PBMC Fixation and Processing for Chromium Single-Cell RNA Sequencing

Jinguo Chen, Foo Cheung, Rongye Shi, Huizhi Zhou, Wenrui Wenrui, Chi Consortium, Julián Candia, Yuri Kotliarov, Katie R StaglianobioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new methanol-based fixation and processing protocol for peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) that preserves RNA integrity for single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-Seq). This method overcomes the limitations of using live cells, enabling more flexible experimental designs and better characterization of immune cell heterogeneity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-Seq) is a powerful tool for understanding cellular heterogeneity, but it typically requires live cells. Working with live cells presents several challenges:

  • Cell stress and perturbation: The preparation process itself can induce stress in cells, altering their gene expression profiles and potentially masking true biological differences. This is particularly problematic for sensitive cell types like immune cells (e.g., PBMCs), which can rapidly change upon isolation.
  • Logistical hurdles: The need to process cells immediately after collection limits the ability to disconnect sampling time and location from downstream analysis. This makes large-scale studies or collaborations challenging.
  • Biosafety concerns: Samples from individuals with highly infectious diseases require strict biosafety containment, making processing outside specialized facilities difficult.

While some fixation methods exist, they often fail to preserve RNA integrity in primary immune cells, leading to RNA degradation and loss. This paper aims to develop a robust fixation protocol that addresses these issues, allowing for the preservation of cellular states and enabling more flexible and comprehensive scRNA-Seq studies.

Methods

The researchers developed a modified methanol-based fixation protocol for PBMCs, breaking it down into three key steps:

  1. Methanol Fixation: Cells were fixed using cold 100% methanol. This step dehydrates cells and denatures proteins and nucleic acids, preserving cellular structures.
  2. Storage: Fixed cells were stored at -20°C or -80°C for up to three months.
  3. Resuspension: Crucially, instead of rehydrating with PBS (which caused RNA degradation), the fixed PBMCs were resuspended in a high-salt solution, specifically 3X saline sodium citrate (SSC) buffer. This step was found to preserve RNA integrity and prevent leakage.

The protocol was then integrated into the standard 10X Chromium single-cell RNA sequencing workflow. They also investigated the impact of diluted SSC buffer on cDNA synthesis and assessed cell quality metrics like low-quality cells and doublets.

Datasets

The study utilized human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) obtained from anonymous, healthy donors from the NIH Blood Bank. They also used other primary cell types and cell lines, including:

  • CD8+ T cells
  • Human Lung Microvascular Endothelial Cells (HMVEC-L)
  • Human Bone Marrow Stromal Cells (BMSC)
  • Mouse spleen cells
  • KLM1, 293T, and MEF cell lines

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The devil is in the rehydration: The critical step for RNA degradation in methanol-fixed PBMCs was not the fixation or storage, but the subsequent rehydration with PBS.
  • SSC to the rescue: Resuspending fixed PBMCs in a high-salt SSC buffer, rather than PBS, was key to preserving RNA integrity and preventing leakage. This high salt concentration likely prevents rehydration and thus protects RNA from degradation.
  • Fixation as a time machine: This protocol effectively "freezes" cells in their state at the time of fixation, allowing for delayed processing and analysis without compromising RNA quality or cellular profiles.
  • Broad applicability: The protocol not only works for PBMCs but also shows promise for other primary cell types and cell lines, suggesting a generalizable method for scRNA-Seq.
  • No significant impact on transcriptional profiles: Despite fixation, the scRNA-Seq data from fixed cells closely mirrored that of live cells, including the identification of major subpopulations and gene expression levels.

Key Results

  • RNA Integrity: Methanol fixation and storage at -20°C for up to three months maintained high RNA integrity (RIN > 8.0) in PBMCs. Resuspension in 3X SSC buffer preserved this integrity, while resuspension in PBS led to complete RNA degradation within 30 minutes.
  • scRNA-Seq Performance: The methanol-fixed, SSC-resuspended PBMCs were successfully processed using the 10X Chromium platform, yielding no elevated levels of low-quality cells or doublets.
  • Transcriptional Profile Preservation: Gene expression levels and transcriptional profiles were highly correlated between live and fixed PBMCs (Pearson's correlation r=0.95-0.97). Major PBMC subpopulations (T cells, NK cells, B cells, myeloid cells) were detected at similar proportions in both live and fixed samples.
  • SSC and cDNA Synthesis: Diluted SSC buffer (0.125X) did not inhibit SMART technology-based reverse transcription, allowing for full-length cDNA synthesis.
  • Low Quality Cells: Fixation did not increase the proportion of low-quality cells (indicated by mitochondrial gene reads); in fact, it appeared to prevent further stress-induced damage.
  • Reproducibility: The fixation method demonstrated high reproducibility, with fixed PBMC samples preserved for different durations showing highly correlated gene expression levels.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low abundant populations: While major subpopulations were well-detected, the paper notes that the boundaries among CD4+, CD8+, and NK cells were somewhat blurred, and low abundant populations (B, NK, DC) showed changes in relative distances on t-SNE plots due to gene loss.
  • Neutrophil challenges: The authors mention that this fixation method did not work for neutrophils (unpublished data), suggesting that this specific cell type may require further optimization.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that this protocol could lead to a paradigm shift in complex single-cell study designs, particularly when standardization methods (like magnet stirring) are developed and implemented. They also highlight the potential for this method to facilitate studies involving tissues with high protease and RNase content, such as pancreas, skin, and lymphatic tissues.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Interest in single-cell transcriptomic analysis is growing rapidly, especially for profiling rare or heterogeneous populations of cells. In almost all reported works investigators have used live cells, which introduces cell stress during preparation and hinders complex study designs. Recent studies have indicated that cells fixed by denaturing fixative can be used in single-cell sequencing, however they did not usually work with most types of primary cells including immune cells. Methods The methanol-fixation and new processing method was introduced to preserve human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) for single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-Seq) analysis on 10X Chromium platform. Results When methanol fixation protocol was broken up into three steps: fixation, storage and rehydration, we found that PBMC RNA was degraded during rehydration with PBS, not at cell fixation and up to three-month storage steps. Resuspension but not rehydration in 3X saline sodium citrate (SSC) buffer instead of PBS preserved PBMC RNA integrity and prevented RNA leakage. Diluted SSC buffer did not interfere with full-length cDNA synthesis. The methanol-fixed PBMCs resuspended in 3X SSC were successfully implemented into 10X Chromium standard scRNA-seq workflows with no elevated low quality cells and cell doublets. The fixation process did not alter the single-cell transcriptional profiles and gene expression levels. Major subpopulations classified by marker genes could be identified in fixed PBMCs at a similar proportion as in live PBMCs. This new fixation processing protocol also worked in several other fixed primary cell types and cell lines as in live ones. Conclusions We expect that the methanol-based cell fixation procedure presented here will allow better and more effective batching schemes for a complex single cell experimental design with primary cells or tissues.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2018pbmc,
  author = {Jinguo Chen and Foo Cheung and Rongye Shi and Huizhi Zhou and Wenrui Wenrui and CHI Consortium and Julián Candia and Yuri Kotliarov and Katie R Stagliano},
  title = {{PBMC Fixation and Processing for Chromium Single-Cell RNA Sequencing}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/315267},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure