Pelvic bone CT: can tin-filtered ultra-low-dose CT and virtual radiographs be used as alternative for standard CT and digital radiographs?

Christoph Stern, Stefan Sommer, Christoph Germann, Julien Galley, Christian W. A. Pfirrmann, Benjamin Fritz, Reto SutterEuropean 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that tin-filtered ultra-low-dose CT (ULD-CT) of the pelvis can achieve diagnostic image quality and detect osseous pathologies at a radiation dose comparable to standard digital radiographs, representing an 84% dose reduction compared to conventional pelvic CT. Furthermore, virtual radiographs generated from this ULD-CT data are equivalent to digital radiographs, offering a promising alternative for pelvic imaging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Standard CT scans of the pelvis, while providing detailed cross-sectional anatomy, expose patients to significantly higher radiation doses than conventional pelvic radiographs. This is particularly concerning for younger patients who may require multiple imaging studies throughout their lives, increasing their lifetime attributable risk of cancer. While digital radiographs are a lower-dose alternative, they are susceptible to projection errors and superposition by soft tissues, which can lead to diagnostic challenges. The paper addresses the need for a pelvic imaging modality that combines the low radiation dose of digital radiographs with the detailed anatomical information and diagnostic utility of CT, while also mitigating the limitations of plain radiography.

Methods

The researchers investigated a novel approach using tin-filtered ultra-low-dose CT (ULD-CT) for pelvic imaging. The core of their method involved:

  • Tin Filtration: A tin filter was placed in front of the X-ray tube during the ULD-CT acquisition. This filter selectively absorbs low-energy X-rays, which contribute little to bone imaging but increase patient dose. By hardening the X-ray spectrum, this technique aims to improve dose efficiency.
  • Optimized ULD-CT Protocol: A specific ULD-CT protocol (Sn140kV/50mAs) was developed and applied to patients.
  • Virtual Radiograph (VR) Generation: A key innovation was the computation of virtual pelvic radiographs directly from the ULD-CT data. This was achieved using an adapted 3D cone beam projection algorithm, designed to mimic the imaging characteristics of digital radiographs.
  • Comparison: The ULD-CT and VRs were rigorously compared against standard clinical CT (CT) and digital radiographs (DRs) in terms of radiation dose, image quality (quantitative and qualitative measures), and diagnostic accuracy for osseous pathologies.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • Pelvic Phantom and Cadavers: Used for protocol optimization.
  • Prospective Patient Cohort: Thirty patients undergoing pelvic CT for clinical indications were included. Their data comprised:
  • Standard non-contrast pelvic CT scans.
  • Tin-filtered ULD-CT scans of the pelvis acquired for the study.
  • Digital pelvic radiographs (anteroposterior and cross-table axial views) obtained for clinical reasons.

No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing clinical data and newly acquired ULD-CT data were used for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dose Equivalence is Achievable: The most significant insight is that tin-filtered ULD-CT can achieve a radiation dose (0.38 mSv) that is virtually identical to that of digital radiographs (0.37 mSv), while still providing diagnostic-quality cross-sectional imaging. This is a substantial improvement over standard CT (2.31 mSv).
  • Virtual Radiographs Bridge the Gap: The ability to generate virtual radiographs from ULD-CT data is a crucial development. This allows for the benefits of low-dose CT while also providing a familiar radiographic view that is equivalent to DRs, potentially improving diagnostic workflow and patient acceptance.
  • Dose Efficiency is Paramount: While standard CT and ULD-CT showed differences in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), the ULD-CT protocol demonstrated significantly higher dose efficiency (Figure of Merit - FOM). This means it achieves better image quality relative to the dose delivered.
  • Osseous Pathology Detection is Maintained: Despite the reduced dose, ULD-CT, along with its generated VRs, proved to be as effective as standard CT and DRs in depicting bone anatomy and accurately detecting common osseous pathologies.

Key Results

  • Dose Reduction: ULD-CT achieved an 84% dose reduction compared to standard CT, with a median effective dose of 0.38 mSv versus 2.31 mSv (p < .001).
  • Image Quality:
    • Standard CT had higher SNR (64.3 vs. 50.4) and CNR (21.5 vs. 18.8) compared to ULD-CT (p < .01).
  • ULD-CT showed slightly higher image noise but fewer artifacts compared to standard CT.
  • Both standard CT and ULD-CT provided good image quality with excellent depiction of anatomy (median score of 4).
  • Diagnostic Accuracy: Perfect agreement was observed between standard CT and ULD-CT regarding the prevalence of assessed osseous pathologies (p > .99).
  • Virtual Radiographs: VRs were successfully calculated and were found to be equivalent to digital radiographs in terms of anatomical depiction. Radiographic angle measurements (CE and Sharp angles) showed excellent inter-method reliability between VRs and DRs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scanner Variability: A limitation noted was that standard CT scans were performed on two different CT machines with slightly different acquisition parameters. While efforts were made to equalize dose parameters, this could have potentially affected dose-length product (DLP) and effective dose in some cases.
  • Scan Length Consistency: For patients not scanned immediately with ULD-CT after standard CT, scan lengths were not completely identical, which could also impact DLP and effective dose. Anatomical landmarks were used to minimize this difference.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further advancements, potentially involving machine learning, could lead to even lower radiation doses for CT scans while maintaining diagnostic quality, possibly even below the dose levels of digital radiographs. They also propose that the cone beam-based projection algorithm could be adapted to produce other radiographic views.

Summary updated

Abstract

• Ultra-low-dose pelvic CT with tin filtration (0.38 mSv) can be performed at a dose of digital radiographs (0.37 mSv), with a dose reduction of 84% compared to standard CT (2.31 mSv). • Tin-filtered ultra-low-dose CT had lower SNR and CNR and higher image noise than standard CT, but showed clear depiction of anatomy and accurate detection of osseous pathologies. • Virtual pelvic radiographs were successfully calculated from ultra-low-dose CT data and were equivalent to digital radiographs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{stern2021pelvic,
  author = {Christoph Stern and Stefan Sommer and Christoph Germann and Julien Galley and Christian W. A. Pfirrmann and Benjamin Fritz and Reto Sutter},
  title = {{Pelvic bone CT: can tin-filtered ultra-low-dose CT and virtual radiographs be used as alternative for standard CT and digital radiographs?}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s00330-021-07824-x},
}
Figure