Pathways for balancing CO2 emissions and sinks

S. Walsh, Philippe Ciais, Ivan A. Janssens, Josep Peñuelas, Keywan Riahi, Felicjan Rydzak, Detlef P. van Vuuren, Michael ObersteinerNature Communications 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses the FeliX model to project pathways for achieving global net decarbonization by 2100, as agreed in the Paris Agreement. The key finding is that anthropogenic CO2 emissions must peak within the next decade to realistically meet COP21 targets, requiring a drastic reduction in fossil fuel consumption and highlighting the critical need for negative emissions technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The 2015 Paris Agreement set ambitious goals for global temperature stabilization, aiming to limit warming to 1.5°C and achieve a balance between anthropogenic CO2 emissions and removals by sinks in the latter half of the century. However, the agreement lacked specific prescriptions for how countries should achieve these goals, leaving a significant gap in understanding the necessary transitions in energy and land-use sectors. This paper addresses this by using an integrated assessment model to explore various emissions mitigation pathways through 2100, considering carbon-climate feedbacks, and determining the feasibility of meeting these targets under different technological and policy assumptions.

Methods

The study employs the FeliX model, an integrated assessment model that links human and natural systems to project the economic and environmental impacts of various trends, policies, and technologies. The model incorporates complex interconnections among demographic, economic, land, energy, carbon, and climate systems, drawing on published models and data.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Scenario Development: The paper defines several scenarios:
  • Fossil Fuels: Assumes fossil fuels maintain a near-constant market share.
  • BAU (Business-as-Usual): Represents a continuation of recent trends in global land, energy, and carbon systems.
  • RE-Low and RE-High: Scenarios with modestly and rapidly accelerating reliance on renewable energies (REs), respectively.
  • CCS/Utilization Variants: The RE-Low and RE-High scenarios are further analyzed with the inclusion of carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) or utilization technologies.
  • Atmospheric Flux Ratio (RAF): A key metric is introduced, defined as the ratio of net CO2 emissions (anthropogenic sources minus artificial sinks) to net CO2 uptake by natural sinks. RAF > 1 indicates increasing atmospheric CO2, 0 < RAF < 1 indicates net negative flux towards stabilization, and RAF < 0 signifies net negative anthropogenic emissions (achieving the COP target).
  • Carbon-Climate Feedbacks: The model parameterizes carbon-climate feedbacks, including bio-stimulation of land sinks and climate impacts on ocean and land sink residence times.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: The study assesses the sensitivity of results to alternative primary energy demand projections and considers a range of equilibrium climate sensitivities (ECS).

Datasets

The study utilizes historical data from various sources for model calibration and validation:

  • International Energy Agency (IEA): For historical total primary energy demand.
  • Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC): Specifically, IPCC AR5 data for global atmospheric carbon flux and historical data for carbon emissions.
  • Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center (CDIAC): For historical CO2 emissions data.
  • Coupled Climate Carbon Cycle Model Intercomparison Project (C4MIP): For ensemble average values of climate and carbon cycle feedback parameters.
  • Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs): Used for comparison of emissions pathways and projections.
  • United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UNDESA): For population projections.
  • FAOSTAT: For land use data (agricultural, forest, urban/industrial, and 'other').
  • HadCRUT4: For historical global surface temperature anomaly data.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing datasets were integrated into the FeliX model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urgency of Peak Emissions: The most striking insight is the critical need for anthropogenic emissions to peak within the next 10 years (by 2025-2030) to maintain realistic pathways to meeting the COP21 targets. Delaying this peak significantly reduces the feasibility of achieving the goals.
  • Fossil Fuel Reduction is Non-Negotiable: To meet the targets, fossil fuel consumption must be drastically reduced, falling below a quarter of the primary energy supply by 2100. This reduction is even more pronounced if negative emissions technologies prove unfeasible.
  • Negative Emissions Technologies are Crucial: The study highlights that achieving net decarbonization, especially for the more ambitious warming targets (like 1.5°C), heavily relies on the development and deployment of negative emissions technologies (like CCS and direct air capture). Without them, the required fossil fuel reduction becomes even more severe.
  • Land Sinks are Important but Not Sufficient: While land and ocean sinks play a vital role in absorbing CO2, their capacity is finite and influenced by climate feedbacks. The paper emphasizes that these natural sinks alone cannot compensate for continued high emissions.
  • RE Transition is Necessary but Not Enough: While accelerating the transition to renewable energies (as in the RE-High scenario) significantly improves emissions trajectories, it is still insufficient on its own to meet the COP targets without additional measures like CCS.
  • The "Balance" is Dynamic: The concept of balancing emissions and sinks is shown to be dynamic. In deep decarbonization scenarios, natural sinks can even become net sources as atmospheric CO2 concentrations decrease, illustrating the complex feedback loops.

Key Results

  • Emissions Peak: In most scenarios, anthropogenic emissions peak between 2022 and 2054. The RE-High scenario sees the earliest peak around 2022.
  • Fossil Fuel Share: By 2100, the fossil fuel market share needs to be below 25% (RE-High scenario with CCS) to achieve the COP targets. In the Fossil Fuels scenario, it remains near 90%.
  • Temperature Targets:
    • The RE-High + CCS scenario is the only one projected to limit global warming below 1.5°C, achieving an anomaly of 1.2-1.4°C by 2100.
  • The RE-Low + CCS scenario approximates RCP 2.6, with a temperature anomaly of 1.6-1.7°C.
  • The BAU scenario projects a temperature anomaly of 3.1-3.3°C, comparable to RCP 6.0.
  • The Fossil Fuels scenario projects 3.4-3.6°C warming.
  • Atmospheric CO2 Concentration: By 2100, concentrations range from 328-363 ppm (RE-High + CCS) to 749-823 ppm (Fossil Fuels).
  • CCS Impact: Implementing CCS in the RE-Low and RE-High scenarios significantly reduces emissions and temperature anomalies, with RE-Low + CCS achieving net negative anthropogenic emissions (RAF < 0).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exogenous Non-CO2 Gases: The FeliX model does not endogenously model non-CO2 greenhouse gases (CH4, N2O, etc.). Their pathways are assumed to follow RCP 4.5, which could influence overall warming.
  • Limited Feedback Loops: While carbon-climate feedbacks are included, the model does not incorporate feedback loops where natural sinks might be influenced by anthropogenic emissions beyond direct climate impacts (e.g., permafrost thaw, carbon credits).
  • Technological Uncertainty: The feasibility and economic viability of negative emissions technologies (like CCS and direct air capture) remain significant uncertainties. The paper explores scenarios with and without these technologies, highlighting their critical role.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future iterations of the model should incorporate more detailed nutrient and water availability feedbacks to land sinks, as well as explore the socio-economic and political challenges of implementing these pathways. Further research into the economic feasibility and environmental impacts of large-scale CCS and other negative emissions technologies is also warranted. The paper also points to the need to consider the adaptation and finance goals of the Paris Agreement, which are beyond the scope of this emissions-focused analysis.

Summary updated

Abstract

In December 2015 in Paris, leaders committed to achieve global, net decarbonization of human activities before 2100. This achievement would halt and even reverse anthropogenic climate change through the net removal of carbon from the atmosphere. However, the Paris documents contain few specific prescriptions for emissions mitigation, leaving various countries to pursue their own agendas. In this analysis, we project energy and land-use emissions mitigation pathways through 2100, subject to best-available parameterization of carbon-climate feedbacks and interdependencies. We find that, barring unforeseen and transformative technological advancement, anthropogenic emissions need to peak within the next 10 years, to maintain realistic pathways to meeting the COP21 emissions and warming targets. Fossil fuel consumption will probably need to be reduced below a quarter of primary energy supply by 2100 and the allowable consumption rate drops even further if negative emissions technologies remain technologically or economically unfeasible at the global scale.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{walsh2017pathways,
  author = {S. Walsh and Philippe Ciais and Ivan A. Janssens and Josep Peñuelas and Keywan Riahi and Felicjan Rydzak and Detlef P. van Vuuren and Michael Obersteiner},
  title = {{Pathways for balancing CO2 emissions and sinks}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms14856},
}

Loading related content...

Figure