People’s Perceptions about the Importance of Forests on Borneo

Erik Meijaard, Nicola K. Abram, Jessie A. Wells, Anne‐Sophie Pellier, Marc Ancrenaz, David Gaveau, Rebecca K. Runting, Kerrie MengersenPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

We ascertained villagers' perceptions about the importance of forests for their livelihoods and health through 1,837 reliably answered interviews of mostly male respondents from 185 villages in Indonesian and Malaysian Borneo. Variation in these perceptions related to several environmental and social variables, as shown in classification and regression analyses. Overall patterns indicated that forest use and cultural values are highest among people on Borneo who live close to remaining forest, and especially among older Christian residents. Support for forest clearing depended strongly on the scale at which deforestation occurs. Deforestation for small-scale agriculture was generally considered to be positive because it directly benefits people's welfare. Large-scale deforestation (e.g., for industrial oil palm or acacia plantations), on the other hand, appeared to be more context-dependent, with most respondents considering it to have overall negative impacts on them, but with people in some areas considering the benefits to outweigh the costs. The interviews indicated high awareness of negative environmental impacts of deforestation, with high levels of concern over higher temperatures, air pollution and loss of clean water sources. Our study is unique in its geographic and trans-national scale. Our findings enable the development of maps of forest use and perceptions that could inform land use planning at a range of scales. Incorporating perspectives such as these could significantly reduce conflict over forest resources and ultimately result in more equitable development processes.

Introduction

Tropical conservation efforts frequently encounter a tension between economic development and the maintenance of biodiversity. Policy decisions regarding land use are often made at high governmental levels, frequently lacking a granular understanding of how local communities—those most directly affected—perceive these trade-offs. While previous research into forest perceptions has typically been limited to individual villages or specific watersheds, this study, published in PLOS ONE, addresses the challenge of scale. By analyzing over 1,800 interviews across the transnational landscape of Borneo (Indonesia and Malaysia), the researchers sought to understand how socio-ecological variables influence forest valuation. This data is essential for making "Green Economy" initiatives, such as REDD+, more equitable and reducing land-use conflicts.

Methods and Data

The study employed a multi-disciplinary approach, filtering a massive dataset of nearly 7,000 interviews down to 1,837 "high-quality" responses to ensure reliability. These interviews were conducted across 185 villages in Kalimantan (Indonesia) and Sabah (Malaysia).

Geographic distribution of surveyed villages across Borneo, showing elevation and land cover types.

Using GPS coordinates for each village, the team performed spatial analysis (GIS) to calculate land cover percentages—such as oil palm, intact forest, and logged forest—within radii ranging from 3km to 20km. Land use data was derived from SarVision PALSAR 2010 classifications and Landsat imagery (1990–2010). For predictive modeling, the researchers utilized Boosted Regression Trees (BRT), a machine-learning method capable of identifying complex, non-linear interactions between variables like religion, age, and proximity to plantations.

Key Insights

The research revealed that perceptions of deforestation are not monolithic but depend heavily on the scale of the activity.

  • The Scale Divide: Villagers generally support small-scale clearing for gardens, viewing it as vital for local welfare. In contrast, large-scale industrial clearing is widely viewed as a source of negative impacts, including pollution, increased temperatures, and loss of resources.
  • Micro-climate Regulation: A significant finding was the spontaneous mention of the forest's "cooling" service. Local residents are acutely aware of the forest's role in regulating the micro-climate, a benefit that is often overshadowed by global carbon sequestration discussions in international policy.
  • Demographic Drivers: Religion and age emerged as strong predictors of forest value. Christian residents and older community members tended to place higher cultural and use values on the forest compared to other demographic groups.
  • The Dwindling Benefit Paradox: Interestingly, perceptions of environmental health benefits (like flood prevention) were strongest in areas where these benefits were actively disappearing due to deforestation. Conversely, direct health benefits, such as access to medicinal plants, were most valued where forests remained intact.

Results and Perceptions

The quantitative results underscore the high value placed on forest ecosystems by local communities. Approximately 67% of respondents perceived the forest as "very important" for their health, and nearly half viewed cultural and spiritual benefits as "very significant."

Villager perceptions regarding the importance of forests for health and cultural/spiritual benefits.

The BRT models demonstrated high predictive accuracy ($r = 0.82$) for direct economic uses based on socio-ecological variables. Regional differences also appeared: support for small-scale clearing was highest in West Kalimantan and Sabah—regions with longer histories of forest loss—suggesting that as forests become scarce, the perceived value of remaining land for agriculture increases.

Discussion and Future Directions

Despite the depth of the study, the authors noted a significant gender bias, as 80% of respondents were male due to survey designs targeting "heads of households." Furthermore, a "carbon gap" was identified: only 13 respondents spontaneously mentioned carbon sequestration, highlighting a communication divide between international climate scientists and local communities.

The study concludes that these predictive models can be used to create continuous maps of forest perception. Such maps would allow land-use planners to identify "high-conflict" zones where industrial expansion might face the most resistance, ultimately leading to more sustainable and equitable development processes on Borneo.

Summary updated

Abstract

We ascertained villagers' perceptions about the importance of forests for their livelihoods and health through 1,837 reliably answered interviews of mostly male respondents from 185 villages in Indonesian and Malaysian Borneo. Variation in these perceptions related to several environmental and social variables, as shown in classification and regression analyses. Overall patterns indicated that forest use and cultural values are highest among people on Borneo who live close to remaining forest, and especially among older Christian residents. Support for forest clearing depended strongly on the scale at which deforestation occurs. Deforestation for small-scale agriculture was generally considered to be positive because it directly benefits people's welfare. Large-scale deforestation (e.g., for industrial oil palm or acacia plantations), on the other hand, appeared to be more context-dependent, with most respondents considering it to have overall negative impacts on them, but with people in some areas considering the benefits to outweigh the costs. The interviews indicated high awareness of negative environmental impacts of deforestation, with high levels of concern over higher temperatures, air pollution and loss of clean water sources. Our study is unique in its geographic and trans-national scale. Our findings enable the development of maps of forest use and perceptions that could inform land use planning at a range of scales. Incorporating perspectives such as these could significantly reduce conflict over forest resources and ultimately result in more equitable development processes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meijaard2013peoples,
  author = {Erik Meijaard and Nicola K. Abram and Jessie A. Wells and Anne‐Sophie Pellier and Marc Ancrenaz and David Gaveau and Rebecca K. Runting and Kerrie Mengersen},
  title = {{People’s Perceptions about the Importance of Forests on Borneo}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0073008},
}
Figure