Passive Sliding Mode Controlled UPFC and its Treatment Strategy of Unbalanced Grid Conditions

Yang Chen, Han Wang, Miao Zhu, Ming Liu, Jianjun Ma, Xu CaiFrontiers in Energy Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Modular multilevel converter based unified power flow controllers (MMC-UPFC) are vital for flexible power regulation in smart grids and future distribution networks. While PI controllers are standard, they often struggle with stability and dynamic performance under parameter variations. This paper proposes a hybrid Passive Sliding Mode Control (P-SMC) strategy that combines the inherent stability of passive control with the robustness of sliding mode techniques. Additionally, a series-side treatment strategy for unbalanced grid conditions is introduced, utilizing a second-order generalized integrator (SOGI) for negative sequence compensation. Simulations based on the Shanghai UPFC Project demonstrate rapid response times and significant reductions in current unbalance from 16% to 0.5%.

The Challenge of Modern Power Flow

In the quest for a "smarter" grid, the Unified Power Flow Controller (UPFC) acts as a high-tech traffic controller, simultaneously managing active and reactive power. However, two major hurdles persist in current implementations:

  1. Control Complexity: Traditional PI (Proportional-Integral) controllers are notoriously difficult to tune for both stability and high-speed dynamic performance, especially when system parameters fluctuate.
  2. Grid Unbalance: Modern distribution networks are often asymmetrical due to varying loads and line impedances. These create "negative sequence components" that degrade power quality and stress equipment. While shunt-side converters often handle local compensation, using the series side of a UPFC to treat grid-wide unbalance remains a relatively unexplored frontier.

Proposed Solution: Hybrid P-SMC

The authors propose a two-pronged solution to these challenges:

  • Passive Sliding Mode Control (P-SMC): This hybrid controller fuses Passive Control (based on the system's energy attributes to ensure stability) with Sliding Mode Control (SMC) (famed for its robustness against parameter variations). The result is a controller that is inherently stable but resistant to real-world noise and delays.
  • Unbalanced Grid Treatment Strategy: The system uses a Second Order Generalized Integrator (SOGI) with a cross-decoupling method to instantly detect negative sequence components. The series side of the MMC-UPFC then injects a compensating voltage to cancel these sequences, forcing transmission line currents back into symmetry.
Figure 1: Typical topology and application of MMC-UPFC in the power grid, showing the shunt and series side MMCs and the detailed half-bridge submodule structure.

System Topology and Validation

The study utilizes a modular multilevel converter (MMC) architecture, as shown in the figure above. The series side converter is uniquely designed to multitask: it controls power flow while simultaneously treating unbalanced grid conditions.

To validate this approach, the authors built a high-fidelity 27-level MMC-UPFC simulation system in MATLAB/Simulink. The simulation parameters—including a 220 kV grid voltage and 400 MW line power—were modeled directly after the Shanghai UPFC Project in China.

Key Results and Insights

The simulation results provided strong quantitative evidence for the P-SMC's superiority:

  • Dynamic Response: When power references were changed, the P-SMC responded immediately (within ~0.1s) with zero steady-state error.
  • Robustness: Under scenarios involving control delays and a 10% change in line impedance, the P-SMC remained stable while traditional PI controllers began to fluctuate wildly.
  • Unbalance Mitigation: The strategy reduced voltage unbalance from 36% to 0.7% and current unbalance from 16% to 0.5%, effectively returning the grid to a symmetrical state.

One critical insight from the paper is the "voltage budget" trade-off: because the converter has a finite voltage limit, using capacity to fix unbalance slightly narrows the total range available for aggressive power steering. However, the gain in overall grid efficiency and equipment protection outweighs this limitation.

Conclusion

By combining energy-based passive control with robust sliding mode techniques, the P-SMC strategy offers a more resilient and responsive solution for modern power grids. The ability of the series-side MMC to simultaneously regulate power and mitigate unbalance represents a significant step forward in maximizing the utility of UPFC hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

Modular multilevel converter based unified power flow controller (MMC-UPFC) can provide flexible power regulation and plays an important role in the smart grid and future distribution networks. PI controller is widely adopted in the Unified power flow controller (UPFC) control. However, it is often difficult to figure out a pair of stable control parameters with good dynamic performance. A passive sliding mode control strategy of MMC-UPFC is proposed in this paper to achieve the advantages of both the passive controller and sliding mode controller. The proposed passive sliding mode control strategy has a fast response speed and is not sensitive to system parameter variation. Since unbalance grid voltage conditions are common in the modern distribution networks, an unbalanced grid treatment strategy is also presented with the series side of MMC-UPFC. Negative sequence components of the grid voltages are detected by the cross-decoupling method with second order generalized integrator and then compensated by the series side of MMC-UPFC. The series side converter controls the power flow and treats unbalanced grid conditions simultaneously. The efficiency of the general device is increased thus. A 27-level MMC-UPFC simulation system is built based on the Shanghai UPFC Project and validate the proposed approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2021passive,
  author = {Yang Chen and Han Wang and Miao Zhu and Ming Liu and Jianjun Ma and Xu Cai},
  title = {{Passive Sliding Mode Controlled UPFC and its Treatment Strategy of Unbalanced Grid Conditions}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2021.712397},
}
Figure