Peer Mentoring Improves Diabetes Technology Use and Reduces Diabetes Distress Among Underserved Communities: Outcomes of a Pilot Diabetes Support Coach Intervention

Jennifer Maizel, Michael J. Haller, David M. Maahs, Ananta Addala, Stephanie L. Filipp, Rayhan Lal, Matthew J. Gurka, Lauren Figg, Melanie Hechavarria, Dessi P. Zaharieva, Keilecia G. Malden, Sarah Westen, Brittney N. Dixon, Korey K. Hood, Eleni Sheehan, Jessie J. Wong, William T. Donahoo, Marina Basina, Angelina Bernier, Eliana Frank, Ashby F. WalkerJournal of Diabetes Research 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This pilot study demonstrates that a "Diabetes Support Coach" (DSC) intervention, utilizing peer mentors with diabetes, significantly reduced diabetes distress and increased the use of continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) among underserved adults. This highlights the potential of lived experience and community-based support to improve health equity and technology adoption in diabetes management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Individuals with diabetes, particularly those from underserved communities, often face significant disparities in healthcare access, leading to poorer outcomes. These disparities are exacerbated by factors like distrust in healthcare providers, limited access to specialists, and lower utilization of advanced diabetes management technologies such as continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) and insulin pumps. Underserved populations also tend to experience higher levels of diabetes distress, which can negatively impact self-management and overall well-being. This paper aims to evaluate a novel intervention designed to address these challenges by providing social support through Diabetes Support Coaches (DSCs) within Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs).

Methods

The study implemented a pilot intervention as part of the Project Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes (ECHO) Diabetes program. This program involved training 28 DSCs, who themselves have diabetes, to act as peer mentors and community health workers. These DSCs provided support to intervention participants (n=74) through various communication channels like text messages, phone calls, and events. A comparison group (n=363) of adults with insulin-requiring diabetes from the same FQHCs who did not receive the DSC intervention was used for evaluation.

Participant outcomes were assessed using:

  • Diabetes Distress Scale (DDS-17): A survey to measure the emotional burden of living with diabetes.
  • Diabetes Technology Usage Survey: To assess the adoption and regular use of devices like CGMs and insulin pumps.
  • HbA1c Tests: Measured at baseline and a 6-month follow-up to track glycemic control.

Data analysis involved descriptive statistics and between-group comparisons using chi-squared and t-tests.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 437 participants (74 in the intervention group, 363 in the comparison group) across 33 Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) in Florida and California. HbA1c data was available for a subset of 259 participants (58 intervention, 201 comparison). The data collected included self-reported information on demographics, diabetes distress, technology usage, and HbA1c levels extracted from health center Electronic Health Records (EHRs) when home testing was not completed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Lived Experience: The core insight is that individuals with diabetes serving as peer mentors (DSCs) can effectively bridge the gap in trust and understanding often experienced by underserved communities with healthcare providers. Their shared experiences seem to foster greater receptiveness to advice and technology.
  • Targeted Social Support: The intervention wasn't just about general encouragement; DSCs provided specific support related to healthcare navigation, medication management, stress coping, diet, and physical activity, tailored to the needs of underserved populations.
  • Reducing Distress is Key: The significant reduction in diabetes distress suggests that addressing the emotional and psychological burden of diabetes is a critical component of improving overall management and well-being.
  • Democratizing Technology Access: The marked increase in CGM usage highlights how peer support can overcome barriers to adopting advanced diabetes technologies, potentially improving glycemic control and quality of life.

Key Results

  • Reduced Diabetes Distress: Participants in the DSC intervention group reported significantly lower overall diabetes distress (mean DDS-17 score of 1.6) compared to the control group (mean score of 2.1, p < 0.001). This reduction was also observed across subscales like emotional burden and regimen-related distress.
  • Increased CGM Use: A substantially higher proportion of intervention participants regularly used continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) (69.9%) compared to the control group (38.8%, p < 0.0001).
  • No Significant Change in Insulin Pump Use or HbA1c: The study found no statistically significant differences in insulin pump usage or HbA1c levels between the groups. However, the intervention group had a slightly higher mean baseline HbA1c, suggesting they might have been more motivated to seek help.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Self-Reported Data: Most data, except for HbA1c, was self-reported, which can introduce bias due to social desirability or recall errors.
  • Optional Survey Questions: The optional nature of survey questions meant not all participants responded to every item, potentially affecting outcome representativeness.
  • Small Intervention Sample Size and Staggered Enrollment: The limited number of intervention participants and their staggered enrollment meant data had to be evaluated cross-sectionally, limiting the ability to draw definitive longitudinal conclusions.
  • Self-Selection Bias: The study did not use patient-level randomization, meaning participants who chose to engage with DSCs might have differed systematically from those who did not.
  • Lack of Qualitative Data: The absence of qualitative methods means deeper insights into participants' experiences and the nuances of the intervention's impact are missing.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Longitudinal Evaluation: Assessing the sustained impact of the DSC intervention over longer periods.
  • Qualitative Research: Gathering in-depth feedback from both participants and DSCs to understand their experiences and perspectives.
  • Broader Intervention Impact: Examining the DSCs' influence on the uptake of automated insulin delivery systems.
  • Larger Scale Studies: Building on the success of this pilot to implement and evaluate similar interventions on a larger scale, potentially incorporating randomization.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> There are well-documented disparities in diabetes care outcomes and technology usage, stemming from differences in healthcare access, distrust in healthcare providers, and other factors. This study evaluated patient-level outcomes of a diabetes support coach (DSC) intervention aimed at improving underserved adults' diabetes technology use, diabetes distress, and HbA1c levels. <b>Methods:</b> As part of a Project Extension for Community Healthcare Outcomes (ECHO) Diabetes program, a social support intervention involving 28 DSCs was piloted at 33 Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs) in Florida and California from May 2021 to May 2022. DSCs, who were adults with diabetes, served in a capacity similar to peer mentors and community health workers and received uniform training/oversight by a clinical team. Intervention participants (<i>n</i> = 74 adults with insulin-requiring diabetes at FQHCs) self-enrolled and engaged with DSCs via text messages, phone calls, and events. Participants' outcomes were evaluated cross-sectionally via the Diabetes Distress Scale (DDS-17) and a diabetes technology usage survey and longitudinally via HbA1c tests upon enrollment and at 6-month follow-up. A group of adults with insulin-requiring diabetes from the same FQHCs who did not receive the DSC intervention (<i>n</i> = 363) was used for comparison. Descriptive statistics were computed for all outcomes (<i>n</i>, percentage; mean, SD/95% CI). Between-group comparisons were evaluated via chi-squared and <i>t</i>-tests. <b>Results:</b> DSC intervention participants reported significantly lower diabetes distress than the comparison group (DDS-17 score mean = 1.6 vs. 2.1, <i>p</i> < 0.001), and significantly more participants in the DSC intervention regularly used continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) than the comparison group (69.9% vs. 38.8%, <i>p</i> < 0.0001). There were no significant differences in insulin pump usage or HbA1c. <b>Conclusions:</b> Lower diabetes distress and greater CGM usage among intervention participants suggest that the DSCs' shared lived experiences and healthcare navigation support positively influenced underserved adults' outcomes. These findings show DSCs' potential for improving diabetes care and technology equity.
BibTeX
@article{maizel2025peer,
  author = {Jennifer Maizel and Michael J. Haller and David M. Maahs and Ananta Addala and Stephanie L. Filipp and Rayhan Lal and Matthew J. Gurka and LAUREN FIGG and Melanie Hechavarria and Dessi P. Zaharieva and Keilecia G. Malden and Sarah Westen and Brittney N. Dixon and Korey K. Hood and Eleni Sheehan and Jessie J. Wong and William T. Donahoo and Marina Basina and Angelina Bernier and Eliana Frank and Ashby F. Walker},
  title = {{Peer Mentoring Improves Diabetes Technology Use and Reduces Diabetes Distress Among Underserved Communities: Outcomes of a Pilot Diabetes Support Coach Intervention}},
  journal = {Journal of Diabetes Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1155/jdr/1970247},
}
Figure