Parsing the Role of the Hippocampus in Approach–Avoidance Conflict

Eleanor Loh, Zeb Kurth‐Nelson, David Berron, Peter Dayan, Emrah Düzel, Raymond J. Dolan, Marc Guitart‐MasipCerebral 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a novel gambling task and fMRI to investigate the hippocampus's role in approach-avoidance conflict, a key component of anxiety. They found that different subregions of the anterior hippocampus are involved in distinct aspects of this conflict: the inferior hippocampus is crucial for behavioral avoidance, while the superior hippocampus monitors potential outcomes when avoidance isn't triggered.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anxiety is often linked to approach-avoidance conflict, where an individual is drawn to a reward but simultaneously repelled by a potential threat. While the hippocampus is known to be involved in anxiety and decision-making, its specific role in navigating these conflicting impulses has been unclear. Researchers have debated whether the hippocampus primarily helps in avoiding negative outcomes, seeking more information about potential risks, or simply representing the context in which these conflicts occur. This paper aims to disentangle these functions by creating a task that isolates behavioral avoidance from information-seeking.

Methods

The researchers designed a novel gambling task with two conditions: approach-avoidance (Ap/Av) and approach-approach (Ap/Ap). In the Ap/Av condition, participants chose to accept a gamble (potential reward, but risk of a significant loss), reject it (no gain, no loss), or explore it (pay a small fee to gain more information before deciding). The Ap/Ap condition was similar but removed the threat of loss, making it a task of choosing between options based on reward probability alone. This design allowed them to differentiate between avoiding aversive outcomes and seeking more information.

They used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to record brain activity while participants performed the task. Behavioral data was analyzed using computational models to estimate subjective values of choices. This model-based approach allowed them to investigate how neural signals related to these estimated values and how they differed between the two conditions.

Datasets

The study used behavioral and fMRI data collected from 20 healthy adult participants. No external datasets were used. The paper introduces a novel experimental paradigm designed to specifically probe approach-avoidance conflict.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hippocampal Subregions Play Distinct Roles: The anterior hippocampus isn't a monolithic structure in approach-avoidance. The inferior part is specifically involved in the act of avoiding a loss, while the superior part seems to be involved in monitoring the potential outcomes when avoidance isn't necessary.
  • Anxiety and Avoidance are Linked: The strength of the inferior hippocampus's response during avoidance was correlated with individual differences in trait anxiety, suggesting a direct link between neural avoidance mechanisms and subjective anxiety levels.
  • Value Signals are Context-Dependent: Value signals in the superior hippocampus were amplified in the approach-avoidance context, particularly when participants didn't avoid a potential threat. This suggests the hippocampus is actively tracking potential outcomes when there's a risk, even if the individual doesn't act on it.
  • Exploration is Not Uniquely Hippocampal: The study found no specific hippocampal role in exploration during approach-avoidance conflict. Instead, exploration in both conditions engaged a broader network of frontal, parietal, and striatal regions, suggesting it's a more general decision-making process.

Key Results

  • Behavioral Avoidance: Participants were more likely to reject gambles in the Ap/Av condition compared to choosing "bomb" in the Ap/Ap condition, indicating a behavioral bias towards avoiding potential losses. This difference correlated with trait anxiety scores.
  • Inferior Hippocampus and Avoidance: The inferior anterior hippocampus showed increased activity when participants rejected gambles in the Ap/Av condition (avoiding a loss) compared to exploring or choosing "bomb" in the Ap/Ap condition. This activation positively correlated with trait anxiety.
  • Superior Hippocampus and Value Monitoring: The superior anterior hippocampus showed potentiated value signals in the Ap/Av condition, particularly on trials where participants did not reject a gamble. This suggests a role in monitoring potential outcomes when avoidance is not triggered.
  • Exploration Network: A network including frontal, parietal, and striatal regions was activated during exploration in both conditions, with no specific hippocampal involvement identified for this process in the context of approach-avoidance conflict.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Resolution: The fMRI's spatial resolution limited the ability to definitively assign functions to specific hippocampal subfields (e.g., CA1 vs. CA3). While the study provides exploratory evidence for subfield segregation, further investigation with higher resolution techniques is needed.
  • Anxiety Measurement: The study used the STAI for anxiety, which, as noted by the authors, can correlate with depressive traits. Future work could use more specific measures of anxiety.
  • Generalizability of Exploration: While exploration in this task didn't engage the hippocampus, the authors acknowledge that different types of exploration (e.g., those heavily relying on memory retrieval) might.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring the interactions between hippocampal subregions and other brain areas like the amygdala and prefrontal cortex in processing threat and value signals. They also propose investigating the precise computational mechanisms within the hippocampus that transform value signals into categorical avoidance decisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The hippocampus plays a central role in the approach-avoidance conflict that is central to the genesis of anxiety. However, its exact functional contribution has yet to be identified. We designed a novel gambling task that generated approach-avoidance conflict while controlling for spatial processing. We fit subjects' behavior using a model that quantified the subjective values of choice options, and recorded neural signals using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Distinct functional signals were observed in anterior hippocampus, with inferior hippocampus selectively recruited when subjects rejected a gamble, to a degree that covaried with individual differences in anxiety. The superior anterior hippocampus, in contrast, uniquely demonstrated value signals that were potentiated in the context of approach-avoidance conflict. These results implicate the anterior hippocampus in behavioral avoidance and choice monitoring, in a manner relevant to understanding its role in anxiety. Our findings highlight interactions between subregions of the hippocampus as an important focus for future study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{loh2016parsing,
  author = {Eleanor Loh and Zeb Kurth‐Nelson and David Berron and Peter Dayan and Emrah Düzel and Raymond J. Dolan and Marc Guitart‐Masip},
  title = {{Parsing the Role of the Hippocampus in Approach–Avoidance Conflict}},
  booktitle = {Cerebral},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1093/cercor/bhw378},
}
Figure