PCAST: Report to the President on Improving Groundwater Security in the United States

Frances H. Arnold, Ajay Prabhakar, M. T. Zuber, Dan Arvizu, Dennis Assanis, John Banovetz, Lisa A. Cooper, John Dabiri, William J. Dally, Susan Desmond-Hellmann, Inez Fung, Andrea Goldsmith, L. H. Greene, Paula T. Hammond, Eric Horvitz, Joe Kiani, Jonathan Levin, Stephen W. Pacala, S. Perlmutter, William H. Press, Jennifer A. Richeson, Vicki L. Sato, Li Su, Kathleen M. Sullivan, Terence Tao, Philip Venables, Catherine E. Woteki2024 · DOI

Official Seal of the President's Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST)

Abstract

The President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) is the sole body of advisors from outside the federal government charged with making science, technology, and innovation policy recommendations to the President and the White House. Established by Executive Order, it is an independent Federal Advisory Committee comprised of distinguished individuals from industry, academia, and non-profit organizations with a range of perspectives and expertise. On December 14, 2024, PCAST submitted a report to the President with recommendations to enhance groundwater stewardship and resilience.

Introduction: The Invisible Crisis

Groundwater is a cornerstone of American infrastructure, providing drinking water for half the population and 70% of agricultural irrigation. Despite its criticality, the United States is currently "mining" its groundwater—often non-renewable fossil water—at unsustainable rates. This depletion threatens national food and energy security and causes irreversible physical damage, such as land subsidence and the permanent loss of aquifer storage capacity.

The core challenge is the "invisibility" of the resource. Groundwater governance is highly decentralized, resulting in a "data desert" characterized by fragmented manual records and incompatible metrics. We currently lack a real-time, comprehensive national picture of groundwater availability and depletion rates.

Technical Framework for Modern Stewardship

To address these challenges, PCAST proposes a massive technical pivot toward a unified national "hydrogeodesy" framework. Key components include:

  • Hydrogeodesy Integration: Utilizing satellite and terrestrial sensors—including GRACE-FO for gravity-based mass changes, InSAR for surface deformation, and GNSS/GPS—to infer groundwater storage changes at high resolution.
  • Interoperable Modeling: Moving away from isolated, site-specific models toward a centralized, open-source hydrologic modeling platform led by the USGS that integrates surface and groundwater data.
  • Molecular-Level Analysis: Employing state-of-the-art high-resolution mass spectrometry to identify chemical tracers and pollutants, such as PFAS, at the molecular level.
  • Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR): Developing engineering strategies to intentionally "bank" excess surface water underground during wet periods to buffer against future droughts.

Data Infrastructure and Unification

The report identifies a fragmented landscape of existing datasets and calls for their integration into a comprehensive national repository. Key existing sources include:

  • USGS National Water Information System (NWIS): Data from 1.5 million sites.
  • United States Groundwater Well Database (USGWD): A compilation of 14.2 million well records.
  • GRACE/GRACE-FO Satellite Data: Monthly global water loading observations.
  • InSAR and GNSS: Local-scale surface deformation tracking as a proxy for aquifer health.

Strategic Insights

  • The Embedded Water Economy: Groundwater depletion in the West is a global economic risk, as this water is "embedded" in agricultural products exported worldwide.
  • Non-Renewable Resource Management: Much of the water currently being extracted is "fossil water" recharged over 10,000 years ago. It must be treated as a finite mineral rather than a renewable flow.
  • Natural Capital Accounting: PCAST recommends incorporating the valuation of aquifers into federal cost-benefit analyses to justify the investment in conservation and recharge infrastructure.

Policy Recommendations

The report culminates in six high-level recommendations to the President:

  1. Establish an Interagency Working Group to create a unified national data repository and modeling toolkit.
  2. Launch a Research Program focused on molecular-level water quality and advanced recharge technologies.
  3. Create Groundwater Engagement Hubs, with a specific focus on Tribal Nations, to provide local technical assistance.
  4. Fund a Competitive Grants Program to incentivize science-based restoration of aquifers.
  5. Integrate Groundwater into Natural Capital Accounting to ensure its economic value is recognized in federal planning.
  6. Workforce Development: Launch a campaign to recruit and train the next generation of hydrogeologists and data scientists.
PCAST Leadership and Co-Chairs involved in the report's development

Challenges and Future Directions

Implementation faces significant jurisdictional hurdles, as the federal government has limited authority over state-led groundwater regulation. Success depends on state and local "buy-in" driven by federal incentives. Additionally, scaling the proposed national monitoring network will require sustained new appropriations and innovative methods to anonymize data from millions of private wells to protect landowner privacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) is the sole body of advisors from outside the federal government charged with making science, technology, and innovation policy recommendations to the President and the White House. Established by Executive Order, it is an independent Federal Advisory Committee comprised of distinguished individuals from industry, academia, and non-profit organizations with a range of perspectives and expertise. On December 14, 2024, PCAST sent a report to the President with recommendations to enhance groundwater stewardship and resilience.
BibTeX
@misc{arnold2024pcast,
  author = {Frances H. Arnold and Ajay Prabhakar and M. T. Zuber and Dan Arvizu and Dennis Assanis and John Banovetz and Lisa A. Cooper and John Dabiri and William J. Dally and Susan Desmond-Hellmann and Inez Fung and Andrea Goldsmith and L. H. Greene and Paula T. Hammond and Eric Horvitz and Joe Kiani and Jonathan Levin and Stephen W. Pacala and S. Perlmutter and William H. Press and Jennifer A. Richeson and Vicki L. Sato and Li Su and Kathleen M. Sullivan and Terence Tao and Philip Venables and Catherine E. Woteki and Philip Venables and Catherine Woteki},
  title = {{PCAST: Report to the President on Improving Groundwater Security in the United States}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2172/2481670},
}

Loading related content...

Figure