PER CAPITA INCOME CONVERGENCE AMONG PROVINCES IN CHINA

Di Wang, Zhimin Wang, Yuying XieInternational Journal of Economics and Financial Issues 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether per capita income has converged across China's provinces between 1999 and 2018, finding that it has, both nationally and in most regions. The study highlights that investments in education, infrastructure, and fixed assets are key drivers of this convergence, suggesting that continued and targeted investment in poorer regions is crucial for sustainable long-term prosperity and reduced inequality.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China's rapid economic growth over the past few decades has been accompanied by a significant and growing challenge of income inequality between its coastal and inland regions. While national policies have aimed to promote growth and reduce this disparity, the effectiveness of these measures and the underlying mechanisms driving convergence (or lack thereof) at the provincial level remain a critical area of inquiry. Previous studies often relied on GDP per capita as a proxy for income, which can be misleading in China due to its export-oriented economy and labor migration patterns. This paper addresses this gap by using provincial-level per capita income data to empirically test the convergence theory and identify the factors contributing to income convergence.

Methods

The study employs a standard econometric approach to test for β-convergence, a concept in economics suggesting that poorer economies tend to grow faster than richer ones, leading to a narrowing of income gaps over time. The core of their methodology is a regression model where the annual growth rate of per capita income is regressed against the initial level of per capita income. A negative and statistically significant coefficient for the initial income level (β) indicates convergence.

To account for potential confounding factors, the researchers include province-specific fixed effects (controlling for time-invariant characteristics like geography) and time-specific fixed effects (controlling for national-level shocks). A key methodological innovation is the use of provincial-level per capita income data, which is considered a more accurate measure than GDP per capita for this specific context. Furthermore, the study splits the data into two periods (1999-2007 and 2008-2018) to assess the impact of the 2008-09 Chinese stimulus package. They also analyze convergence in per capita education expenses, infrastructure investments (proxied by highway length), and fixed asset investments to understand the drivers of income convergence.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is provincial-level per capita income data for 31 provinces in mainland China, collected over the period from 1999 to 2018. This data was sourced from the China Statistical Yearbook. Additionally, the study utilizes provincial-level data for education expenses, highway length (as a proxy for infrastructure investment), and fixed asset investments, also obtained from the China Statistical Yearbook for the same period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Per Capita Income Data Matters: The paper strongly advocates for using per capita income over GDP per capita for analyzing income convergence in China, arguing that the latter can overestimate income levels due to factors like lower labor costs in export industries and inter-regional labor migration.
  • The 2008 Stimulus Package as a Turning Point: The study reveals that the 2008-09 Chinese stimulus package had a significant and positive impact on income convergence, particularly in the period following its implementation. This suggests that targeted government intervention can accelerate the narrowing of income gaps.
  • Convergence is Driven by Investment: The research identifies education expenses, infrastructure investments, and fixed asset investments as key drivers of per capita income convergence. This implies that strategic investments in these areas are crucial for promoting balanced regional development.
  • Regional Heterogeneity: While national convergence is observed, the study highlights that convergence patterns vary across different regions within China. Some regions show strong convergence, while others do not, suggesting that regional specificities and policy implementation play a crucial role.
  • Sustainability of Convergence: The authors argue that convergence is not merely a short-term phenomenon but can be sustainable in the long run if investments in education, infrastructure, and fixed assets are continuously increased, especially in poorer regions.

Key Results

  • National Convergence: Per capita income shows a statistically significant negative relationship with its initial level across all 31 provinces from 1999-2018, indicating national-level convergence.
  • Regional Convergence: Convergence was observed in 4 out of 6 defined regions for the entire period. This pattern strengthened significantly in the second period (2009-2018), with convergence observed in 5 out of 6 regions.
  • Impact of Stimulus: The convergence coefficient (β) became more negative and statistically significant in the 2009-2018 period compared to 1999-2008, suggesting faster convergence after the stimulus.
  • Drivers of Convergence: Convergence was also found in per capita education expenses, infrastructure investments, and fixed asset investments, supporting their role as key drivers.
  • Outliers: Direct-controlled municipalities like Beijing and Shanghai exhibited higher convergence coefficients, acting as outliers and potentially skewing national averages if not accounted for.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Outlier Impact: The study acknowledges that direct-controlled municipalities can act as outliers, influencing national average convergence metrics. While they analyze this by excluding them, it highlights the complexity of regional dynamics.
  • Short-Term Deviations: The authors note that rapid economic growth can lead to short-term deviations from long-term equilibrium, potentially explaining why convergence might not be consistently observed in all regions at all times.
  • Sustainability Concerns: While arguing for sustainability, the paper implicitly suggests that without continued and targeted investment, the current convergence might not be permanent.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that policymakers should regularly revisit and revise national development policies to ensure resources are directed effectively, avoiding over-reliance on existing patterns. They also emphasize the importance of balancing regional development to reduce income inequality and foster long-term prosperity. Further research could explore the specific mechanisms through which different types of investments impact convergence in various regional contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

One increasingly important political and economic challenge of China's economy is income inequality. In the past two decades, a series of regulations and policies were enacted to promote its economic growth and reduce income inequality. In this empirical study, we examine the effectiveness of these regulations and policies on reducing the personal income gap at the provincial level in China and analyze the reasons behind the effectiveness: education expenses, infrastructure investments, and fixed asset investments. We test the per capita income data of 31 provinces over the periods 1999 to 2018 and our results show that the per capita income converges nationally and in most regions. The convergence in per capita income is supported by the convergence in per capita education expenses, infrastructure investments, and fixed asset investments. Without fundamental changes in economic policies, the current economic growth may not be sustainable. Our paper suggests that continuously increase investments in education expenses, infrastructure investments, and fixed asset investments in poor regions are necessary to reduce the income gap between rich and poor regions to foster long-term prosperity.Keywords: Convergence Theory, Per Capita Income, Education Expense, Infrastructure Investments, Fixed Asset InvestmentsJEL Classifications: D31, F63, O47, R11DOI: https://doi.org/10.32479/ijefi.10713
BibTeX
@article{wang2020per,
  author = {Di Wang and Zhimin Wang and Yuying Xie},
  title = {{PER CAPITA INCOME CONVERGENCE AMONG PROVINCES IN CHINA}},
  journal = {International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.32479/ijefi.10713},
}
Figure