Parton Distribution of Proton in a Simple Statistical Model

Yimeng Zhang, B. S. Zou, Liming YangarXiv 2001 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel statistical model to explain the observed asymmetry between up and down sea quarks within a proton. By treating the proton as an ensemble of quark-gluon Fock states and applying the principle of detailed balance, the authors successfully reproduce experimental data on this asymmetry, suggesting it arises from a fundamental statistical effect rather than complex QCD dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the internal structure of protons is fundamental to particle physics. For decades, it was assumed that the "sea" of quark-antiquark pairs within a proton was symmetric with respect to flavor (i.e., equal numbers of up and anti-up quarks as down and anti-down quarks). However, recent experiments have revealed a surprising asymmetry, with more anti-up quarks than anti-down quarks in the proton's sea. This discrepancy challenges existing models, which often struggle to explain this phenomenon without invoking complex, non-perturbative QCD effects or specific mesonic degrees of freedom. The authors aim to provide a simpler explanation for this observed sea quark asymmetry.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach is a simple statistical model. They conceptualize the proton as a collection of various quark-gluon Fock states. The key idea is to apply the principle of detailed balance to transitions between these states, which are driven by the creation and annihilation of partons.

Crucially, they make two main assumptions:

  1. Equal Probability for Energy Configurations: For a given number of partons ($n$) in a Fock state, all possible energy configurations of these partons are equally probable.
  2. Statistical Origin of Asymmetry: The asymmetry arises not from fundamental differences in quark-antiquark pair production, but from the fact that there are more valence up quarks than down quarks in the proton. This leads to a higher probability of anti-up quarks annihilating compared to anti-down quarks.

To implement this, they use a Monte Carlo simulation with an event generator called GENEV. This allows them to calculate the momentum distribution of partons within different Fock states and then, by summing over all possible states weighted by their probabilities, derive the overall parton distribution functions for the proton. They define the Bjorken-x distribution using a light-front formula.

Datasets

The paper compares its model predictions to experimental data from:

  • FNAL E866/NuSea Collaboration: Specifically, results from experiments measuring the $d(x) - \bar{u}(x)$ asymmetry.
  • HERMES Collaboration: Also providing data on the sea quark asymmetry.

The authors do not introduce new datasets but rather use existing experimental measurements to validate their theoretical model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Statistical Origin of Sea Quark Asymmetry: The most significant insight is the proposal that the observed $d(x) - \bar{u}(x)$ asymmetry can be a purely statistical effect, stemming from the underlying valence quark content of the proton.
  • Detailed Balance as a Unifying Principle: The application of detailed balance to Fock state transitions provides a powerful framework for constructing parton distribution functions without relying solely on perturbative QCD.
  • Monte Carlo Simulation for Complex Systems: The use of Monte Carlo methods is highlighted as an effective way to explore the phase space of multi-parton states and derive observable distributions.
  • Q² Independence of Intrinsic Asymmetry: The paper suggests that the "intrinsic" sea quark asymmetry (arising from the model's core assumptions) is largely independent of the momentum transfer scale ($Q^2$), which aligns with experimental observations.

Key Results

  • The model successfully reproduces the observed Bjorken-x dependent light flavor sea quark asymmetry, $d(x) - \bar{u}(x)$, with good agreement with recent experimental data from FNAL E866/NuSea and HERMES.
  • The calculated parton distribution densities (for $u, d, \bar{u}, \bar{d}, g$) at a low scale ($\mu_0 \approx 0.168$ GeV) are presented and compared visually with other theoretical models and experimental data.
  • The model predicts that the intrinsic sea quark asymmetry is largely $Q^2$ independent, a feature supported by experimental findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The paper acknowledges that it uses a "simple statistical model." While this simplicity is its strength in explaining the asymmetry, it may not capture all the nuances of proton structure.
  • Comparison with QCD Evolution: The authors mention that it would be "interesting to check whether with some QCD evolution equation our $xf(x, \mu_0^2)$ distribution could evolve into a momentum distribution $xf(x, Q^2)$ at higher $Q^2$ to be similar to the GRV's." This suggests a potential avenue for future work to connect their statistical model to established QCD evolution frameworks.
  • Focus on Light Flavors: The model primarily focuses on light flavor sea quarks ($u, d$). Future work could explore the inclusion of heavier quarks or more complex Fock states.

Note: The abstract mentions that "This paper has been withdrawn by the authors. due fail of replacement of the paper. new version is hep-ph/0201214." This is an important piece of metadata to consider when interpreting the paper's contribution and its place in the scientific literature. The summary above reflects the content as presented in the provided PDF.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper has been withdrawn by the authors. due fail of replacement of the paper. new version is hep-ph/0201214.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2001parton,
  author = {Yimeng Zhang and B. S. Zou and Liming Yang},
  title = {{Parton Distribution of Proton in a Simple Statistical Model}},
  year = {2001},
  eprint = {hep-ph/0106263},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0106263},
}

Loading related content...

Figure