Palladium-catalyzed selective C–C bond cleavage of keto-vinylidenecyclopropanes: construction of structurally rich dihydrofurans and tetrahydrofurans

Chao Ning, Ziqi Yu, Min Shi, Yin WeiChemical 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a "switchable" palladium-catalyzed method to selectively break specific C–C bonds in keto-vinylidenecyclopropanes. By simply changing the phosphine ligand, they can steer the reaction to produce either structurally complex dihydrofurans or tetrahydrofurans with high precision and yields.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cyclopropanes are the "coiled springs" of organic chemistry. Their intense ring strain makes them highly reactive, providing a powerful platform for building complex bicyclic skeletons found in pharmaceuticals and natural products. However, controlling which bond in the ring breaks is a significant challenge.

Vinylidenecyclopropanes (VDCPs) have two types of C–C bonds: distal (far from the vinylidene group) and proximal (adjacent to it). While distal cleavage is well-documented, the proximal cleavage of unactivated VDCPs—those lacking specific electron-withdrawing groups—has remained an elusive "holy grail" in the field. This paper provides a solution by using sterically bulky ligands to dictate the regioselectivity of the bond-breaking event, opening up new pathways to oxygen-containing heterocycles.

Methods

The team utilized Palladium (Pd) catalysis, discovering that the choice of phosphine ligand acts as a molecular switch:

  • For Proximal Cleavage: Using dtbpf as a ligand allows the Pd catalyst to insert into the proximal bond. This leads to an unusual eight-membered cyclic palladium intermediate, eventually yielding dihydrofurans.
  • For Distal Cleavage: Switching to $^t$BuXPhos (a biaryl phosphine) combined with a ZnCl₂ additive promotes a [3 + 2] cycloaddition via distal bond cleavage, resulting in tetrahydrofurans.

To validate their findings, the authors employed:

  1. Substrate Mapping: Testing dozens of different chemical groups (alkyl, aryl, naphthyl) to ensure the reaction is robust.
  2. DFT Calculations: Using Density Functional Theory to model the energy landscapes of the reaction pathways, explaining why specific ligands favor one bond over the other.
  3. Control Experiments: Including "gram-scale" syntheses to prove the method works for practical, large-scale laboratory use.

Datasets

As a synthetic chemistry paper, the "datasets" consist of experimental characterization data for dozens of newly synthesized compounds.

  • Substrate Scope: 32 examples of dihydrofurans (yields up to 96%) and 31 examples of tetrahydrofurans (yields up to 92%).
  • Crystallographic Data: Structures were confirmed via X-ray diffraction and deposited in the Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre (CCDC 2206931 and 2246469).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ligand-Controlled Regioselectivity: The most striking insight is that the steric bulk of the phosphine ligand doesn't just change the reaction rate; it fundamentally changes the geometry of the transition state, forcing the palladium to "bite" into a different part of the cyclopropane ring.
  • The Role of ZnCl₂: The additive isn't just a spectator. DFT studies revealed that ZnCl₂ coordinates with the carbonyl group of the substrate, significantly lowering the energy barrier for the migratory insertion step in distal cleavage.
  • Hemilabile Interactions: In the distal pathway, the bulky biaryl phosphine ligand exhibits "hemilabile" behavior—weakly interacting with the palladium to stabilize intermediates that would otherwise be too high-energy to form.
  • The 8-Membered Intermediate: The discovery of a stable 8-membered palladacyclic intermediate in the proximal pathway provides a new mechanistic template for researchers looking to break unactivated small rings.

Key Results

  • High Efficiency: Most reactions achieved yields between 70% and 96% under optimized conditions.
  • Broad Functional Group Tolerance: The method works with a wide variety of substituents, including halogens, ethers, and complex aromatics like thiophenes and naphthyls.
  • Synthetic Utility: The authors demonstrated that the resulting bicyclic products can be further transformed into even more complex molecules, such as tricyclic structures or functionalized lactones, through downstream reactions like Diels-Alder cycloadditions or oxidations.

Limitations and Future Work

While the method is highly selective, it requires relatively high temperatures (100 °C) and anhydrous conditions (toluene). The authors also noted that asymmetric catalysis (creating "left-handed" or "right-handed" versions of the molecules) remains a challenge. Initial tests with chiral ligands yielded low enantioselectivity (15–20% ee), likely because the high reaction temperatures cause the chiral ligands to dissociate from the palladium center.

Future research will likely focus on developing new catalyst-ligand combinations that can achieve this same selectivity at lower temperatures, enabling better control over the 3D orientation (chirality) of the final products.

Summary updated

Abstract

Palladium-catalyzed selective cleavage of the distal C-C bond and proximal C-C bond of keto-vinylidenecyclopropanes by altering the sterically bulky phosphine ligands has been realized. The proximal C-C bond cleavage can be achieved by using dtbpf as a phosphine ligand, affording bicyclic products containing dihydrofuran skeletons in good yields along with broad substrate scope. In proximal C-C bond cleavage reactions, the eight-membered cyclic palladium intermediate plays a key role in the reaction. The [3 + 2] cycloaddition of keto-vinylidenecyclopropanes through the distal C-C bond cleavage can be effectively accomplished with <sup><i>t</i></sup> BuXPhos as a phosphine ligand and ZnCl<sub>2</sub> as an additive, delivering bicyclic products containing tetrahydrofuran skeletons in good yields. The further transformation of these bicyclic products has been demonstrated, and the reaction mechanisms of two different C-C bond cleavage reactions have been investigated by control experiments and DFT calculations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ning2024palladium,
  author = {Chao Ning and Ziqi Yu and Min Shi and Yin Wei},
  title = {{Palladium-catalyzed selective C–C bond cleavage of keto-vinylidenecyclopropanes: construction of structurally rich dihydrofurans and tetrahydrofurans}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1039/d4sc02536a},
}
Figure