Penetration and ligament formation of viscoelastic droplets impacting on the superhydrophobic mesh

Abbasali Abouei Mehrizi, Shiji Lin, Lijie Sun, Yile Wang, Longquan ChenScientific 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Scientific Reports, explores how adding a tiny amount of polymer to water can fundamentally change how droplets interact with a mesh. By introducing viscoelasticity, the researchers demonstrate a way to prevent droplets from shattering into a fine spray upon impact—a finding with significant implications for everything from agricultural pesticide application to reducing the spread of airborne pathogens.

TL;DR

Adding high-molecular-weight polymers to water droplets creates "elastic ligaments" that can poke through a superhydrophobic mesh and then snap back like a rubber band instead of breaking into a spray. This viscoelasticity suppresses fragmentation during both the initial impact and the subsequent recoil, governed by a physical mechanism that mimics a classic spring-dashpot system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a liquid droplet hits a porous surface, like a screen or a mesh, it often penetrates the holes. For Newtonian fluids like pure water, this penetration usually results in "spraying"—the liquid fragments into many tiny satellite droplets. This is often undesirable. In agriculture, it leads to pesticide drift; in industrial cooling, it reduces efficiency; and in medical settings, it can aerosolize pathogens.

While much is known about how water behaves on these surfaces, most real-world fluids (like paints, biological fluids, or pesticide mixes) are viscoelastic. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how the "stretchiness" (elasticity) of a fluid changes the physics of mesh penetration and fragmentation.

Methods

The researchers used a combination of high-speed imaging and theoretical modeling:

  • Experimental Setup: They fabricated superhydrophobic (SH) meshes with three different pore sizes (87, 135, and 357 μm) by growing nanostructures on copper and coating them with PDMS.
  • Fluid Variables: They compared pure water to aqueous solutions of Polyethylene Oxide (PEO) at four concentrations (0.5 to 3.0 g/L).
  • Observation: Using a high-speed camera at 52,000 frames per second, they captured the millisecond-scale dynamics of droplets (2 mm diameter) impacting the mesh at various velocities.
  • Modeling: The team applied the Kelvin–Voigt model (a parallel spring-dashpot system) to describe the growth and retraction of the liquid "ligaments" that form during impact.

Datasets

The study relies on original experimental data, including:

  • Phase Diagrams: Mapping impact outcomes (penetration vs. no penetration) across a range of Weber numbers ($We$) and mesh pore sizes ($S$).
  • Time-Series Imaging: High-speed video sequences documenting the distinct stages of spreading, ligament formation, and recoil.
  • Rheological Data: Measurements of the PEO solutions' viscosity and elasticity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Elastic Stabilization: In pure water, liquid "fingers" (ligaments) poking through the mesh are destroyed by Rayleigh-Plateau instability (the same force that turns a stream of water into droplets). In PEO solutions, the polymer chains act like microscopic springs that stabilize these ligaments, allowing them to stretch significantly without breaking.
  • The "Snap-Back" Effect: Unlike water, which fragments into a spray, the viscoelastic ligaments reach a maximum length and then retract back through the mesh to rejoin the "mother" droplet.
  • Mechanism Shift in Recoil: Water typically experiences "recoil penetration" due to the symmetric collapse of an air cavity, which shoots a jet of liquid downward through the mesh. In viscoelastic droplets, the upward flow from the retracting ligaments causes the cavity to detach from the mesh instead of collapsing, effectively "choking off" the spray.
  • Spring-Dashpot Analogy: The growth of these liquid ligaments follows the same mathematical rules as a Kelvin-Voigt material. The polymer concentration dictates the "spring constant" (elasticity), while the fluid's motion provides the "damping" (viscosity).

Key Results

  • Spray Suppression: Adding PEO does not significantly change the initial pressure needed to penetrate the mesh, but it almost entirely eliminates the subsequent fragmentation (spray).
  • Critical Thresholds: The researchers identified that for PEO droplets, the threshold for recoil penetration is much higher than for water. For example, at a concentration of 0.5 g/L on a 135 μm mesh, the critical Weber number for recoil penetration ($We_{c2}$) jumped to ~16.7, compared to just ~7.5 for water.
  • Predictive Modeling: The proposed mass conservation model successfully predicted the maximum ligament size based on impact velocity and mesh geometry, showing that higher polymer concentrations result in shorter, more stable ligaments.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their model, while effective at capturing the "big picture," is simplified. It assumes a uniform ligament thickness and does not account for the highly complex internal flow dynamics during the final stages of retraction.

Future research could explore how different types of polymers (e.g., branched vs. linear) or different mesh architectures (e.g., 3D printed lattices) influence these dynamics. There is also a clear path toward applying these findings to specific "anti-aerosol" technologies, such as redesigned dental tools or agricultural spray nozzles that minimize environmental drift.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spraying occurs by the impact of water droplets on the superhydrophobic wire meshes by liquid penetration during the spreading and recoiling. We have shown that adding a small amount of high molecular weight polymer (PEO) alters the ligaments formation and stabilizes them due to its high elasticity. Consequently, it suppresses droplet spray during droplet spreading and recoiling (recoil penetration). In the wide range of the impact velocities, the penetrated ligaments retracted back to the mesh after reaching the maximum length and eventually merged with the droplet on the mesh. The empirical fitting shows that the ligament evolution follows the parallel spring-dashpot model of Kelvin-Voigt. The additive polymer also changes the recoil penetration mechanisms from cavity collapse to cavity detachment due to the higher retraction velocity of the cavity near the mesh that is induced by the upward flow formed by the retraction of the ligaments to the mother droplet. A model based on mass conservation is proposed to calculate the variation of the maximum ligament size.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mehrizi2022penetration,
  author = {Abbasali Abouei Mehrizi and Shiji Lin and Lijie Sun and Yile Wang and Longquan Chen},
  title = {{Penetration and ligament formation of viscoelastic droplets impacting on the superhydrophobic mesh}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-15645-1},
}
Figure