Perception and attitude toward online versus traditional anatomy teaching: An internet-based cross-sectional study among Indian medical students during COVID pandemic

Satabdi Sarkar, Anasuya Ghosh, Biswabina Ray, Anirban Dasgupta, Arpita SarkarAsian 2022 · DOI

This study provides a critical look at the "emergency remote teaching" pivot in Indian medical education during the COVID-19 pandemic. While digital tools offered a lifeline for theoretical subjects, the research highlights a massive gap in practical anatomy training, where students overwhelmingly favor the traditional cadaver-based approach over virtual screens.

TL;DR

Indian medical students overwhelmingly prefer traditional, hands-on anatomy teaching over virtual alternatives, with over 90% favoring the lab over the screen. While online platforms were deemed acceptable for visual sub-topics like histology and embryology, significant infrastructure gaps and physical health issues like eye strain remain major barriers to digital medical education.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anatomy is the cornerstone of medical education, traditionally built on the tactile experience of cadaveric dissection and face-to-face demonstrations. When the COVID-19 pandemic forced a sudden transition to digital formats, medical schools had to replace the dissection hall with Zoom calls and recorded videos.

The authors sought to understand if this transition actually worked. They investigated student perceptions of online versus traditional teaching, identified which specific areas of anatomy (e.g., gross anatomy vs. histology) translated best to a digital format, and documented the primary obstacles—both technical and physical—that hindered learning during the lockdown.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study using a pre-tested, semi-structured questionnaire delivered via Google Forms.

  • Participants: 1st-year medical students from various institutions across India.
  • Timeline: Data was collected between August and December 2020.
  • Metrics: A four-point Likert scale (Strongly Agree to Strongly Disagree) was used to gauge perceptions.
  • Analysis: Data was analyzed using Pearson’s Chi-square tests to evaluate differences between groups (e.g., male vs. female, urban vs. rural), with a p-value of <0.05 considered statistically significant.

Datasets

The study relied on a primary dataset of 252 valid student responses (out of 263 total respondents). The cohort was nearly evenly split by gender (124 male, 128 female) and represented a mix of urban (51.58%), suburban (27.2%), and rural/remote (20.63%) residential backgrounds. No external secondary datasets were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Tactile Gap" in Gross Anatomy: Gross anatomy (the study of structures visible to the naked eye) suffered the most online. Only about 2% of students felt gross anatomy was well-suited for virtual learning. The lack of "face-to-face cadaveric study" was cited as a major blow to long-term knowledge retention.
  • Sub-topic Compatibility: Not all anatomy is equal in the digital space. Students found online learning much more acceptable for embryology, histology, and radiological anatomy. These subjects are inherently more visual and "slide-based," making them easier to digest on a screen than the 3D complexity of a human body.
  • The Smartphone Bottleneck: A staggering 79.36% of students used smartphones to attend classes. Trying to identify minute anatomical structures on a 6-inch screen is a massive pedagogical hurdle compared to a full-sized cadaver or a high-resolution lab monitor.
  • The Physical Toll of the "Digital Surge": The shift wasn't just a mental strain; it was physical. Over 34% of students reported physical ailments like headaches and eye pain. This is directly linked to the "screen time explosion": before the pandemic, less than 10% of students spent more than 5 hours a day on screens; after the shift, that number skyrocketed to over 60%.

Key Results

  • Preference: 90%+ of students preferred traditional anatomy teaching.
  • Acceptance: Less than 50% of students actually liked the online anatomy format.
  • Infrastructure: 81.34% of students relied on mobile internet, which often lacked the bandwidth for stable, synchronized video sessions.
  • Barriers: Internet connectivity was the #1 obstacle (42.06%), followed by physical health issues (34.52%).
  • Gender Differences: Male students were significantly more likely to complain about network issues and inappropriate teaching tools, while female students reported higher rates of physical ailments (44.53%) during online classes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Recall Bias: As a cross-sectional study, student responses may have been influenced by their current mood or recent experiences.
  2. Sample Size: While diverse, the sample size is relatively small given the massive population of medical students in India.
  3. Digital Literacy: The study assumes all students had a similar level of comfort with the Google Forms interface.

Future Work: The paper suggests that while "pure" online anatomy isn't the answer, a blended learning model might be. Future curricula could move theoretical or slide-based subjects (histology, embryology) to digital platforms while reserving precious in-person time for the indispensable practice of cadaveric dissection.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated conduction of online medical education in India in both synchronized and asynchronized modes. Before the pandemic, the online teaching had very limited role in anatomy education in India. Aims and Objectives: This study was conducted to know the student’s perceptions and attitudes regarding online versus traditional anatomy teaching, the problems hindering online anatomy learning, and the areas of anatomy students enjoyed in virtual lessons. Materials and Methods: A cross-sectional study was done among the 1st year medical students of various institutions of India based on a questionnaire applied by Google Forms. Relevant information on student’s sociodemographic profile and their perception toward online versus traditional anatomy teaching were obtained. Four-point Likert scale was used for the responses on perception of teaching. Two hundred and fifty-two responses were studied and statistically analyzed. Results: Two hundred students (79.36%)used smartphones and 205 students (81.34%) used mobile internet in online learning. More than 90% of students preferred traditional anatomy teaching whereas less than 50% of students liked online anatomy teaching. In comparison with gross anatomy, students preferred online teaching of embryology, histology, and radiological anatomy. One hundred and six students (42.06%) opined that the internet problems were the major obstacle and 87 students (34.52%) considered the physical problems as main hindrances in online classes.Statistically significant increase in screentime after commencement of online class was seen among study participants. Conclusion: Majority of students preferred (statistically significant) traditional anatomy teaching over online anatomy teaching. Although students enjoyed online learning on selected topics of embryology, histology, and radiological anatomy, the main hindrances encountered in online anatomy classes were internet problems and physical problems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sarkar2022perception,
  author = {Satabdi Sarkar and Anasuya Ghosh and Biswabina Ray and Anirban Dasgupta and Arpita Sarkar},
  title = {{Perception and attitude toward online versus traditional anatomy teaching: An internet-based cross-sectional study among Indian medical students during COVID pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Asian},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3126/ajms.v13i9.44447},
}
Figure