Perceived Community Support, Users’ Interactions, and Value Co-Creation in Online Health Community: The Moderating Effect of Social Exclusion

Wenlong Liu, Xiucheng Fan, Rongrong Ji, Yi JiangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Online health communities (OHCs) struggle with user engagement and retention. This study reveals that perceived community support is crucial for fostering user interactions, which in turn create value and drive continued participation. Notably, social exclusion can amplify the positive impact of community support on health-related discussions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online health communities (OHCs) are valuable platforms for patients to seek and share health information and emotional support. However, like many social media platforms, they face challenges with declining user activity and high attrition rates. Understanding the factors that encourage users to remain active and engaged is critical for the sustainability and effectiveness of these communities. This paper investigates how perceived community support influences user interactions, leading to value co-creation and ultimately continuous participation, while also exploring how social exclusion might moderate these relationships.

Methods

The researchers employed structural equation modeling (SEM) to test their hypotheses. They developed a research model based on organizational support theory and the concept of value co-creation. The model posits that perceived community support influences health-related and general topic interactions. These interactions, in turn, contribute to perceived functional, social, and affective values. These values then influence continuous participation intention. Additionally, the study examined the moderating role of perceived social exclusion on the relationship between community support and user interactions.

Datasets

The study collected data from a specific online health community focused on diabetes, "Sweet Home" (http:bbs.tnbz.com). A survey questionnaire was distributed to members of this community. A total of 319 responses were received, and after discarding incomplete ones, 292 valid samples were used for the final analysis. The demographic characteristics of the participants are detailed in Table 3, indicating a diverse sample in terms of gender, age, education, income, and experience within the OHC.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Community Support is Foundational: The study strongly supports the idea that a supportive online community environment is a key driver for users to engage in interactions. This isn't just about sharing health tips; it's about creating an atmosphere where users feel valued and encouraged.
  • Interactions Create Value: User interactions, whether focused on health topics or more general discussions, are not just conversations; they are active processes of value co-creation. Users gain functional knowledge, build social connections, and experience emotional benefits through these exchanges.
  • Social Exclusion Amplifies Support's Impact (for Health Topics): A particularly interesting finding is how social exclusion plays a role. For users who feel more socially excluded, the positive impact of community support on their willingness to engage in health-related discussions is even stronger. This suggests OHCs can be a vital safe space for those who struggle to discuss their health concerns elsewhere.
  • Value Pathways to Participation: The study highlights different routes through which value translates into continued participation. Functional and affective values directly contribute, while social value plays an indirect role, influencing affective value first.

Key Results

  • Community Support Drives Interactions: Perceived community support significantly and positively influenced both health-related topic interactions (β = 0.573) and general topic interactions (β = 0.377).
  • Interactions Create Value:
    • Health topic interactions positively influenced perceived functional value (β = 0.901) and social value (β = 0.696), but not affective value.
  • General topic interactions positively influenced perceived functional value (β = 0.097), social value (β = 0.149), and affective value (β = 0.115).
  • Value Drives Participation:
    • Functional value (β = 0.527) and affective value (β = 0.212) directly and positively influenced continuous participation intention.
  • Social value indirectly influenced continuous participation intention through affective value (indirect effect β = 0.121).
  • Social Exclusion Moderates Health Interactions: Users with higher perceived social exclusion were more influenced by community support to participate in health topic interactions (β = 0.789 for high SE vs. β = 0.736 for low SE). However, social exclusion did not significantly moderate the relationship between community support and general topic interactions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size and Generalizability: The study acknowledges that the sample size of 292 valid responses, while sufficient for SEM, might not be large enough to fully represent the millions of OHC users. The findings are specific to a diabetic patient community, and future research should collect data from diverse health communities for broader applicability.
  • Moderating Factors: While social exclusion was found to be a moderator, the authors suggest that other factors, such as user roles (poster vs. lurker) or perceived health status, could also play moderating roles and warrant further investigation.
  • Community Type: The study focused on patient-to-patient OHCs. Future research could explore whether community support has similar critical roles in doctor-to-patient communities.
  • Big Data Analysis: The authors suggest leveraging big data techniques to gain deeper insights into user behavior in online health communities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online health communities (OHCs) face the same problem as other social media platforms in terms of decreasing activity and user attrition. Drawing upon organizational support theory, this study explores how perceived community support affects user interactions and value co-creation which in turn influence their continuous participation. OHCs act as both health knowledge-sharing platforms and important social media for patients, and thus, interpersonal interactions in OHCs are categorized into health-related and general topic interactions. Considering the identity of patients, this study also examines the moderating effect of user-perceived social exclusion on the relationship between community support and user interaction. A total of 292 valid samples from a diabetic patient community in China were used to examine the proposed hypotheses through structural equation modeling. The results show that: (1) Community support has a positive effect on health topic and general topic interactions; (2) both types of interactions have significant positive effects on users' perceived functional and social values, while general topic interaction is also related positively to users' perceived affective value; (3) perceived functional value can result directly in continuous participation, while perceived social value contributes indirectly to continuous participation intention through perceived affective value; and (4) users perceived higher social exclusion are more influenced by community support to participate in health topic interactions than those who perceived lower social exclusion, while no significant difference in general topic interactions between two groups. The results of this study can provide implications for both researchers and practitioners.
BibTeX
@article{liu2019perceived,
  author = {Wenlong Liu and Xiucheng Fan and Rongrong Ji and Yi Jiang},
  title = {{Perceived Community Support, Users’ Interactions, and Value Co-Creation in Online Health Community: The Moderating Effect of Social Exclusion}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph17010204},
}
Figure