Pathway Aggregation in the Risk Assessment of Proliferation Resistance and Physical Protection (PR&PP) of Nuclear Energy Systems

Tunc Aldemir, Richard Denning, Ümit V. Çatalyürek, Alper Yılmaz, Meng Yue, Lap-Yan Cheng2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces OSUPR, a software tool that automates the generation and clustering of proliferation scenarios for nuclear energy systems. By applying clustering algorithms to complex pathway analyses, OSUPR helps identify system vulnerabilities and communicate major risk contributors more effectively.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Assessing the proliferation resistance and physical protection (PR&PP) of nuclear energy systems involves analyzing a vast number of potential pathways (sequences of events) that could lead to a proliferation objective. These pathways can become incredibly complex due to numerous interconnected stages, making it challenging to analyze them comprehensively and identify critical vulnerabilities. The paper addresses the need for a systematic and efficient method to manage and analyze this complexity, enabling better risk assessment and system optimization.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in the development of the OSUPR (Nuclear Energy Enabling Technologies) software tool. OSUPR integrates two key components:

  1. Scenario Generation: It utilizes the PRCALC (Proliferation Resistance and Physical Protection Assessment) code, which employs a Markov approach to model proliferation scenarios. This allows for the generation of a large number of scenarios based on defined challenges, system responses, and threat initiation events.
  2. Scenario Clustering: OSUPR implements and compares three clustering algorithms: K-means, Mean-shift, and Adaptive Mean-shift. These algorithms group similar scenarios based on their PRCALC outputs (e.g., probability of detection, proliferation time, probability of success) to facilitate analysis.

Datasets

The study uses the Example Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor (ESFR) as a case study. The "datasets" are generated scenarios based on the ESFR system's material flows and potential diversion points, as modeled by PRCALC. No pre-existing external datasets were used for training or evaluation; rather, the data was generated through the simulation of various diversion scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clustering is Crucial for Complexity Management: The sheer number of potential proliferation pathways necessitates sophisticated analysis techniques. Clustering provides a way to group similar scenarios, making it feasible to identify patterns and vulnerabilities that would be lost in a sea of individual data points.
  • Mean-Shift Algorithm Shows Promise: Among the tested clustering algorithms, the Mean-shift algorithm demonstrated the most potential for assisting in the analysis of scenarios generated by PRCALC, likely due to its ability to handle arbitrary cluster shapes.
  • Safeguards are Key Differentiators: The analysis highlighted that certain safeguard categories (specifically Category 2, related to physical inspections and inventory verification) are critical in reducing the probability of success for proliferators and increasing detection probability.
  • Diversion Rate Impacts Outcomes: Increased diversion rates at certain stages (e.g., TRU Extraction) can lead to less desirable outcomes for proliferators, suggesting that these stages are more sensitive to diversion efforts.

Key Results

  • The OSUPR software tool was successfully developed, enabling automated scenario generation and clustering.
  • The study demonstrated that clustering facilitates the probabilistic and deterministic analysis of scenarios, aiding in the identification of system vulnerabilities.
  • The Mean-shift algorithm was identified as having the most potential for assisting in the analysis of PRCALC-generated scenarios.
  • Analysis of the ESFR system revealed that specific safeguard categories are important for preventing diversion, and increased diversion rates at certain stages can negatively impact proliferation outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bandwidth Sensitivity: The Mean-shift algorithm's sensitivity to the bandwidth parameter was noted, leading to the exploration of adaptive Mean-shift.
  • K-means Limitations: K-means clustering was found to be sensitive to initialization and outliers, and struggled with unbalanced clusters and non-globular shapes.
  • CCC and ADT Suggest Larger Cluster Numbers: While BIC and AIC suggested an optimal number of clusters around 24, CCC and ADT indicated that a much larger number of clusters might be more appropriate, suggesting that K-means' assumption of cluster shape might be violated.
  • Future Work: The authors recommend augmenting the Markov model to include expected residence time in each stage as an additional output variable. This would allow for time sequencing of events and identification of stages most attractive to proliferators based on available time. The OSUPR clustering techniques are expected to be applicable to these augmented scenario vectors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The framework for Proliferation Resistance and Physical Protection (PR & PP) evaluation is to define a set of challenges, to obtain the system responses, and to assess the outcomes. The assessment of outcomes heavily relies on pathways, defined as sequences of events or actions that could potentially be followed by a State or a group of individuals in order to achieve a proliferation objective, with the defined threats as initiating events. There may be large number of segments connecting pathway stages (e.g. acquisition, processing, and fabrication for PR) which can lead to even larger number of pathways or scenarios through possible different combinations of segment connections, each with associated probabilities contributing to the overall risk. Clustering of these scenarios in specified stage attribute intervals is important for their tractable analysis and outcome assessment. A software tool for scenario generation and clustering (OSUPR) is developed that utilizes the PRCALC code developed at the Brookhaven National Laboratory for scenario generation and the K- means, mean shift and adaptive mean shift algorithms as possible clustering schemes. The results of the study using the Example Sodium Fast Breeder as an example system show that clustering facilitates the probabilistic or deterministic analysis of scenarios to identify system vulnerabilities and communication of the major risk contributors to stakeholders. The results of the study also show that the mean shift algorithm has the most potential for assisting the analysis of the scenarios generated by PRCALC.
BibTeX
@misc{aldemir2015pathway,
  author = {Tunc Aldemir and Richard Denning and Ümit V. Çatalyürek and Alper Yılmaz and Meng Yue and Lap-Yan Cheng},
  title = {{Pathway Aggregation in the Risk Assessment of Proliferation Resistance and Physical Protection (PR\&PP) of Nuclear Energy Systems}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2172/1172631},
}

Loading related content...

Figure