TL;DR
This study investigates how the particle size of curcumin nanocrystals (NCs) affects their delivery through the skin using dissolving microneedles (MNs). They found that smaller curcumin NCs (60 nm) delivered via MNs penetrate deeper into the skin and hair follicles more effectively than larger NCs, offering a promising strategy for enhanced topical drug delivery.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The skin's outermost layer, the stratum corneum (SC), acts as a formidable barrier, significantly hindering the transdermal delivery of many drugs, especially poorly soluble ones. While microneedles (MNs) offer a way to bypass this barrier by creating temporary pathways, the optimal characteristics of drug carriers within these MNs for effective skin penetration remain an area of active research. Specifically, for drug nanocrystals (NCs), which are gaining traction due to their high drug loading and potential for targeted delivery, understanding how their particle size influences their journey through the skin and into appendages like hair follicles (HF) is crucial for optimizing therapeutic outcomes. This paper aims to elucidate the specific role of curcumin NC particle size in transdermal and transfollicular delivery when incorporated into dissolving hyaluronic acid (HA) microneedles.
Methods
The researchers fabricated curcumin nanocrystals (CUR-NCs) with three distinct particle sizes: 60 nm, 120 nm, and 480 nm, using an anti-solvent precipitation method. These CUR-NCs were then incorporated into dissolving hyaluronic acid microneedles (HA-MNs) via a two-layer centrifugation method. The mechanical strength and insertion properties of the fabricated MNs were assessed using a texture analyzer and by testing their penetration through Parafilm® M and porcine skin.
To evaluate transdermal and transfollicular penetration, ex vivo porcine skin models were used. CUR-NCs were applied via the HA-MNs, and their penetration and distribution within the skin layers and hair follicles were visualized using fluorescence microscopy and 3D z-stack imaging. The amount of CUR that permeated the skin was quantified using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC). Additionally, the retention of CUR in hair follicles (HF) and skin without hair follicles (no-HF) was analyzed after 48 hours.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized ex vivo porcine skin as the biological model for evaluating drug penetration.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Size Matters for Skin Penetration: The most significant finding is the clear demonstration that smaller CUR-NCs (60 nm) exhibit superior transdermal penetration and deeper diffusion within the skin layers compared to their larger counterparts (120 nm and 480 nm) when delivered via MNs.
- MNs Enhance Delivery: The use of HA-MNs significantly improved CUR delivery compared to a simple gel formulation, highlighting the efficacy of MNs in overcoming the SC barrier.
- Hair Follicle Targeting is Size-Dependent (for initial uptake): While the total accumulation of CUR in hair follicles after 48 hours was not significantly different across particle sizes, the rate of accumulation was higher for smaller NCs, suggesting faster initial entry into the HF.
- Concentration Gradients Drive Diffusion: Smaller NCs create steeper concentration gradients within the skin, which, according to Fick's first law, drives higher passive diffusion. This is further supported by the formation of more extensive "diffusional coronas" around smaller NCs.
- Amorphous State of NCs: Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) revealed that the CUR-NCs were in an amorphous state, which is generally associated with enhanced solubility and dissolution rates.
Key Results
- CUR-NCs with sizes of 60 ± 1.7 nm, 116 ± 7.3 nm, and 488 ± 8.5 nm were successfully fabricated.
- The HA-MNs exhibited good mechanical strength (≥0.14 N/needle) and insertion efficiency (96.9 ± 1.2% in porcine skin).
- After 48 hours, CUR-MNs showed approximately a two-fold higher cumulative permeation of CUR compared to a CUR-gel formulation.
- The 60 nm CUR-MNs demonstrated a 1.5- to 2-fold higher permeation in the first 4 hours compared to 120 nm and 480 nm CUR-MNs.
- The mean penetration depth (MPD) of CUR from 60 nm CUR-MNs was significantly greater (581 ± 61.92 µm) at 1 hour compared to 120 nm (411 ± 17.68 µm) and 480 nm (315 ± 50.5 µm) CUR-MNs.
- CUR fluorescence was observed in all skin layers with 60 nm CUR-MNs after 1 hour, indicating effective permeation.
- The retention of CUR in hair follicles was about 2.3-fold higher than in skin without hair follicles, confirming HF as a significant pathway.
Limitations and Future Work
- In Vivo Studies Needed: The study was conducted using ex vivo porcine skin. Future work should involve in vivo studies to confirm these findings in a living system and to investigate the cellular uptake and efflux mechanisms of NCs.
- HF Accumulation Dynamics: While total HF accumulation after 48 hours was similar, the initial rapid diffusion of smaller NCs into HFs warrants further investigation into the long-term fate and potential therapeutic implications of this early accumulation.
- Optimization of MNs and NCs: The authors suggest that controlling the particle size of drug NCs and the matrix materials of MNs can lead to promising expectations for drug control release and improved therapeutic efficacy for various skin conditions. Further research could focus on optimizing these parameters for specific drug targets.
Summary updated