Pedagogical Value of Polling-Place Observation by Students

Christopher Mann, Gayle Alberda, Nathaniel A. Birkhead, Ouyang Yu, Chloe Singer, Charles V. Stewart, Michael C. Herron, Emily Beaulieu, Frederick J. Boehmke, Joshua Boston, Francisco Cantú, Rachael Cobb, David Darmofal, Thomas C. Ellington, Charles J. Finocchiaro, Michael D. Gilbert, Victor Haynes, Brian D. Janssen, David C. Kimball, Charles A. Kromkowski, Elena Llaudet, Matthew R. Miles, David Miller, Lindsay Nielson, Costas Panagopoulos, Andrew Reeves, Min Hee Seo, Haley Simmons, Corwin D. Smidt, Robert M. Stein, Rachel VanSickle-Ward, Abby K. Wood, Julie WronskiPS 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Good education requires student experiences that deliver lessons about practice as well as theory and that encourage students to work for the public good—especially in the operation of democratic institutions. We report on an evaluation of the pedagogical value of a research project involving 23 colleges and universities across the country. Faculty trained and supervised students who observed polling places in the 2016 General Election. Our findings indicate that this was a valuable learning experience in both the short and long terms. Students found their experiences to be valuable and reported learning generally and specifically related to course material. Postelection, they also felt more knowledgeable about election science topics, voting behavior, and research methods. Students reported interest in participating in similar research in the future, would recommend other students to do so, and expressed interest in more learning and research about the topics central to their experience. Our results suggest that participants appreciated the importance of elections and their study. Collectively, the participating students are engaged and efficacious—essential qualities of citizens in a democracy.

Introduction

Political science education often struggles to bridge the gap between abstract theory and real-world practice. While simulations and case studies are common, "experiential learning"—learning by doing—is harder to implement in politics without crossing into partisan advocacy. This paper evaluates a massive multi-campus initiative where over 500 students served as field researchers during the 2016 US General Election. By observing polling place operations firsthand, students not only contributed to "election science" data collection but also demonstrated significant gains in research methodology, subject matter expertise, and civic efficacy. The authors specifically look at whether participating in a large-scale data collection project (the Polling Place Lines Project) provides measurable pedagogical value, helping students understand the "mundane" but critical administrative machinery of elections.

Methods and Data

The study utilized a multi-campus experiential learning model involving 23 diverse institutions. Faculty trained students using a standardized research protocol for fieldwork. Students spent between 2 and 12 hours at randomly selected polling places, recording data on line lengths, wait times, and administrative procedures such as voter check-in and ballot submission.

To evaluate the educational impact, researchers administered a post-election survey, achieving a 90% cooperation rate with 479 responses. The sample was well-distributed across undergraduate years and included 17% graduate students. The analysis employed a mix of quantitative Likert-scale questions and qualitative open-ended prompts.

Key Insights: The Human Element of Bureaucracy

One of the most significant findings was the shift in student perspective regarding the nature of elections. Qualitative analysis of student reflections revealed that "people" was the most prominent term used to describe their experience.

Word cloud of student reflections highlighting the prominence of 'people' and 'time'.

This suggests the experience moved students from seeing elections as abstract systems to seeing them as human-driven operations involving poll workers and fellow citizens. Acting as a neutral observer made students feel more connected to the democratic process without requiring partisan activism. Furthermore, students reported significant knowledge gains in "dry" topics like election law and logistics, bridging the gap between classroom theory and administrative reality.

Key Results and Learning Outcomes

The quantitative data strongly supports the pedagogical value of the project. Approximately 75% of participants considered their time spent on the project to be "very" or "somewhat" valuable. Learning outcomes were consistently high across all student levels.

Reported learning from Election Day experiences categorized by student academic level.

As shown in Figure 2, over 65% of students reported learning "a lot" or a "good amount" from the experience. In retrospective self-assessments across 11 topics—including research ethics, data collection, and election law—student knowledge shifted significantly toward higher proficiency. Despite the physical demands of field research, such as long hours and waiting, 52% of students expressed a high likelihood of participating in similar research in the future.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The project demonstrated that decentralized, multi-institution collaboration can produce high-quality research data while serving as a powerful teaching tool. While the authors acknowledge potential retrospective bias in self-reporting, the overall trend of increased engagement and knowledge is clear. Future iterations, such as those planned for the 2018 election, aimed to implement pre- and post-tests to more accurately capture knowledge gains and foster deeper inter-campus interaction, such as videoconferences for comparing jurisdictional observations. Ultimately, the results suggest that such experiential learning projects are essential for developing engaged and efficacious citizens.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Good education requires student experiences that deliver lessons about practice as well as theory and that encourage students to work for the public good—especially in the operation of democratic institutions (Dewey 1923; Dewy 1938). We report on an evaluation of the pedagogical value of a research project involving 23 colleges and universities across the country. Faculty trained and supervised students who observed polling places in the 2016 General Election. Our findings indicate that this was a valuable learning experience in both the short and long terms. Students found their experiences to be valuable and reported learning generally and specifically related to course material. Postelection, they also felt more knowledgeable about election science topics, voting behavior, and research methods. Students reported interest in participating in similar research in the future, would recommend other students to do so, and expressed interest in more learning and research about the topics central to their experience. Our results suggest that participants appreciated the importance of elections and their study. Collectively, the participating students are engaged and efficacious—essential qualities of citizens in a democracy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mann2018pedagogical,
  author = {Christopher Mann and Gayle Alberda and Nathaniel A. Birkhead and Ouyang Yu and Chloe Singer and Charles V. Stewart and Michael C. Herron and Emily Beaulieu and Frederick J. Boehmke and Joshua Boston and Francisco Cantú and Rachael Cobb and David Darmofal and Thomas C. Ellington and Charles J. Finocchiaro and Michael D. Gilbert and Victor Haynes and Brian D. Janssen and David C. Kimball and Charles A. Kromkowski and Elena Llaudet and Matthew R. Miles and David Miller and Lindsay Nielson and Costas Panagopoulos and Andrew Reeves and Min Hee Seo and Haley Simmons and Corwin D. Smidt and Robert M. Stein and Rachel VanSickle-Ward and Abby K. Wood and Julie Wronski},
  title = {{Pedagogical Value of Polling-Place Observation by Students}},
  booktitle = {PS},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1017/s1049096518000550},
}
Figure