Performance Analysis and Discussion on the Thermoelectric Element Footprint for PV–TE Maximum Power Generation

Guiqiang Li, Xudong Zhao, Yi Jin, Xiao Chen, Jie Ji, Samson ShittuJournal of Electronic Materials 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Geometrical optimisation is a valuable way to improve the efficiency of a thermoelectric element (TE). In a hybrid photovoltaic-thermoelectric (PV-TE) system, the photovoltaic (PV) and thermoelectric (TE) components have a relatively complex relationship; their individual effects mean that geometrical optimisation of the TE element alone may not be sufficient to optimize the entire PV–TE hybrid system. In this paper, we introduce a parametric optimisation of the geometry of the thermoelectric element footprint for a PV–TE system. A uni-couple TE model was built for the PV–TE using the finite element method and temperature-dependent thermoelectric material properties. Two types of PV cells were investigated in this paper and the performance of PV–TE with different lengths of TE elements and different footprint areas was analysed. The outcome showed that no matter the TE element's length and the footprint areas, the maximum power output occurs when $A_n/A_p = 1$. This finding is useful, as it provides a reference whenever PV–TE optimisation is investigated.

Introduction: The PV–TE Design Challenge

Hybrid PV–TE systems aim to harvest the full solar spectrum by using a photovoltaic cell to convert light into electricity and a thermoelectric (TE) device to capture the "waste" heat from the PV cell. However, designing these systems is a balancing act.

If the TE element is too thermally resistive (e.g., very long legs), it creates a large temperature difference that boosts TE power but causes the PV cell to overheat, slashing its efficiency. Conversely, if the TE element is too thermally conductive, the PV cell stays cool, but the TE device generates almost no power. Previous research on standalone TE generators suggested that because n-type and p-type materials have different properties, their footprint areas should be different. This paper investigates whether that logic holds true when the TE device is coupled with a PV cell.

Methodology and Modeling

The authors employed a Finite Element Method (FEM) approach using COMSOL Multiphysics to simulate a "uni-couple" PV–TE model.

Schematic of the hybrid PV-TE uni-couple model showing the layered structure from the PV cell to the cooling base.

Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • Temperature-Dependent Properties: Unlike many simplified models, this study accounted for the fact that electrical resistivity, thermal conductivity, and the Seebeck coefficient of Bismuth Telluride ($Bi_2Te_3$) change with temperature.
  • Parametric Sweep: They varied the leg lengths (5 mm, 10 mm, 15 mm), total footprint areas, and the ratio of n-type to p-type area ($A_n/A_p$).
  • Dual PV Scenarios: They tested two types of PV cells: Cell_1 (10% standard efficiency, low temperature sensitivity) and Cell_2 (15% standard efficiency, high temperature sensitivity).
Temperature-dependent thermoelectric properties (electrical conductivity, heat conductivity, and Seebeck coefficient) for p-type and n-type materials used in the simulation.

The study relies on standard physical constants for $Bi_2Te_3$, copper, and PV materials. A simulation matrix of 13 different area ratios (ranging from 0.05 to 20.086) was tested across various geometric configurations.

Key Insights: The "Golden Rule" of Symmetry

The most significant insight is that the interaction between the PV cell and the TE element "normalizes" the optimization. While a standalone TEG might perform better with asymmetric legs, the thermal load from the PV cell makes a symmetric footprint ($A_n/A_p = 1$) the optimal configuration for the total system's power output.

Across all tested leg lengths (5–15 mm) and all footprint areas, the maximum system efficiency consistently occurred when the n-type and p-type areas were equal. This suggests that the PV cell is the "senior partner" in the relationship. Because PV efficiency is much higher than TE efficiency, the system must be optimized to ensure the PV cell doesn't get too hot, even if it means the TE element isn't operating at its own theoretical maximum.

  • The $A_n/A_p = 1$ Constant: Across all tested leg lengths and footprint areas, the maximum system efficiency consistently occurred when the n-type and p-type areas were equal.
  • Efficiency Peaks: For the lower-efficiency PV cell (Cell_1), the hybrid system could reach efficiencies above 12% under specific conditions.
  • Sensitivity Matters: For Cell_2 (the more efficient but temperature-sensitive cell), the researchers found that the hybrid system's efficiency was often lower than the PV cell alone if the TE elements were too long or the footprint was too small, due to excessive heat buildup.
  • Footprint Area Trends: Generally, for a fixed leg length, increasing the total TE footprint area increases the system efficiency up to a point, as it helps manage the PV cell's operating temperature.

Limitations and Future Work

The study looks at a single n-p pair (uni-couple). In reality, TE modules consist of dozens of pairs connected by ceramic plates and solder, which introduce parasitic thermal and electrical resistances not fully captured here. Furthermore, while smaller footprints are more cost-effective, a full techno-economic analysis was not performed. Future work could explore how these geometric "golden rules" shift under high-concentration systems (e.g., 50x or 100x suns) where thermal management becomes even more critical.

Summary updated

Abstract

Geometrical optimisation is a valuable way to improve the efficiency of a thermoelectric element (TE). In a hybrid photovoltaic-thermoelectric (PV-TE) system, the photovoltaic (PV) and thermoelectric (TE) components have a relatively complex relationship; their individual effects mean that geometrical optimisation of the TE element alone may not be sufficient to optimize the entire PV–TE hybrid system. In this paper, we introduce a parametric optimisation of the geometry of the thermoelectric element footprint for a PV–TE system. A uni-couple TE model was built for the PV–TE using the finite element method and temperature-dependent thermoelectric material properties. Two types of PV cells were investigated in this paper and the performance of PV–TE with different lengths of TE elements and different footprint areas was analysed. The outcome showed that no matter the TE element's length and the footprint areas, the maximum power output occurs when An/Ap = 1. This finding is useful, as it provides a reference whenever PV–TE optimisation is investigated.
BibTeX
@article{li2018performance,
  author = {Guiqiang Li and Xudong Zhao and Yi Jin and Xiao Chen and Jie Ji and Samson Shittu},
  title = {{Performance Analysis and Discussion on the Thermoelectric Element Footprint for PV–TE Maximum Power Generation}},
  journal = {Journal of Electronic Materials},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1007/s11664-018-6421-4},
}
Figure