Penalized G-estimation for effect modifier selection in a structural nested mean model for repeated outcomes

Ajmery Jaman, Guanbo Wang, Ashkan Ertefaie, Michèle Bally, Renée Lévesque, Robert W. Platt, Mireille E. SchnitzerBiometrics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel statistical method, "penalized G-estimation," to simultaneously identify which patient characteristics (effect modifiers) influence treatment effectiveness and estimate the treatment's causal effect in longitudinal studies with repeated outcomes. This approach is crucial for personalized medicine and optimizing treatments when the key modifying factors aren't known beforehand.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In healthcare and other fields, we often want to understand not just if a treatment works, but for whom it works best. This is known as "effect modification." Identifying these "effect modifiers" (patient characteristics like age, comorbidities, etc.) is vital for tailoring treatments and improving patient outcomes. However, in studies where patients are followed over time and measurements are taken repeatedly (longitudinal data), and where the treatment and confounding factors can change over time, identifying these effect modifiers is complex. Existing methods often assume we know the effect modifiers in advance or focus on outcomes at a single time point. This paper tackles the challenge of simultaneously selecting these unknown effect modifiers and estimating causal effects within a sophisticated framework for longitudinal data called Structural Nested Mean Models (SNMMs).

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a doubly robust penalized G-estimator. Here's a breakdown:

  • Structural Nested Mean Models (SNMMs): These are causal models designed for time-varying treatments and confounders, allowing us to estimate the average effect of a treatment on an outcome over time, even when the treatment's impact might differ for different individuals.
  • G-estimation: This is a standard technique for estimating parameters in SNMMs. It's known for its robustness.
  • Penalization (SCAD Penalty): To address the problem of unknown effect modifiers, the authors incorporate a "penalized" version of the G-estimation. They use a non-convex penalty (specifically, the Smoothly Clipped Absolute Deviation or SCAD penalty) which has desirable properties for variable selection: it encourages sparsity (setting coefficients of unimportant modifiers to zero) while remaining unbiased and continuous.
  • Simultaneous Selection and Estimation: The key innovation is that this penalized approach allows for the selection of effect modifiers and the estimation of causal effects to happen at the same time. This is more efficient and less prone to errors than a two-step process.
  • Oracle Property: The authors prove that their estimator has the "oracle property." This means it can, with high probability, correctly identify which variables are true effect modifiers and estimate the parameters associated with them as efficiently as if the true model were known in advance.
  • Doubly Robust: The estimator is "doubly robust," meaning it provides consistent estimates if either the model for how treatment is assigned (propensity score model) or the model for the outcome (treatment-free model) is correctly specified, but not necessarily both. This significantly increases its reliability.

Datasets

The authors use data from a study of patients undergoing hemodiafiltration (a type of dialysis) at the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal (CHUM) and its affiliated ambulatory dialysis center (CED). This real-world dataset involves repeated measurements of convection volume (an indicator of hemodiafiltration effectiveness) for patients over multiple dialysis sessions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Need for Data-Driven Discovery: In complex longitudinal settings, we can't always assume we know which patient characteristics will modify treatment effects. A method that can discover these modifiers from the data is essential for advancing personalized medicine.
  • Balancing Sparsity and Accuracy: The SCAD penalty is crucial for achieving a parsimonious model by eliminating non-significant effect modifiers, which improves estimation precision and interpretability.
  • Robustness is Key: The doubly robust nature of the estimator is a significant advantage, making it more reliable in practice where model misspecification is common.
  • Simultaneous Optimization: Combining effect modifier selection and causal effect estimation into a single penalized framework is more efficient and statistically sound than separate steps.

Key Results

The paper presents results from extensive simulation studies and an application to the hemodiafiltration data.

  • Simulation Studies:
    • The penalized G-estimator demonstrated good performance in selecting true effect modifiers, with high "EXACT" selection rates (correctly identifying the true set of modifiers) in various scenarios.
  • The method showed robustness to misspecification in either the treatment assignment model or the outcome model.
  • Performance improved with larger sample sizes and when accounting for correlation structures among repeated outcomes.
  • The estimator was found to be more efficient than a previous method (Boruvka et al., 2018) that does not perform variable selection.
  • Hemodiafiltration Data Application:
    • The analysis suggested that the effect of dialysis facility (CHUM vs. CED) on convection volume differs based on patient characteristics, notably cancer status.
  • Specifically, under the AR1 correlation structure, patients without cancer had lower convection volumes at CHUM compared to CED. However, cancer patients had higher convection volumes at CHUM, indicating a potential benefit for this subgroup.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Burden: The method can be computationally intensive, especially when subjects have a large number of observations.
  • Informative Censoring: The current method does not address informative censoring (when the reason for stopping follow-up is related to the outcome or treatment). This is a potential area for future extension.
  • Weak Effect Modifiers: Identifying very weak effect modifiers remains a challenge, and further research is suggested in this area, potentially by exploring ranking procedures for weaker modifiers.
  • High-Dimensional Settings: While simulations were conducted in high-dimensional settings, performance could be further improved, especially in small samples.
  • Treatment Model Selection: The paper focused on selecting effect modifiers for the outcome model. Future work could explore simultaneous selection for both the treatment and outcome models, especially in high-dimensional scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Effect modification occurs when the impact of the treatment on an outcome varies based on the levels of other covariates known as effect modifiers. Modeling these effect differences is important for etiological goals and for purposes of optimizing treatment. Structural nested mean models (SNMMs) are useful causal models for estimating the potentially heterogeneous effect of a time-varying exposure on the mean of an outcome in the presence of time-varying confounding. A data-adaptive selection approach is necessary if the effect modifiers are unknown a priori and need to be identified. Although variable selection techniques are available for estimating the conditional average treatment effects using marginal structural models or for developing optimal dynamic treatment regimens, all of these methods consider a single end-of-follow-up outcome. In the context of an SNMM for repeated outcomes, we propose a doubly robust penalized G-estimator for the causal effect of a time-varying exposure with a simultaneous selection of effect modifiers and prove the oracle property of our estimator. We conduct a simulation study for the evaluation of its performance in finite samples and verification of its double-robustness property. Our work is motivated by the study of hemodiafiltration for treating patients with end-stage renal disease at the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal. We apply the proposed method to investigate the effect heterogeneity of dialysis facility on the repeated session-specific hemodiafiltration outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jaman2025penalized,
  author = {Ajmery Jaman and Guanbo Wang and Ashkan Ertefaie and Michèle Bally and Renée Lévesque and Robert W. Platt and Mireille E. Schnitzer},
  title = {{Penalized G-estimation for effect modifier selection in a structural nested mean model for repeated outcomes}},
  booktitle = {Biometrics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1093/biomtc/ujae165},
}
Figure