Perforated flexible catheters improve joint fluid aspiration in shoulder cadavers

Andreas Hecker, Manuel Waltenspül, Lukas Ernstbrunner, Reto Sutter, Karl Wieser, Samy BouaichaScientific 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces a novel perforated flexible catheter designed to significantly improve the yield of synovial fluid during shoulder joint aspirations. By comparing this new device against standard needles and a non-perforated flexible catheter in cadaveric shoulders, the researchers demonstrated a substantial increase in aspirated fluid, potentially reducing the rate of insufficient aspirations crucial for accurate diagnosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Arthrocentesis, the process of aspirating fluid from a joint, is a critical diagnostic tool, particularly for identifying infections in shoulder surgery. However, a common challenge in shoulder arthrocentesis, especially when using the standard anterior approach in a supine position, is a high rate of "dry aspirations" – where little to no fluid is obtained. This can hinder accurate diagnosis, as a minimum volume of fluid (at least 2 mL) is required for comprehensive analysis (cell count, crystals, bacterial culture). Existing methods often only retrieve about 50% of the available fluid, making it difficult to obtain sufficient sample volume when synovial fluid is scarce. This paper aims to address this limitation by developing and evaluating a new aspiration device that can maximize fluid retrieval.

Methods

The researchers conducted an experimental study using ten human cadaveric shoulder specimens. They employed a standardized supine position with an anterior approach under fluoroscopic guidance. The glenohumeral joint was sequentially filled with increasing volumes of contrast agent (5, 10, 20, and 30 mL). Four different aspiration devices were tested for each volume: a 20-gauge needle, a 16-gauge needle, a 16-gauge flexible catheter, and a novel 16-gauge perforated flexible catheter. The perforated catheter was custom-made, featuring ten 1.7 mm holes around its tip. Aspirations were performed by inserting the device, attempting to aspirate the maximum possible fluid while slowly withdrawing, and then documenting the volume. The insertion depth of the devices was also measured. Statistical analysis, including Friedman's Two-Way Analysis of Variance, was used to compare the performance of the different devices.

Datasets

The study utilized ten human cadaveric shoulder joint specimens. These specimens were selected to represent normal anatomy, excluding those with significant arthritis, rotator cuff tears, or previous surgery. The contrast agent used (Iopamiro 200) served as a surrogate for synovial fluid for the purpose of aspiration volume measurement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Perforations: The key innovation is the addition of multiple small perforations along the tip of a flexible catheter. This design appears to overcome the limitations of a single-tip opening, which can be easily occluded by synovial tissue, especially when the catheter is positioned deep within the joint.
  • Flexibility Meets Functionality: While a flexible catheter offers advantages in reaching deeper joint recesses (as evidenced by its greater insertion depth), its effectiveness in fluid aspiration is significantly enhanced by the perforations. Without them, the flexible catheter performed poorly, even worse than rigid needles.
  • Clinical Relevance for "Dry Taps": The improved aspiration volume is particularly impactful in scenarios where synovial fluid is scarce. This new technique could significantly reduce the incidence of "dry taps," ensuring that sufficient fluid is obtained for crucial diagnostic tests.
  • Anatomical Considerations: The study highlights how anatomical factors, like the location of fluid in the posterior recess in a supine position, can influence aspiration success. The flexible catheter's ability to navigate these recesses, combined with its perforated design, seems to be a winning combination.

Key Results

The 16-gauge perforated flexible catheter (16GPFC) demonstrated superior performance across most tested volumes:

  • Significant Improvement: The 16GPFC consistently aspirated a significantly higher amount of fluid compared to all other devices when 5, 10, and 20 mL of contrast agent were in the joint (p = 0.002-0.028).
  • High Aspiration Rate: The perforated flexible catheter aspirated between 80-96% of the available fluid.
  • Comparison to Standard Needles: In contrast, the standard 20-gauge needle aspirated only 40-60% of the fluid.
  • Insertion Depth: Flexible catheters (both standard and perforated) could be inserted significantly deeper into the joint (median 123 mm) compared to rigid needles (median 43-49 mm).
  • Fluid Volume: For a 30 mL filling, the 16GPFC was significantly superior to the 16GFC (p = 0.049) and 16GN (p = 0.028).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cadaveric Study: The study was performed on cadavers, which lack the dynamic factors of a live patient, such as muscle contractions, pain, and movement, which can affect aspiration in clinical practice.
  • Ideal Anatomy: Only specimens with normal anatomy were used. Joints with arthritis or rotator cuff tears might yield different results, potentially making aspiration easier due to enlarged joint spaces.
  • Contrast Agent Viscosity: The use of contrast agent, with its potentially different viscosity compared to synovial fluid, might influence aspiration dynamics.
  • Potential Fluid Loss: Although the aspirate was reinjected, a small amount might have been lost in the tissue between aspirations, potentially underestimating the performance of later-tested devices (like the 16GPFC, which was always used last).
  • Availability: The perforated flexible catheter is not commercially available and requires custom manufacturing.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Clinical Trials: A randomized clinical trial is necessary to evaluate the feasibility and clinical efficacy of this new technique in patients.
  • Optimizing Diameter: Further research is needed to determine the optimal diameter of perforated catheters for maximizing aspiration capacity.
  • Exploring Other Positions: While the study focused on the supine position, exploring other patient positions could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

A fluoroscopically controlled anterior approach in supine position is often used for arthrocentesis of the shoulder, but can lead to a high rate of dry aspirations. The aim of this study was to compare the aspiration performance of rigid needles and flexible catheters used with this approach. We hypothesized that a flexible catheter can significantly improve the amount of the obtained fluid. The glenohumeral joint of ten human cadaveric shoulder specimens were sequentially filled with 5, 10, 20 and 30 mL of contrast agent. For each volume the maximum aspirated amount of contrast agent with 4 different aspiration devices (20 gauge needle, 16 gauge needle, 16 gauge flexible catheter and 16 gauge perforated flexible catheter) were compared. All aspirations were done in supine cadaver position from anterior under fluoroscopic control. The aspirated amount of fluid was significantly higher using the 16 gauge perforated flexible catheter (p = 0.002-0.028) compared with all other devices when 5, 10 and 20 mL of contrast agent were in the joint. This perforated flexible catheter aspirated 80-96% of the available fluid while the standard 20 gauge needle aspirated 40-60%. Using a 16 gauge perforated flexible catheter in a supine anterior arthrocentesis technique results in aspiration of most of the fluid in human cadaveric shoulder specimens, while standard needles aspirate only about 50% of it. This can be clinically relevant when there is very little synovial fluid available and might reduce the number of insufficient aspirations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hecker2021perforated,
  author = {Andreas Hecker and Manuel Waltenspül and Lukas Ernstbrunner and Reto Sutter and Karl Wieser and Samy Bouaicha},
  title = {{Perforated flexible catheters improve joint fluid aspiration in shoulder cadavers}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-01613-8},
}
Figure