Parent, partner, co-parent or partnership? The need for clarity as family systems thinking takes hold in the quest to motivate behavioural change

Chris May, Li Kheng Chai, Tracy BurrowsChildren 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues for greater clarity in how researchers describe participants in childhood obesity interventions, particularly regarding the roles of fathers and parenting partnerships. It highlights that current research often defaults to "parents" but primarily engages mothers, potentially limiting intervention effectiveness by overlooking crucial family dynamics. The authors propose a more precise terminology to better capture the complexity of family systems in future research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Childhood obesity interventions often aim to influence family behaviors, recognizing that parental knowledge, attitudes, and actions significantly impact a child's health. However, a significant challenge in this field is the lack of precision in describing who is being targeted and engaged. Research frequently uses the broad term "parents" but systematically underrepresents fathers and other fathering figures. This skew towards maternal engagement means interventions may miss opportunities to leverage the full potential of family systems thinking, which acknowledges the influence of multiple caregivers and their relationships. The paper addresses the gap in understanding how to effectively engage diverse parenting figures and partnerships, and the need for clearer reporting to accurately assess intervention impact.

Methods

This paper is primarily a conceptual and review-based piece. The authors integrate existing literature from family systems thinking, parenting efficacy, co-parenting, and family intervention research. They conduct a critical analysis of published childhood obesity research, highlighting trends in participant reporting. Based on this review, they propose a taxonomy for describing parents and parenting figures to improve clarity and consistency in future studies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper analyzes existing published research rather than using specific datasets for empirical evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Parent" Blind Spot: The term "parents" is often used as a catch-all, but research consistently shows a strong bias towards engaging mothers, with fathers significantly underrepresented in childhood obesity interventions.
  • Family Systems are Complex: Children are influenced by multiple layers of their environment, with the immediate family (microsystem) being particularly impactful. Interventions that only target one parent may not fully leverage the family system's potential for change.
  • Parenting Efficacy Matters: A parent's belief in their ability to parent effectively (parenting self-efficacy) is a key driver of behavior change. This efficacy is influenced not just by knowledge but also by partner support and overall family function.
  • Co-parenting is Crucial: The relationship between parents (co-parenting or parenting partnership) has an independent influence on child outcomes. Interventions that ignore this dynamic may be less effective.
  • Gendered Expectations Persist: Despite societal shifts, traditional gender roles continue to influence how parenting responsibilities are divided, impacting fathers' involvement and employers' expectations.
  • Technology Offers New Avenues: Information technology (IT), such as messaging apps, presents a scalable and adaptable way to engage diverse parenting figures, including fathers, and potentially enhance parenting efficacy.
  • Need for Precise Terminology: To accurately understand intervention effects, researchers must clearly define who they are engaging with (e.g., biological father, non-biological mother, co-parent, other parenting figures) and how the intervention targets specific relationships and dynamics.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results from new experiments. Instead, its key findings are derived from the synthesis of existing literature:

  • Skewed Participation: A systematic review found that explicit attempts to engage fathers in pediatric obesity prevention trials occurred in less than 1% of eligible trials.
  • Maternal Dominance: In studies involving both parents, mothers were present in almost all interactions, while fathers had dyadic (1:1) involvement for only 11% of the time.
  • Limited Focus on Partnerships: A review found no reported interventions specifically focused on co-parenting in childhood obesity.
  • Partner Support is Key: Studies indicate that support from a parenting partner is a stronger predictor of parenting self-efficacy than parenting knowledge alone.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The paper acknowledges that while technology offers promising avenues for engagement, more research is needed to determine its influence on personal or collective parenting efficacy. * The proposed taxonomy does not fully address the nuances of the term "co-parenting" as an intervention strategy versus "co-parent" as a role.

Future Work: * Researchers are encouraged to adopt more precise terminology when describing participants in childhood obesity interventions to improve the clarity and comparability of studies. * Future research should explore how IT-based interventions can effectively engage fathers and other family members, and how these interventions influence parenting efficacy and family dynamics. * Further investigation is needed into the specific contributions of different parenting figures and partnerships to child outcomes and how interventions can be tailored to these diverse family structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research is increasingly pointing to the importance of extending the focus of childhood obesity intervention to include fathers, fathering figures, and other members of a child's primary parenting network. Advances in communication technology are now making it possible to achieve this aim, within current resources, using modalities such text messaging, web-based resources and apps that extend intervention to parents not in attendance at face to face interactions. However, published research is often unclear as to which parent/s they targeted or engaged with, whether interventions planned to influence behaviours and capabilities across family systems, and how this can be achieved. As childhood obesity research employing information technology to engage with family systems takes hold it is becoming important for researchers clearly describe who they engage with, what they hope to achieve with them, and the pathways of influence that they aim to activate. This paper integrates extant knowledge on family systems thinking, parenting efficacy, co-parenting, and family intervention with the way parents are represented and reported in childhood obesity research. The paper concludes with recommendations on terminology that can be used to describe parents and parenting figures in future studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{may2017parent,
  author = {Chris May and Li Kheng Chai and Tracy Burrows},
  title = {{Parent, partner, co-parent or partnership? The need for clarity as family systems thinking takes hold in the quest to motivate behavioural change}},
  booktitle = {Children},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/children4040029},
}

Loading related content...

Figure