Pandemic related Health literacy – A Systematic Review of literature in COVID-19, SARS and MERS pandemics

Jun Jie Benjamin Seng, Cheng Teng Yeam, Caleb Huang, Ngiap Chuan Tan, Lian Leng LowmedRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Health literacy is a critical determinant of an individual's ability to navigate the complex "infodemic" that accompanies global health crises. This systematic review summarizes the assessment, levels, and determinants of pandemic-related health literacy across 70 studies covering COVID-19, SARS, and MERS. The review identifies sub-optimal literacy levels globally, ranging from 4.0% to 82.5% in non-medical populations. While higher education, older age, and female gender were associated with better literacy, the review highlights a significant research gap: a total lack of studies connecting health literacy scores to actual clinical outcomes. The authors propose the "PANDEMIC-HL" framework to standardize future assessments and help healthcare administrators formulate more effective public health policies.

Introduction: The Infodemic Challenge

During a pandemic, the public faces a "double-edged sword": a massive influx of information and a rapidly shifting scientific landscape. Recommendations regarding preventive measures—such as mask-wearing or social distancing—can change overnight as new data emerges. In this environment, general health literacy, which typically focuses on managing chronic diseases, is insufficient. Individuals require "pandemic health literacy": the specific ability to rapidly acquire, discern, and apply accurate medical information under the pressure of an active crisis.

This paper addresses the lack of standardized tools to measure this specific literacy. By reviewing literature from three major coronavirus outbreaks (COVID-19, SARS, and MERS), the researchers aimed to identify the determinants of high health literacy and whether poor literacy correlates with worse clinical outcomes.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, searching eight databases including Medline, Embase, and PsychINFO. Notably, the search included pre-print servers (medRxiv, bioRxiv, arXiv, and SSRN) to capture the most recent data from the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Data from 70 included studies were categorized into three main themes:

  1. Knowledge: Understanding of symptoms, transmission, and treatment.
  2. Attitudes: Levels of worry/fear and confidence in government responses.
  3. Practices: Adherence to mask usage, hand hygiene, and social distancing.

Due to the high heterogeneity of assessment tools used across these studies, the authors performed a narrative synthesis rather than a quantitative meta-analysis.

The Landscape of Pandemic Literacy

The review analyzed 70 articles: 21 on COVID-19, 17 on SARS, and 32 on MERS. The geographic focus was predominantly Asian (84.3%), with a significant portion of MERS studies originating from Saudi Arabia.

Sub-optimal Literacy Levels

The findings indicate that pandemic-related health literacy is sub-optimal globally. Rates of "low" literacy ranged from 4.3% to 57.9% among medical-related populations and 4.0% to 82.5% among non-medical populations. This wide variance suggests that even within professional groups, the ability to process novel pandemic information is not guaranteed.

Key Determinants: The Age and Gender Factors

  • The Age Paradox: In general health literacy research, older age is typically associated with lower literacy due to cognitive decline. However, this review found that older age was associated with better pandemic health literacy. The authors hypothesize that older individuals may benefit from "prior knowledge" gained during previous outbreaks (like SARS), which helps them synthesize new information more effectively.
  • The Gender Gap: Female gender was consistently associated with higher health literacy. This is likely tied to traditional caregiving roles, which often require a higher degree of familiarity with navigating healthcare systems and information for family members.
  • Education: Higher education levels remained a consistent predictor of better health literacy across all three pandemics.

The "Moving Target" of Measurement

A significant challenge identified in the review is the difficulty of designing literacy surveys during an active crisis. For example, early COVID-19 surveys marked "avoiding travel to China" as the primary preventive measure, failing to account for the later necessity of global social distancing. This "moving target" problem makes it difficult to compare literacy levels across different stages of a single pandemic.

To address this, the authors proposed the PANDEMIC-HL Framework. This standardized framework suggests that future assessment tools must include specific items on:

  • Incubation periods and clinical outcomes.
  • Confidence in government and public health institutions.
  • Information-seeking behaviors and the ability to filter misinformation.

Critical Gaps and Limitations

Despite the theoretical assumption that low health literacy leads to worse health, the review found zero studies that evaluated the association between pandemic health literacy and actual clinical outcomes, such as hospitalization or mortality rates. This represents a major gap in the current body of research.

Furthermore, the review highlighted a "Digital Divide." Most COVID-19 studies relied on online questionnaires, which naturally excludes populations that lack internet access or digital literacy. This likely results in an overestimation of the literacy levels of the general population. Additionally, the review was limited to English-language articles, potentially missing critical data from non-English speaking regions heavily affected by these viruses.

Conclusion

Pandemic-related health literacy is a vital but under-standardized component of public health. Current literacy levels are sub-optimal, and the tools used to measure them are often inconsistent. Healthcare administrators must be aware of these literacy determinants—particularly the roles of age, gender, and education—when formulating communication policies. Future research must move beyond descriptive surveys and begin longitudinal studies that connect health literacy scores to tangible clinical outcomes to better protect vulnerable populations in future crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Health literacy plays an essential role in one’s ability to acquire and understand critical medical information in the COVID-19 infodemic and other pandemics. Purpose To summarize the assessment, levels and determinants of pandemic related health literacy and its associated clinical outcomes. Data sources Medline®, Embase®, PsychINFO®, CINAHL®, arXiv, bioRxiv, medRxiv, and Social Science Research Network. The start date was unrestricted and current as of 22 April 2020. Study selection Studies which evaluated health literacy related to novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) or Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) Data extraction Data on the characteristics of study designs, instruments, participants and level of health literacy were collected. Items used in instruments were grouped under the themes of knowledge, attitudes and practices. Determinants of health literacy were grouped into five domains (socio-demographic, medical, psychological/psychiatric, health systems related and others). Data synthesis Of 2,065 articles screened, 70 articles were included. 21, 17 and 32 studies evaluated health literacy related to COVID-19, SARS and MERS, respectively. The rates of low pandemic health literacy ranged from 4.3 to 57.9% among medical-related populations and 4.0% to 82.5% among non-medical populations. Knowledge about symptoms and transmission of infection; worry about infection and, practices related to mask usage and hand hygiene was most frequently evaluated. Socio-demographic determinants of health literacy were most studied, where higher education level, older age and female gender were associated with better health literacy. No studies evaluated outcomes associated with health literacy. Limitations Non-English articles were excluded. Conclusion The level of pandemic related health literacy is sub-optimal. Healthcare administrators need to be aware of health literacy determinants when formulating policies in pandemics.
BibTeX
@misc{seng2020pandemic,
  author = {Jun Jie Benjamin Seng and Cheng Teng Yeam and Caleb Huang and Ngiap Chuan Tan and Lian Leng Low},
  title = {{Pandemic related Health literacy – A Systematic Review of literature in COVID-19, SARS and MERS pandemics}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.05.07.20094227},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure