TL;DR
This study objectively measured sedentary behavior in young children attending family child care homes (FCCHs), finding that most sedentary time occurs in short bursts. Crucially, it identified specific FCCH provider practices, like encouraging outdoor play and providing varied equipment, that are associated with significantly less sedentary behavior in children.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Public health guidelines recommend limiting sedentary time for young children, yet understanding how this plays out in real-world settings, particularly family child care homes (FCCHs), is limited. FCCHs are a common childcare setting, but research on children's sedentary behavior within them is scarce, especially regarding objective measurements and the influence of provider practices. This paper aims to fill this gap by quantifying sedentary behavior patterns and exploring how specific childcare environments and provider actions correlate with reduced sedentary time in this population.
Methods
The researchers employed an objective measurement approach using accelerometers to track the physical activity and sedentary behavior of children aged 3.5 ± 1.1 years over a randomly selected week. Accelerometers were worn on the hip for the duration of FCCH attendance, excluding nap times. Sedentary bouts were defined by specific accelerometer count thresholds and durations. To assess provider practices, the Nutrition and Physical Activity Self-Assessment for Child Care (NAPSACC-SA) instrument was used. FCCHs were then categorized as "promoting PA" (PPA) or "not promoting PA" (non-PPA) based on their adherence to established child care standards related to movement behaviors. Statistical analysis involved mixed-model ANOVAs to compare sedentary behavior between PPA and non-PPA groups, controlling for child sex and accelerometer wear time.
Datasets
The study utilized data from 127 children across 41 family child care homes (FCCHs) in Oregon, USA. The data collected included objective accelerometer measurements of sedentary behavior for each child and self-reported provider practices via the NAPSACC-SA instrument. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing instruments and established cut-points for accelerometer data were used.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Sedentary time is mostly short-lived: The study found that the vast majority of sedentary bouts in young children in FCCHs are brief, lasting less than 5 minutes. This suggests that prolonged, uninterrupted sedentary periods are less common than fragmented ones.
- Gender differences in sedentary behavior: Boys exhibited fewer sedentary bouts and less sedentary time in bouts compared to girls, particularly in shorter durations. This highlights a potential area for targeted interventions.
- The environment matters: FCCHs that actively promoted physical activity through specific practices (e.g., outdoor play, varied equipment, adequate indoor space) were associated with significantly less sedentary behavior in children. This underscores the importance of the childcare environment in shaping children's movement patterns.
- Provider engagement is key: When providers actively participated in children's free play, it was linked to fewer sedentary bouts. This emphasizes the role of adult interaction in promoting active behaviors.
Key Results
- Children in FCCHs predominantly accumulated sedentary time in short bouts (<5 min), with very few bouts exceeding 10 minutes.
- Girls had significantly more sedentary bouts and accumulated significantly more sedentary time in short bouts compared to boys.
- FCCHs meeting or exceeding childcare standards for outdoor active play, providing portable and fixed play equipment, and having adequate indoor play space showed significantly fewer sedentary bouts and less sedentary time in short and medium-length bouts.
- Specific practices like daily outdoor active play, availability of play equipment, and provider engagement in active play were strongly associated with reduced sedentary behavior. For instance, limiting computer use for educational purposes or games was associated with a large effect size (d=0.79) for reducing short sedentary bouts.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Accelerometer limitations: Hip-mounted accelerometers cannot distinguish between quiet sitting and motionless standing, potentially overestimating sedentary time. They also cannot differentiate between educational and non-educational sedentary activities (e.g., reading vs. watching TV).
- Data collection period: Data was collected between 2011 and 2012. While the policy environment for FCCHs has remained relatively stable, contemporary studies are needed to confirm findings.
- Self-reported practices: While the NAPSACC-SA is validated, provider practices were self-reported, introducing a potential for bias.
Future work should focus on developing and testing interventions specifically designed for FCCHs to implement the identified physical activity-promoting practices, aiming to reduce child sedentary time. Further research could also explore the nuances of different types of sedentary behavior and their impact on child development.
Summary updated