Per un'identificazione del sarcofago a rilievo del sepolcreto scaligero di Verona

Peter SeilerheiDOK 2015 · DOI

Introduction: The Mystery of the Relief Sarcophagus

The Scaliger tombs (Arche scaligere) in Verona stand as some of the most significant achievements of Gothic funerary sculpture. While the monumental equestrian tombs of the dynasty are well-documented, the identity of the occupants in the smaller, non-monumental sarcophagi has long been a subject of scholarly dispute. Peter Seiler’s research focuses on the so-called "relief sarcophagus"—the only one in the complex featuring figurative carvings—which has been attributed to Alberto I della Scala (d. 1301) for over a century. Seiler argues that this attribution is a 19th-century construct lacking historical rigor, proposing instead that the tomb was intended for the family’s most illustrious member, Cangrande I.

Heraldry as a Chronological Marker

Seiler’s primary evidence rests on the evolution of Scaliger heraldry. The sarcophagus prominently features the imperial eagle perched atop the traditional ladder (scala). Historical records, including the Historia Augusta by Albertino Mussato, indicate that the Della Scala family only adopted the imperial eagle after 1311, when Alboino and Cangrande I were appointed Imperial Vicars by Emperor Henry VII.

This chronological marker effectively disqualifies Alberto I, who died a decade before the symbol was granted. While some scholars point to Dante Alighieri’s Paradiso (XVII, 70-72), where the "Great Lombard" is associated with the eagle as early as 1303, Seiler suggests Dante was either using the eagle as a broader Ghibelline metaphor or projecting later heraldic honors back onto his early patron to suit the poem's prophetic structure. In the context of official funerary art, the eagle-on-ladder stemma serves as a terminus post quem of 1311.

The Stylistic Shift: From Archaic to Giottesque

Beyond heraldry, the stylistic execution of the reliefs points toward a later date. The figures on the sarcophagus exhibit "paragiottesque" qualities—heavy, blocky forms and voluminous drapery—that contrast sharply with the flatter, more archaic styles of the late 13th century. By comparing the relief to dated Veronese monuments, such as the Dussaimi tomb (post-1307) and the Pelacani tomb (1327), Seiler places the relief sarcophagus firmly in the artistic milieu of the 1320s rather than the turn of the century. This stylistic alignment suggests the workshop was influenced by the innovations of Giotto, which were permeating Northern Italy during Cangrande's reign.

The Hagiographic Calendar: A Visual Record of Death

The most compelling evidence for the re-identification is found in the specific iconographic program. The sarcophagus depicts Mary Magdalene and St. James (San Giacomo) flanking the deceased. Seiler argues these are not random devotional choices but "calendar figures" linked to the specific historical events of 1329.

Cangrande I died in Treviso on July 22, the feast day of Mary Magdalene, and was buried in Verona on July 25, the feast day of St. James. The presence of these two specific saints, framing the knight, acts as a visual record of the narrow window between his death and his interment. This "smoking gun" iconography provides a level of specificity that matches no other member of the Della Scala dynasty.

Conclusion: A New Resting Place for Cangrande I

Seiler’s re-identification of the tomb as belonging to Cangrande I (d. 1329) necessitates a rethink of the cemetery's architectural history. He proposes that this relief sarcophagus might have been the original intended resting place for the ruler, perhaps serving as a primary component of his funerary complex before the more famous monumental equestrian tomb was finalized.

While the absence of an original inscription means the identification remains a high-probability hypothesis, the convergence of heraldic, stylistic, and iconographic evidence provides a much more robust historical foundation than the previous tradition. The study highlights how a multi-disciplinary approach—combining philology, art history, and heraldry—can correct long-standing misconceptions in the study of medieval monuments.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{seiler2015per,
  author = {Peter Seiler},
  title = {{Per un'identificazione del sarcofago a rilievo del sepolcreto scaligero di Verona}},
  booktitle = {heiDOK},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.11588/artdok.00003094},
}
Figure