like their interference threshold $Q$) only affect the coding gain. They do not impact the diversity gain of the secondary system.
  • Bottlenecks: Under perfect CSI, the system's diversity is limited by the minimum of the source-to-relay and relay-to-destination links: $\min(N_1, M \times N_2)$.

Results and Conclusion

Numerical results demonstrate that as the correlation coefficient $\rho$ (a measure of CSI freshness) decreases, the SNR required to maintain performance increases drastically. For example, moving from a correlation of 0.3 to perfect CSI can yield an SNR gain of approximately 9.1 dB.

While the study highlights the severe impact of feedback delay, it also provides a rigorous mathematical framework for designing more robust cognitive networks. Future work may explore multi-antenna relays or alternative protocols like Decode-and-Forward (DF) to further mitigate these real-world constraints.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, a comprehensive comparison analysis in terms of outage probability and average symbol error ratio (SER) is presented for cooperative cognitive multiple-input and multiple-output (CC-MIMO) multiuser systems with amplify-and-forward (AF) protocol. Specially, we consider two scenarios where the CC-MIMO multiuser systems have the perfect and imperfect channel state information (CSI). The CC-MIMO multiuser systems consist of one multi-antenna source, one single-antenna relay, and multiple multi-antenna destinations. At the secondary source and destinations, the maximal ratio transmission (MRT) and maximal ratio combining (MRC) are employed, respectively. For such CC-MIMO multiuser systems, we first obtain the exact closed-form expressions of outage probability under the two cases where the CC-MIMO multiuser systems have the perfect and imperfect CSI. Then, to reduce the implementation complexity, the tight lower bounds of outage probability and average SER are derived. Finally, to obtain insight, by using the high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) approximation, the asymptotic estimations of outage probability are achieved. The numerical results show that the derivations are agreed with the simulations, which validate our derivations. At the same time, the results show that, for the systems without perfect CSI, the achievable diversity order reduces to one, regardless of the number of antennas at the cognitive source and destinations as well as the number of the cognitive destinations. Nevertheless, these key parameters affect the coding gain of the CC-MIMO multiuser systems. When the systems have the perfect CSI (or without feedback delay), the achievable diversity gain is determined by the minimum between the number of source’s antennas and the product of the number of destinations and the number of destination’s antennas. For the effect of PU’s parameters, our results indicate that primary systems only affect the coding gain but not the diversity gain.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jia2015performance,
  author = {Xiangdong Jia and Dan Wang and Xiaochao Dang and Longxiang Yang and Hongbo Zhu},
  title = {{Performance analysis of cooperative cognitive MIMO multiuser downlink transmission with perfect and imperfect CSI over Rayleigh fading channels}},
  booktitle = {EURASIP},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1186/s13638-015-0431-1},
}
Figure