Parents’ Perspectives on Using Artificial Intelligence to Reduce Technology Interference During Early Childhood: Cross-sectional Online Survey

Jill R. Glassman, Kathryn L. Humphreys, Serena Yeung, Michelle Smith, Adam Jauregui, Arnold Milstein, Lee SandersJournal of Medical Internet Research 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores parents' willingness to adopt AI-powered tools to combat "technoference" – the interference of mobile technology in parent-child interactions. The findings indicate a high level of acceptance for such tools, particularly among younger parents, suggesting a promising avenue for supporting healthy early childhood development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Parents' use of mobile devices can significantly disrupt crucial parent-child interactions, a phenomenon termed "technoference." This interference is linked to reduced parental responsiveness and potential negative impacts on a child's development. While the problem is recognized, there's a significant knowledge gap regarding parents' awareness of technoference and their receptiveness to technological solutions, specifically AI-based tools, for mitigating it. This paper aims to bridge this gap by assessing parental awareness, the acceptability of AI tools, and how these perceptions vary across different demographic groups.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional online survey targeting a nationally representative sample of US parents with children aged 5 years or younger. They adapted validated scales to measure:

  • Problematic technology use: Parents' self-reported extent to which their mobile device use had become problematic.
  • Parenting technoference: The frequency with which various devices interrupted interactions with their child.
  • Acceptability of AI tools: Parents' agreement with statements about the usefulness and utility of an AI-based "computer-assisted coach" designed to help them manage their device use during parenting.

Statistical analyses, including multiple regression and mediation analysis, were employed to examine the relationships between these measures and various sociodemographic factors (age, sex, race/ethnicity, language, education, income, and geographic region).

Datasets

The study utilized a web-based survey administered through the Amazon TurkPrime (now CloudResearch) platform via its Prime Panels service. This platform incorporates attention and language comprehension screening to ensure data quality. The survey was pilot-tested and translated into Spanish to accommodate a diverse participant pool. No new datasets were introduced; the study relied on data collected from the survey respondents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquity of Technoference: The study confirms that mobile device interference in parent-child interactions is a widespread issue, with parents reporting an average of over 3 devices interfering daily.
  • Parental Concern is High: A significant majority of parents expressed worry about the impact of their mobile device use on their children and found the idea of an AI coach helpful for self-awareness.
  • AI as a Potential Solution: The core insight is the high acceptability of AI-based tools for mitigating technoference, suggesting parents are open to technological assistance in this area.
  • Younger Parents Lead the Way: Younger parents, in particular, showed higher awareness of technoference and greater acceptance of AI tools, potentially due to their greater exposure to and concern about technology's impact.
  • Problematic Use is Key: Parents' own perceptions of their general problematic technology use were the strongest predictor of their acceptance of AI tools, even more so than their specific parenting technoference concerns. This suggests a broader concern about technology overuse.
  • Sociodemographics Less Influential (Post-Control): While some sociodemographic factors were associated with technoference awareness, they did not significantly predict AI tool acceptance once parents' own perceptions of problematic use and technoference were accounted for. This points to the personal experience of the problem as a primary driver of acceptance.

Key Results

  • High Technoference: Approximately 75.6% of parents reported that smartphones interfered in their parent-child interactions at least daily.
  • Acceptance of AI: Two-thirds of parents agreed that an AI coach would help them notice their device use interfering with caregiving and be more aware of their device use around their child. The overall mean technology acceptance score was 3.53 out of 6.
  • Problematic Use: 62.5% of parents agreed with the statement that they "cannot resist checking" their mobile device when it alerts them. The mean score for problematic technology use was 3.72 out of 6.
  • Key Predictors of Acceptance: In regression models, parents' perception of their own problematic technology use was the strongest predictor of AI tool acceptance (Cohen's d = 0.98, explaining 27% of the variance). Parenting technoference also played a significant role (Cohen's d = 0.51, explaining 6% of the variance).
  • Mediation Findings: The relationship between general problematic technology use and technology acceptance was only weakly mediated by parenting technoference (indirect effect of 0.08), indicating that the direct effect of general technology overuse on acceptance was more substantial.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Selection Bias: Web-based surveys may attract participants who are already more receptive to technology, potentially overestimating acceptance.
  • Sample Demographics: The sample had a disproportionately high number of females and differed from the US population in income and education levels, limiting generalizability.
  • Lack of National Standards: For some scales, there are no established national benchmarks for interpreting results (e.g., what constitutes "high" technology acceptance).
  • Social Desirability Bias: Participants might have downplayed their technology use due to social desirability.

Future work should:

  • Focus on Younger Parents: Given their higher awareness and acceptance, younger parents should be a priority for future research and development.
  • Validate AI Tools: Further research is needed to develop and test AI-based tools to ensure their effectiveness and usability.
  • Investigate General Overuse: Explore whether focusing AI interventions on general technology overuse, rather than solely on specific parenting technoference, is sufficient and effective.
  • Identify Other Influencing Factors: Uncover additional factors that influence the acceptability and utility of AI-based parenting supports.

Summary updated

Abstract

Parents reported high levels of mobile device use and technoference around their youngest children. Most parents across a wide sociodemographic spectrum, especially younger parents, found the use of AI tools to help mitigate technoference during parent-child daily interaction acceptable and useful.
BibTeX
@article{glassman2021parents,
  author = {Jill R. Glassman and Kathryn L. Humphreys and Serena Yeung and Michelle Smith and Adam Jauregui and Arnold Milstein and Lee Sanders},
  title = {{Parents’ Perspectives on Using Artificial Intelligence to Reduce Technology Interference During Early Childhood: Cross-sectional Online Survey}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2196/19461},
}
Figure