Perceptions of malaria control and prevention in an era of climate change: a cross-sectional survey among CDC staff in China

Michael Tong, Alana Hansen, Scott Hanson‐Easey, Scott Cameron, Jianjun Xiang, Qiyong Liu, Xiaobo Liu, Yehuan Sun, Philip Weinstein, Gil‐Soo Han, Craig Williams, Peng BiMalaria 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study surveyed Chinese CDC staff about their perceptions of climate change's impact on malaria. Findings reveal widespread concern about climate change and its link to infectious diseases, with staff identifying mosquitoes and imported cases as key challenges to malaria control, alongside climate change itself. The research highlights a need for enhanced training and policy development to address these evolving threats.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Climate change is a significant global challenge, with its impact on infectious diseases, particularly vector-borne ones like malaria, becoming increasingly evident. While malaria incidence has declined in China over past decades, a re-emergence has been observed since 2000, with outbreaks occurring in new areas. Understanding how public health professionals, specifically those on the front lines of disease control in China (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention - CDC staff), perceive these changes and their implications for malaria control is crucial for developing effective adaptation strategies. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by exploring the perceptions of CDC staff regarding climate change, its influence on malaria transmission, and their views on current control and prevention measures.

Methods

The study employed a cross-sectional survey design. A questionnaire was developed based on existing literature on climate-sensitive diseases in China and covered participants' beliefs about climate change, its potential impact on infectious diseases, and their perceptions of disease control and prevention strategies. The questionnaire was translated into Chinese and validated by experts from the China National CDC, with a pilot test conducted to ensure clarity and understanding. The survey was administered to health professionals working in infectious disease control, public health, medical laboratory examination, and emergency response across eleven CDCs in Anhui, Henan, and Yunnan provinces. These provinces were chosen due to their high malaria incidence. Descriptive analysis was used to study the staff's knowledge, attitudes, perceptions, and suggestions. Statistical analysis included Chi-square tests and Fisher's exact tests to assess relationships between demographic variables and perception variables.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected through a questionnaire administered to 557 CDC staff members in China. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation. The questionnaire itself served as the primary data collection instrument.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Widespread Concern: A significant majority of CDC staff (nearly 80%) expressed concern about climate change, with a similar proportion believing their local areas are getting warmer.
  • Climate Change as a Health Threat: Over 90% of participants believed climate change negatively impacts population health, and a substantial majority (over 85%) linked it to increased transmission of infectious and vector-borne diseases, including malaria.
  • Malaria Re-emergence and Contributing Factors: While about half of the staff reported malaria re-emergence in their regions, they identified a complex interplay of factors. High mosquito density and an increase in imported malaria cases were frequently cited as primary risks, alongside climate change itself, poor environmental conditions, and internal migration.
  • Knowledge Gaps: Despite concerns, a notable portion of staff (nearly 70%) felt they lacked a good understanding of climate change, with a strong majority (almost 90%) indicating a need for more information on its health impacts. This was particularly pronounced among female and junior staff.
  • Regional Differences: Perceptions varied slightly across provinces, with Anhui participants being less likely to report malaria re-emergence, potentially due to a significant decrease in reported cases in that province.

Key Results

  • Concern and Warming: 79.8% of CDC staff were concerned or very concerned about climate change. 79.7% believed their local areas were becoming warmer.
  • Impact on Health: 90.3% of participants indicated climate change would have a negative effect on population health.
  • Disease Transmission: 92.6% believed increasing temperatures and precipitation would influence infectious disease transmission, and 86.8% thought climate change would influence vector-borne diseases.
  • Malaria Transmission: 83.9% expected climate change to promote malaria transmission.
  • Risk Factors: The most frequently reported risk factors for malaria were mosquitoes in high-density (25.1%), imported cases (21.9%), and climate change (12.8%).
  • Understanding: Only 31.1% of participants felt they had a good understanding of climate change.
  • Information Needs: 88.7% of participants indicated they needed more information about the health impacts of climate change.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Representativeness: The study involved 11 CDCs, and the results may not be fully representative of all CDC staff in China.
  • Sample Size by Level: The sample size of county-level and prefectural-level CDCs was smaller compared to provincial-level CDCs. Future studies could focus on recruiting more frontline staff.
  • Translation Anomalies: The questionnaire was translated from English to Chinese, and minor translation issues might have occurred.
  • Response Bias: As with any survey, response biases could influence results, with participants potentially over- or underestimating their knowledge and competence.
  • Subjectivity of Terms: The terms "re-emerged" and "in recent years" in the questionnaire could be interpreted subjectively, especially given the decrease in malaria cases between 2007 and 2014.

Future work suggested includes:

  • In-house Training: Promoting in-house training activities to improve staff's knowledge and understanding of climate change and its health impacts.
  • Policy Formulation: Utilizing the findings to inform in-house training guidelines, community health promotion programs, and policies to enhance malaria control and prevention capacity in the face of climate change.
  • Regional Cooperation: Emphasizing the need for regional cooperation, data sharing, and information exchange with neighboring countries for effective malaria control.
  • Further Research: Conducting more relevant research among frontline staff in prefecture and county-level CDCs to assess malaria re-emergence in the context of climate change. Investigating the reasons for differing perceptions between provinces could also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study found most CDC staff endorsed the statement that climate change had a negative impact on infectious disease transmission. Malaria had re-emerged in some areas of China, and most of the staff believed that this can be managed. However, high densities of mosquitoes and the continuous increase in imported cases of malaria in local areas, together with environmental changes are bringing about critical challenges to malaria control in China. This study contributes to an understanding of climate change related perceptions of malaria control and prevention amongst CDC staff. It may help to formulate in-house training guidelines, community health promotion programmes and policies to improve the capacity of malaria control and prevention in the face of climate change in China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tong2017perceptions,
  author = {Michael Tong and Alana Hansen and Scott Hanson‐Easey and Scott Cameron and Jianjun Xiang and Qiyong Liu and Xiaobo Liu and Yehuan Sun and Philip Weinstein and Gil‐Soo Han and Craig Williams and Peng Bi},
  title = {{Perceptions of malaria control and prevention in an era of climate change: a cross-sectional survey among CDC staff in China}},
  booktitle = {Malaria},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1186/s12936-017-1790-3},
}
Figure