Partial wave analysis of J/ψ→γ(π+π−π+π−)

J.z. Bai, Y. Ban, J. G. Bian, A.d. Chen, G.p. Chen, H.f. Chen, H.s. Chen, J.c. Chen, X.d. Chen, Y. Chen, B. Cheng, X. Z. Cui, Hao Ding, L. Y. Dong, Zhaocheng Du, C. S. Gao, M. Gao, Shipeng Gao, J. H. Gu, S. Gu, W. X. Gu, Y.n. Guo, Z. J. Guo, S. W. Han, Y. L. Han, Jun He, K. L. He, M. He, Y. K. Heng, G. Y. Hu, H. Hu, Jiangsheng Hu, Qin Hu, G. S. Huang, X. P. Huang, Yizhong Huang, Chun-Hua Jiang, Y. Jin, X. Ju, Z. J. Ke, Y. F. Lai, P. F. Lang, C.g. Li, Da Li, H.b. Li, J. Li, P.q. Li, Weijie Li, Wenmi Li, X.h. Li, X.n. Li, X.q. Li, Z.c. Li, B. Liu, F. Liu, H.m. Liu, J. Liu, R.g. Liu, Y. Liu, Z.x. Liu, G. R. Lu, F. Lu, J. G. Lu, X. L. Luo, E.c. Ma, Jun Ma, H. S. Mao, Z. P. Mao, X. C. Meng, X. H. Mo, J. Nie, N. D. Qi, X. R. Qi, C. D. Qian, J. F. Qiu, Y. H. Qu, Y. K. Que, G. Rong, Y. Shao, B. W. Shen, D. L. Shen, Hong Shen, Hangjia Shen, X. Y. Shen, F. Shi, H. Shi, X. F. Song, H. Sun, L. Sun, Yao Sun, S. Q. Tang, G. L. Tong, F. Wang, Linlin WangPhysics 2000 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The search for glueballs—bound states of gluons predicted by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD)—remains a central objective in hadron spectroscopy. Because gluons carry color charge, they can interact with one another, potentially forming states without valence quarks. Radiative $J/\psi$ decays, specifically $J/\psi \to \gamma + \text{hadrons}$, provide an ideal "gluon-rich" environment for this search, as the initial charm-anticharm ($c\bar{c}$) pair annihilates into a photon and two gluons. This paper presents a detailed partial wave analysis (PWA) of the $J/\psi \to \gamma(\pi^+\pi^-\pi^+\pi^-)$ decay channel using data from the Beijing Spectrometer (BES).

Experimental Methodology and Data Selection

The study utilized a sample of $7.8 \times 10^6$ $J/\psi$ triggers collected at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPC). To isolate the $\gamma\pi^+\pi^-\pi^+\pi^-$ final state, researchers applied stringent selection criteria to minimize backgrounds from $J/\psi \to \pi^0\pi^+\pi^-\pi^+\pi^-$ and other multi-pion processes where a photon might be misidentified.

After kinematic fitting and background subtraction, a final sample of 1,988 clean events was obtained. The analysis accounted for detector acceptance and efficiency using a high-fidelity Monte Carlo simulation of the BES detector, representing a significant technical improvement over previous studies by the MARK III and DM2 experiments.

Partial Wave Analysis (PWA)

The complexity of the four-pion final state requires PWA to disentangle overlapping resonances. The team employed a maximum likelihood fit to the data, modeling the intermediate states as resonances with specific spin-parity ($J^{PC}$) assignments.

Key components of the modeling included:

  • Breit-Wigner Distributions: Used to describe the short-lived intermediate resonances.
  • Decay Channels: The analysis considered various decay chains, including $J/\psi \to \gamma X$ where $X$ decays into $\rho\rho$, $\sigma\sigma$ (the broad $\pi\pi$ S-wave), $f_2(1270)\sigma$, or $a_2(1320)\pi$.
  • Statistical Validation: The researchers performed "drop tests"—removing individual resonances from the fit—to ensure that every identified particle was statistically necessary to explain the experimental data.

Results and Discussion

The PWA successfully resolved six distinct resonances within the $4\pi$ mass spectrum, providing a clearer picture of the scalar and tensor states in this energy region.

Scalar Resonances ($0^{++}$)

Three scalar states were identified at 1500 MeV, 1740 MeV, and 2104 MeV. Notably, the $f_0(1500)$ and $f_0(1740)$ are produced significantly in this gluon-rich environment. These are considered prime candidates for containing glueball components, supporting theoretical models regarding the mixing of glueballs with standard quark-antiquark mesons.

Tensor Resonances ($2^{++}$)

The analysis identified tensor states at 1275 MeV, 1565 MeV, and 1940 MeV. A critical finding was the necessity of the broad $f_2(1940)$ resonance; without this state, the model could not accurately replicate the observed data. The team also observed a shift in decay dynamics: lower-mass tensors tend to decay into $\rho\rho$, while higher-mass tensors prefer the $f_2(1270)\sigma$ mode.

Branching Fraction and Conclusions

The total branching fraction for the decay $J/\psi \to \gamma(\pi^+\pi^-\pi^+\pi^-)$ was measured to be $(3.8 \pm 0.3 \pm 1.3) \times 10^{-3}$.

This analysis provides strong evidence for the production of scalar and tensor resonances in radiative $J/\psi$ decays. While the current sample of 1,988 events allowed for a robust PWA, the researchers noted that the overlap between the broad $\sigma$ and $\rho$ mesons remains a complex area of the fit. Future experiments with higher statistics, such as those planned for BES II and BES III, will be essential to further refine the masses and widths of these states and definitively confirm their exotic nature.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2000partial,
  author = {J.Z. Bai and Y. Ban and J. G. Bian and A.D. Chen and G.P. Chen and H.F. Chen and H.S. Chen and J.C. Chen and X.D. Chen and Y. Chen and Yuanbo Chen and B. Cheng and X. Z. Cui and Hao Ding and L. Y. Dong and Zhaocheng Du and C. S. Gao and M. Gao and Shipeng Gao and J. H. Gu and S. Gu and W. X. Gu and Y.N. Guo and Z. J. Guo and S. W. Han and Y. L. Han and Jun He and Jun He and K. L. He and M. He and Y. K. Heng and G. Y. Hu and H. Hu and Jiangsheng Hu and Qin Hu and J. F. Hu and G. S. Huang and X. P. Huang and Yizhong Huang and Chun-Hua Jiang and Y. Jin and X. Ju and Z. J. Ke and Y. F. Lai and P. F. Lang and C.G. Li and Da Li and H.B. Li and J. Li and J.C. Li and P.Q. Li and Weijie Li and Wenmi Li and X.H. Li and X.N. Li and X.Q. Li and Z.C. Li and B. Liu and F. Liu and Feng Liu and H.M. Liu and J. Liu and Jun Liu and R.G. Liu and Y. Liu and Z.X. Liu and G. R. Lu and F. Lu and J. G. Lu and X. L. Luo and E.C. Ma and Jun Ma and H. S. Mao and Z. P. Mao and X. C. Meng and X. H. Mo and J. Nie and N. D. Qi and X. R. Qi and C. D. Qian and J. F. Qiu and Y. H. Qu and Y. K. Que and G. Rong and Y. Shao and B. W. Shen and D. L. Shen and Hong Shen and Hangjia Shen and X. Y. Shen and F. Shi and H. Shi and X. F. Song and H. Sun and L. Sun and Yao Sun and S. Q. Tang and G. L. Tong and F. Wang and Linlin Wang},
  title = {{Partial wave analysis of J/ψ→γ(π+π−π+π−)}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.1016/s0370-2693(99)01393-3},
}
Figure