Abstract
The in-plane penetration depth of ${\text{Sr}}_{0.88}{\text{La}}_{0.12}{\text{CuO}}_{2+x}$ thin films at various doping obtained from oxygen reduction has been measured, using ac-susceptibility measurements. For the higher doping samples, the superfluid density deviates strongly from the $s$-wave behavior, suggesting, in analogy with other electron-doped cuprates, a contribution from a nodal hole pocket, or a small gap on the Fermi surface such as an anisotropic $s$-wave order parameter. The low value of the superfluid densities, likely due to a strong doping-induced disorder, places the superconducting transition of our samples in the phase-fluctuation regime.
Introduction
The symmetry of the superconducting order parameter in electron-doped cuprates remains a subject of intense debate. While hole-doped cuprates exhibit a well-established $d$-wave symmetry with nodes in the superconducting gap, electron-doped materials like the "infinite-layer" $Sr_{0.88}La_{0.12}CuO_{2+x}$ (SLCO) have shown evidence for both $s$-wave and $d$-wave-like behaviors. This study investigates the evolution of the superconducting state in SLCO thin films as a function of electron doping, achieved through oxygen reduction.
Experimental Methods
Epitaxial thin films of $Sr_{0.88}La_{0.12}CuO_{2+x}$ (~400 Å thick) were grown on $KTaO_3$ substrates using RF magnetron sputtering. Doping levels were controlled by annealing samples in vacuum or Argon to remove oxygen, effectively increasing the electron concentration. The in-plane magnetic penetration depth ($\lambda$) was determined using a high-sensitivity AC susceptometer, allowing for the calculation of the superfluid density $n_s \propto \lambda^{-2}$ across a range of temperatures. Structural integrity and epitaxial strain were confirmed via X-ray diffraction (XRD) and reciprocal space mapping.
Superfluid Density and Gap Symmetry
A central finding of this work is the doping dependence of the superconducting gap symmetry. At lower doping levels, the temperature dependence of the superfluid density is consistent with a standard $s$-wave model. However, as doping increases, the curvature of $\lambda^{-2}(T)$ shifts significantly.
As shown in Figure 3, the higher $T_c$ samples (corresponding to higher doping) exhibit a strong departure from $s$-wave behavior. This transition suggests the emergence of nodes or a highly anisotropic gap, potentially linked to the appearance of "hole pockets" on the Fermi surface. This two-band model, where both electron and hole pockets contribute to the superfluid density, aligns with observations in other electron-doped cuprates.
Phase Fluctuations and Universal Scaling
The measured superfluid densities in these SLCO films are notably low, with zero-temperature penetration depths $\lambda(0)$ ranging from 0.69 $\mu m$ (for $T_c = 19$ K) to 7.1 $\mu m$ (for $T_c = 7.1$ K). These values are significantly larger than those observed in bulk crystals, pointing toward a high degree of disorder introduced during the oxygen reduction process.
The relationship between $T_c$ and the superfluid density further distinguishes SLCO from typical underdoped hole-doped cuprates. Instead of following the linear Uemura relation ($T_c \propto \lambda^{-2}$), the SLCO samples exhibit a sub-linear dependence ($T_c \propto (\lambda^{-2})^{0.2}$), as seen in Figure 6. This behavior suggests that the superconducting transition is limited by phase fluctuations rather than the pairing energy gap, placing SLCO in the regime of "dirty" or highly disordered superconductors.
Conclusion
This investigation reveals that the superconducting state in infinite-layer SLCO is highly sensitive to electron doping. The shift from $s$-wave-like to nodal behavior at high doping supports a complex Fermi surface topology involving hole pockets. While disorder plays a significant role in suppressing the superfluid density and driving the system into a phase-fluctuation regime, the underlying physics reflects the intrinsic competition between different gap symmetries in electron-doped cuprates. Future work at lower temperatures and with varying strain states will be essential to further decouple these effects.
Summary updated