People, organizational, and leadership factors impacting informatics support for clinical and translational research

Philip R. O. Payne, Taylor R. Pressler, Indra Neil Sarkar, Yves A. LussierBMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak 2013 · DOI

Abstract

The rapid growth of Clinical and Translational Science (CTS) has created an unprecedented demand for informatics expertise. However, support for these needs often remains inadequate within Academic Health Centers (AHCs). This paper explores the organizational, leadership, and human factors that influence the effectiveness of informatics support. Through a mixed-methods study involving surveys of subject matter experts and thematic analysis of institutional documents, the authors demonstrate that formal academic structures and coordinated leadership are the primary drivers of informatics success.

Introduction

The transition of biomedical research from "bench to bedside" relies heavily on the ability to manage, analyze, and interpret vast quantities of data. As Clinical and Translational Science Awards (CTSAs) have become a cornerstone of the national research infrastructure, the role of Biomedical Informatics (BMI) has shifted from a peripheral support function to a core scientific necessity.

Despite its importance, informatics support often falls short of researcher expectations. This study posits that the root cause of this failure is not technical, but rather organizational. Many institutions fail to distinguish between Information Technology (IT) as a service utility and BMI as a scientific discipline, leading to siloed environments and inefficient resource allocation.

Methodology

This research employed a sociotechnical approach to evaluate the state of informatics support across major AHCs.

Survey Instrument

A structured survey was administered to 31 Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) affiliated with the National CTSA consortium and the American Medical Informatics Association (AMIA). Participants represented institutions such as Duke, Vanderbilt, and Johns Hopkins. The survey assessed three key areas:

  • Access to informatics services and expertise.
  • Coordination between BMI and IT leadership.
  • Institutional funding models for informatics infrastructure.

Document Analysis

To triangulate survey data, a qualitative thematic analysis was performed on a corpus of public-domain documents from nine representative institutions. These documents included annual reports, strategic plans, and peer-reviewed publications. A grounded theory approach was used to identify recurring themes related to organizational success and failure.

Results and Analysis

The Impact of Organizational Structure

The most significant predictor of informatics success was the presence of a formal academic "home" for BMI, such as a dedicated department or center.

  • Formal Units: 60% of respondents at institutions with a formal BMI unit rated their access to services as "Very Good" or "Good."
  • Decentralized Models: At institutions without a formal unit, high satisfaction ratings were significantly lower, ranging from 9% to 27%.

Leadership Coordination

The degree of integration between BMI and IT leadership was another critical factor. At institutions where leadership was perceived as "coordinated and integrated," 80% of respondents reported high-quality service access. In contrast, only 26% of respondents reported similar satisfaction levels at institutions with uncoordinated leadership.

Systemic Mediocrity

Despite the success of some institutions, the study found that "Fair" was the most common rating for both service access and funding models (approximately 45-48% of respondents). This suggests a widespread systemic struggle to meet the evolving informatics needs of the CTS community.

Discussion

The Informatics Translational Cycle

The authors propose a model where BMI acts as the essential bridge in the "Informatics Translational Cycle." In this model, Computational Science provides the underlying theories and algorithms, while IT provides the deployment infrastructure. BMI occupies the critical middle ground, translating raw computational power into usable tools for clinical research. When BMI lacks a formal organizational identity, this cycle is broken, resulting in a "gap" that hinders research progress.

Perception vs. Reality

The thematic analysis highlighted a significant discordance between internal expert perceptions and external institutional reporting. Many AHCs publicly claim to have "integrated" informatics environments, yet internal experts often describe these same environments as fragmented or poorly coordinated. This suggests that institutional branding often outpaces operational reality.

Conclusion

Improving informatics support for clinical and translational research requires more than just increased funding; it requires a fundamental shift in organizational strategy. Institutions must move away from treating informatics as a decentralized service utility and instead establish formal academic units that recognize BMI as a distinct scientific partner. Furthermore, tight coordination between BMI and IT leadership is essential to bridge the gap between technical infrastructure and scientific application.

Future research should expand upon these findings by including the perspectives of clinical researchers and senior university administrators to develop a more comprehensive understanding of the financial and political barriers to informatics integration.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{payne2013people,
  author = {Philip R. O. Payne and Taylor R. Pressler and Indra Neil Sarkar and Yves A. Lussier},
  title = {{People, organizational, and leadership factors impacting informatics support for clinical and translational research}},
  journal = {BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1186/1472-6947-13-20},
}
Figure