Partitioning the hypercube into smaller hypercubes

Noga Alon, József Balogh, Potapov, Vladimir N.Illinois 2023 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper provides the first rigorous asymptotic estimates for the number of ways to partition a $d$-dimensional hypercube into smaller sub-hypercubes. The authors prove that while the number of such partitions is exponentially larger than the number of perfect matchings (tilings using only edges), it remains within the same general asymptotic order of magnitude, specifically bounded by $(d+1)^{2^{d-1}}$.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The $d$-dimensional hypercube ($Q_d$) is a cornerstone of discrete mathematics and computer science. A "partition" or "tiling" of $Q_d$ is a collection of vertex-disjoint sub-hypercubes (of any dimension from 0 to $d$) that together cover every vertex of the original cube.

While the number of perfect matchings (partitions using only 1-dimensional edges) has been studied for decades, the total number of ways to partition the cube using any size of sub-cube—denoted as $f(d)$—was poorly understood. This problem is not just a combinatorial curiosity; it has direct implications for:

  • Boolean Networks: $f(d)$ counts the number of bijective commutative Boolean networks of dimension $d$.
  • SAT Solvers: It represents the number of ways to construct a "tautology" from disjoint terms, or more simply, the number of SAT instances where every possible truth assignment fails exactly one clause.

Methods

The authors employ a mix of classical combinatorial inequalities and modern probabilistic techniques:

  • Combinatorial Encoding: To establish an upper bound, they show that any partition can be uniquely encoded as a sequence of length $n = 2^{d-1}$ over an alphabet of size $d+1$. This elegantly proves that $f(d) \leq (d+1)^n$.
  • Probabilistic Method: To prove the lower bound, the authors use a "nibble-like" approach. They randomly select a small fraction of 2-dimensional sub-cubes, remove overlaps, and then show that the remaining "holes" can be filled with matchings in a vast number of ways.
  • Classical Bounds: They leverage the Bregman-Minc inequality (for upper bounds on matchings) and Schrijver’s bound (for lower bounds) to compare the total number of partitions to the number of perfect matchings.
  • Recursive Construction: For the specific case of "irreducible tight" partitions (partitions that use every coordinate and cannot be simplified), they use an inductive argument to show their numbers also grow exponentially.

Datasets

As a theoretical mathematics paper, no external datasets were used. The authors reference specific values for small $d$ from the Online Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences (OEIS), specifically sequence A018926, which lists $f(d)$ for $d=0$ to $5$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Exponential Jump": The most significant finding is that allowing 2-dimensional sub-cubes (squares) in the partition creates an exponential explosion in the number of possibilities compared to using only 0-dimensional points or 1-dimensional edges.
  • Subexponential Ratios: While the jump from edges to squares is massive, the authors show that the ratio between different types of matchings (perfect vs. non-perfect) is only subexponential ($2^{\Theta(n/\sqrt{d})}$), meaning they are "close" in the grand scheme of hypercube asymptotics.
  • Encoding Efficiency: The fact that a complex tiling can be reduced to a simple sequence of length $n$ suggests that these partitions have a much more constrained structure than one might intuitively expect.
  • SAT Equivalence: The paper highlights a beautiful bridge between geometry and logic: partitioning a cube is identical to creating a set of logical constraints where every possible world violates exactly one rule.

Key Results

  • Asymptotic Order: The number of partitions $f(d)$ satisfies $c^n \cdot m(d) \leq f(d) \leq (d+1)^n$, where $m(d)$ is the number of perfect matchings and $c > 1$ is a constant.
  • Upper Bound: $f(d) \leq (d+1)^n \leq e^{n + n/d} \cdot N$, where $N$ is a rough estimate of perfect matchings.
  • Lower Bound on Complexity: The number of "irreducible tight" partitions is at least $c^n$ for some $c > 1$.
  • Hierarchy of Tilings: The authors establish a clear hierarchy: $$\text{Perfect Matchings} \leq \text{All Matchings} \leq \text{Tilings with } \{0,1,2\}\text{-cubes} \leq \text{All Tilings}$$ They prove that the first inequality is a subexponential gap, while the third is an exponential gap.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exact Constants: While the authors prove $f(d)$ is exponentially larger than $m(d)$, they do not determine the optimal constant $c$.
  • The $f_2(d)$ Mystery: A remaining open question (Problem 1.9) is the asymptotic behavior of partitions that use only 2-dimensional sub-cubes.
  • Subexponential Gaps: The authors conjecture, but do not prove, that the ratio $f(d) / f_{\leq 2}(d)$ (the impact of using sub-cubes of dimension 3 or higher) is subexponential. This would imply that almost all the "variety" in hypercube partitions comes from the 0, 1, and 2-dimensional components.

Summary updated

Abstract

Denote by Q_d the d-dimensional hypercube. Addressing a recent question we estimate the number of ways the vertex set of Q_d can be partitioned into vertex disjoint smaller cubes. Among other results, we prove that the asymptotic order of this function is not much larger than the number of perfect matchings of Q_d. We also describe several new (and old) questions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alon2023partitioning,
  author = {Noga Alon and József Balogh and Potapov, Vladimir N.},
  title = {{Partitioning the hypercube into smaller hypercubes}},
  booktitle = {Illinois},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure