Path Learning with Trajectory Advantage Regression

Kohei MiyaguchiarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Finding optimal sequences of actions from historical data—a task known as Path Learning (PL)—is a critical challenge in domains ranging from logistics to sequence design. Traditional approaches often struggle to balance the simplicity of regression with the planning capabilities of Reinforcement Learning (RL). This paper introduces Trajectory Advantage Regression (TAR), a theoretical framework that reduces Path Learning to a straightforward regression problem. By decomposing the value of a trajectory into a maximum potential yield minus a series of step-wise "drawdowns" (regrets), TAR allows for optimal path identification using standard least-squares objectives. We provide formal proofs establishing TAR as a mathematically sound surrogate for complex RL optimization techniques.

Introduction

In many real-world applications, such as traffic routing or industrial process optimization, the goal is to identify a sequence of actions that maximizes a specific outcome, or "yield." Often, we are restricted to learning from offline data: historical records of paths taken and their resulting yields, without the luxury of real-time experimentation.

Existing methodologies typically fall into two camps: pure regression and offline Reinforcement Learning. Pure regression models excel at predicting outcomes but offer little guidance on how to iteratively plan an optimal path. Conversely, offline RL provides a framework for planning but is frequently plagued by computational complexity and stability issues. This paper bridges this gap by introducing Trajectory Advantage Regression (TAR), a framework that leverages the simplicity of regression to solve the optimization challenges of Path Learning.

Methodology

The TAR framework is built upon a two-step theoretical bridge that connects Path Learning to established Reinforcement Learning principles.

1. PL-to-RL Reduction

The paper first establishes that any offline path learning problem can be formally framed as a Markov Decision Process (MDP). In this reduction, the "state" is defined as the sequence of actions taken up to a specific point, and the "reward" is a sparse signal revealed only at the conclusion of the trajectory. This mapping allows Path Learning to inherit the robust mathematical tools of RL.

2. Advantage Decomposition and the "Drawdown" Intuition

The core innovation of TAR is the decomposition of the optimal value function ($V^*$) into a sum of step-wise advantages. The value of a specific path $a^T$ is represented as:

$$V_\theta(a^T) = c_\theta + \sum_{k=1}^T A_\theta(a^{k-1}, a_k)$$

In this formulation, $c_\theta$ represents the maximum possible yield achievable in the environment. The advantage function $A_\theta$, crucially, is constrained to be non-positive. This allows for a powerful intuition: each action $a_k$ represents a potential "drawdown" or regret. If the action is optimal, the drawdown is zero; if sub-optimal, the value of the path is reduced by the magnitude of the advantage.

3. The TAR Objective

By utilizing this decomposition, the paper demonstrates that finding the optimal policy does not require solving complex Bellman equations. Instead, one can minimize a simple least-squares regression objective between the predicted path value and the actual observed yield. Because the model is structured to identify drawdowns, minimizing the prediction error naturally identifies the actions that minimize regret, thereby revealing the optimal path.

Theoretical Results

As a theoretical contribution, the paper provides several formal proofs to validate the TAR approach:

  • Proposition 3.1: Confirms that the optimal policy derived within the reduced RL environment corresponds exactly to the optimal path in the original Path Learning problem.
  • Theorem 4.1: Establishes the TAR objective function as a mathematically sound surrogate for Value Linear Programming (V-LP), a standard but more complex optimization method in RL.
  • Corollary 4.1: Proves that for sufficiently expressive models, the parameters that minimize the TAR regression objective are identical to those that would solve the penalized V-LP problem.

Discussion: Explainability and Simplicity

Beyond its mathematical properties, TAR offers significant practical advantages in terms of interpretability. Because the total yield is decomposed into step-by-step contributions, the model is inherently explainable. Stakeholders can analyze a sub-optimal path and identify the specific step where the "drawdown" occurred, quantifying exactly how much potential yield was lost due to a specific decision.

Furthermore, by reducing the problem to regression, TAR bypasses the heavy machinery of Q-learning or Policy Gradients. This suggests a more stable and accessible path for practitioners to implement optimal planning in offline settings.

Limitations and Future Work

While the theoretical foundation of TAR is robust, the paper notes several areas for future exploration:

  • Empirical Validation: The current work is entirely theoretical. Future research is required to test TAR against existing algorithms (such as RETRACE) using real-world datasets or synthetic benchmarks.
  • Function Approximation: The stability of the advantage decomposition across different neural network architectures remains an open question.
  • Algorithmic Extensions: There is potential to explore whether this regression-based formulation can be extended to other RL formalisms beyond the V-LP framework.

Conclusion

Trajectory Advantage Regression provides a novel and mathematically rigorous way to treat path optimization as a regression task. By framing sub-optimal actions as measurable "drawdowns" against a maximum potential yield, TAR offers a promising path toward offline learning models that are both high-performing and inherently interpretable.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose trajectory advantage regression, a method of offline path learning and path attribution based on reinforcement learning. The proposed method can be used to solve path optimization problems while algorithmically only solving a regression problem.
BibTeX
@misc{miyaguchi2025path,
  author = {Kohei Miyaguchi},
  title = {{Path Learning with Trajectory Advantage Regression}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2506.19375},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.19375},
}
Figure