TL;DR
This paper investigates the complex soil-spudcan interaction during the installation of offshore wind turbine jack-up vessels in a challenging "thin stiff over normally consolidated (NC) clay" seabed. Using advanced numerical simulations, the study reveals how soil plug formation influences penetration resistance and develops a predictive model for this critical plug thickness, offering a more robust design basis for these vital offshore structures.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Offshore wind energy is rapidly expanding, and jack-up vessels are crucial for installing these turbines. These vessels rely on spudcan foundations to anchor themselves securely to the seabed. However, predicting the spudcan's penetration behavior, especially in complex layered soil conditions like "thin stiff over NC clay," is challenging. This soil profile is particularly problematic because the stiff top layer can mask the underlying softer clay, potentially leading to punch-through failures. Such failures can cause catastrophic structural damage and operational downtime. Existing design methods often don't fully account for the "soil plug effect" – the phenomenon where soil gets trapped beneath the spudcan, significantly altering penetration resistance. This study aims to address this gap by thoroughly investigating the failure mechanisms and developing a predictive tool for the soil plug in this specific, challenging soil scenario.
Methods
The core of this research utilizes Large Deformation Finite Element (LDFE) analyses with the Remeshing and Interpolation Technique with Small Strain (RITSS) implemented in the AFENA finite element package. This advanced LDFE approach is well-suited for simulating the large soil displacements and complex failure patterns associated with spudcan penetration. The RITSS method combines small strain analyses with frequent automatic remeshing to maintain mesh quality and accuracy throughout the simulation.
To understand the influence of various soil and interface properties, the researchers conducted an extensive parametric study. They systematically varied:
- The thickness of the top stiff clay layer (H/D).
- The normalized strength of the top layer soil (sut/γ'D).
- The ratio of shear strengths between the stiff top layer and the soft bottom layer (sut/sui).
- The gradient of shear strength increase in the bottom NC clay layer (k).
- The coefficient of friction between the spudcan and the soil (α).
The numerical results were rigorously validated against previously published centrifuge test data and numerical simulations, ensuring the reliability of their LDFE model.
Datasets
This study did not introduce new experimental datasets. Instead, it relied on existing centrifuge test data and numerical simulation results from prior research (specifically referencing the work of Hossain and Randolph [22] and others) for model validation. The paper presents a summary of the LDFE analyses performed, detailing the parameters used for each group of simulations, which can be considered a form of benchmark dataset for future comparative studies.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Soil Plug Formation is Key: The study highlights that a significant "soil plug" forms beneath the spudcan as it penetrates the stiff-over-NC clay. This plug is not just passive material but actively influences the penetration resistance.
- Backflow and Trapping: The failure mechanism involves soil backflow from the NC clay layer, trapping the stronger top-layer material beneath the spudcan. This trapped plug is crucial for understanding the overall resistance.
- Layer Thickness Matters: The thickness of the stiff top layer (H/D) directly influences the plug shape and thickness. For thin top layers, the plug thickness increases linearly with thickness.
- Strength Gradient is Critical: The rate at which the shear strength increases in the bottom NC clay layer (k) significantly impacts how the soil plug behaves and how easily it can be squeezed out or reformed.
- Strength Ratio Governs Flow: The ratio of the stiff layer's strength to the soft layer's strength (sut/sui) dictates the soil flow mechanism, influencing whether the top layer is cut or if the bottom layer flows more uniformly.
- Friction Has Minimal Impact: Interestingly, the coefficient of friction between the spudcan and the soil showed a minimal influence on the soil flow mechanism and the maximum plug thickness within the studied range.
- Predictive Model for Plug Thickness: The research successfully developed an empirical expression to quantify the maximum thickness of the trapped soil plug (hmax/D), providing a valuable tool for engineers.
Key Results
- Validation Success: The LDFE simulations were consistently validated against centrifuge test data, demonstrating good agreement in soil flow patterns and plug formation.
- Parametric Influence: The study quantified the influence of various parameters on soil plug formation:
- H/D: Increased H/D led to a thicker soil plug.
- sut/γ'D: Higher normalized top layer strength resulted in different plug formation types.
- sut/sui: The strength ratio significantly influenced the soil flow mechanism.
- k: A higher strength gradient in the bottom layer led to more rapid backflow and plug reformation.
- Empirical Formula: An equation was derived to predict the normalized equivalent soil plug thickness (hmax/D) with an R² value of 0.9, incorporating H/D, sut/γ'D, sut/sui, and k. This formula is applicable for spudcan dimensions (D = 10 m) and soil profiles within the studied ranges.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Range of Application: The derived prediction formula for plug thickness is based on specific ranges of spudcan dimensions and soil parameters. The authors caution that it should be used with care for conditions outside these ranges.
- Focus on Plug Thickness: While the study focused on the maximum thickness of the soil plug underneath the spudcan due to its impact on resistance, the influence of plugs forming above the spudcan was not considered.
- Future Work Suggested: The authors suggest further investigation into the relationship between bearing capacity and soil plug formation. They also propose that future studies could explore the broader implications of the plug's shape and dimension on the overall penetration resistance, particularly for interpolating resistance in the bottom NC clay. Understanding the peak resistance in relation to plug behavior remains an area for continued research.
Summary updated