TL;DR
This qualitative study explores the perspectives of non-video consultation (VC) users with non-communicable diseases (NCDs) in Singapore. It reveals that while patients see VC as convenient and safe for stable conditions, they have concerns about suboptimal care due to the lack of physical examination, digital literacy, and healthcare costs. The findings suggest a hybrid model of in-person and VC is the most promising path forward for NCD management.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the adoption of telemedicine, including video consultations (VC), in healthcare. However, understanding patient perspectives is crucial for its widespread and effective integration, especially for managing chronic conditions like non-communicable diseases (NCDs). This paper addresses the gap in understanding the views and concerns of patients who have not yet used VC for their NCD management. Without this insight, policymakers and healthcare providers risk implementing solutions that don't meet patient needs or address their anxieties, potentially hindering the adoption of this valuable technology.
Methods
This study employed a qualitative research methodology, specifically individual in-depth interviews (IDIs). The researchers used a semi-structured interview guide, informed by the Health Information Technology Acceptance Model (HITAM). This model categorizes factors influencing technology adoption into "health," "information," and "technology" zones. The interviews were conducted with 16 patients who had NCDs (type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and/or hyperlipidaemia) but no prior VC experience. The data was analyzed using thematic analysis, with two investigators independently coding the transcripts to ensure reliability.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Stable" is the keyword: Patients with stable NCDs are more receptive to VC, viewing it as a minimal change to their existing treatment plans. This highlights the importance of patient stratification for VC implementation.
- Convenience is king, but not at the expense of care: The time and cost savings associated with VC are significant perceived benefits. However, this convenience is weighed against the fundamental need for perceived quality of care.
- The "physical exam" void: The absence of a physical examination is a primary concern, leading to worries about missing crucial diagnostic cues and the need for in-person visits for investigations. This points to a need for clear communication about what VC can and cannot achieve.
- Digital divide and cost barriers: Concerns about digital health familiarity and the availability of necessary devices (smartphones, internet) are significant hurdles, particularly for less tech-savvy or lower-income individuals. Healthcare costs, including potential out-of-pocket expenses for data or devices, also play a role.
- Data security is less of a worry than perceived: While network connectivity is a concern, participants generally felt that data managed through platforms like Zoom was secure. This suggests that trust in established platforms might mitigate some data privacy anxieties.
Key Results
The study identified three main themes:
- Perceived benefits of VC utility:
- Stable NCDs were suitable for VC: Patients felt VC was appropriate for managing their conditions when stable.
- Perceived safe environment: Patients saw VC as a way to avoid crowded clinics, especially during the pandemic, enhancing safety.
- Convenience and time-savings: VC was viewed as convenient due to reduced travel and waiting times, and potential cost savings from not taking time off work.
- Perceived barriers of VC adoption:
- Concern about suboptimal care: The lack of physical examination was a major concern, with participants believing in-person visits might be necessary for thorough assessments.
- Concern about medication supply: Participants highlighted the need for adequate medication at home, as delivery after VC might take time.
- Potential challenges of VC:
- Digital health familiarity: Less tech-savvy individuals expressed concerns about learning new technologies and anticipated needing help.
- Availability of own mobile and telemonitoring devices: Participants recognized that owning the necessary devices was a prerequisite for VC, posing a challenge for some.
- Healthcare expenses: Direct and indirect costs, including internet access and potential device costs, were seen as factors that could influence adoption, with a call for affordability.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- English-speaking participants only: The study was limited to participants who could understand and communicate in English, potentially excluding other demographic groups.
- No direct VC experience: Participants were non-users of VC, meaning their perspectives were based on anticipation rather than lived experience. However, this was also a strength, as it explored reasons for non-adoption.
- NCD scope: The study focused on NCDs that generally do not require frequent physical examinations. Findings may not generalize to respiratory NCDs like asthma or COPD.
Future work suggested includes:
- Research on NCDs requiring physical examination.
- Exploring the experiences of VC users and healthcare providers to gain a broader understanding of the VC system.
- Investigating the provision of home telemonitoring devices and self-administered tests to support VC adoption.
- Further exploration of hybrid clinical care models that combine in-person visits and VC.
Summary updated