PAIR PRODUCTION IN A STRONG ELECTRIC FIELD: AN INITIAL VALUE PROBLEM IN QUANTUM FIELD THEORY

Yuval Kluger, J. M. Eisenberg, Benjamin SvetitskyInternational Journal of Modern Physics E 1993 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper reviews recent advancements in solving the initial-value problem for quantum backreaction in both scalar and spinor Quantum Electrodynamics (QED). Formulated within a semiclassical mean-field approximation for homogeneous, time-dependent electric fields, the study is primarily motivated by the production of quark-gluon plasma. We detail the application of adiabatic regularization to Klein-Gordon and Dirac fields to renormalize the current's expectation value, resulting in a finite set of coupled ordinary differential equations. The evolution of the system reveals three distinct time scales and physical phenomena such as plasma oscillations and current plateaus. Furthermore, we demonstrate that a simpler relativistic Boltzmann-Vlasov model, when augmented with quantum statistical factors (Pauli blocking or Bose enhancement), remarkably reproduces the field-theory results, providing an intuitive classical understanding of the underlying quantum dynamics.

Introduction: The Backreaction Problem

In 1951, Julian Schwinger established that a sufficiently strong electric field could spontaneously create electron-positron pairs from the vacuum. While the "Schwinger mechanism" is a cornerstone of strong-field QED, early theoretical models often treated the electric field as a static, external background. In reality, the creation of charged particles introduces a dynamic feedback loop: as pairs are produced and accelerated, they generate an internal electric current. This current, in turn, produces a field that opposes and modifies the original external field.

This process, known as backreaction, transforms the system into a complex non-linear initial value problem. Solving this in the context of Quantum Field Theory (QFT) is notoriously difficult because time-dependent calculations often encounter mathematical infinities (divergences) that require sophisticated renormalization techniques to yield physically meaningful results.

Methodology

To address this, the researchers employ a semiclassical mean-field approximation. In this framework, the matter fields (fermions or bosons) are treated as quantized, while the electromagnetic field is treated as a classical background. This approach corresponds to the leading order in a $1/N$ expansion.

Adiabatic Regularization

The core technical challenge is the renormalization of the electric current. The authors utilize adiabatic regularization, a method that allows for the subtraction of infinite vacuum contributions in a time-dependent manner. By decomposing the quantum fields into Fourier modes, the problem is reduced to a set of coupled ordinary differential equations (ODEs) that can be solved numerically.

The Kinetic Alternative

A major highlight of the work is the comparison of these heavy-duty QFT calculations against a Relativistic Boltzmann-Vlasov (BV) equation. The BV model is a classical kinetic approach that tracks particle distributions in phase space. To bridge the gap between classical and quantum regimes, the authors incorporate a "source term" derived from the Schwinger creation rate, modified by quantum statistical factors.

Key Insights and Dynamics

The evolution of the system is characterized by three distinct time scales: the rapid "zitterbewegung" (jittery) motion of particles, the intermediate scale of plasma oscillations, and the long-term decay of the field.

Plasma Oscillations and Current Plateaus

As backreaction takes hold, the electric field does not simply vanish; it over-corrects, leading to plasma oscillations. The field and the current oscillate back and forth, similar to a pendulum. Before these oscillations dominate, the electric current often reaches a "plateau." The height of this plateau is a critical diagnostic tool, as it allows researchers to estimate the number of pairs created before the onset of collective plasma effects.

The Role of Quantum Statistics

The most significant finding is the necessity of including statistical factors in the kinetic model to match the QFT results. Specifically:

  • Bosons: Require a $(1 + 2f)$ factor for Bose enhancement.
  • Fermions: Require a $(1 - 2f)$ factor for Pauli blocking.

For fermions, the Pauli Exclusion Principle limits the number of particles that can occupy specific states, causing the electric field to reach a saturation point much faster than in the bosonic case. When these factors are included, the classical BV model's momentum distributions align almost perfectly with the full QFT simulation.

Results and Numerical Stability

The authors successfully implemented an iterative numerical scheme that remains stable despite the highly oscillatory nature of quantum mode functions. This allowed for some of the first reliable results in 3+1 dimensions. The quantitative agreement between the smoothed QFT results and the BV model suggests that nearly all the essential physics of the backreaction problem can be understood through the lens of a classical distribution function, provided quantum statistics are respected.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the model provides a robust solution for homogeneous fields, it faces limitations in real-world applications like heavy-ion collisions, where fields are spatially localized and vary over time. Furthermore, the current model accounts for the mean field but neglects mutual particle interactions, such as scattering or the emission of bremsstrahlung radiation. Finally, while the work is motivated by the Quark-Gluon Plasma, it utilizes the Abelian mathematics of QED. Extending these practicable numerical solutions to the non-Abelian "color" fields of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) remains a primary goal for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We review recent achievements in the solution of the initial-value problem for quantum backreaction in scalar and spinor QED. The problem is formulated and solved in the semiclassical mean-field approximation for a homogeneous, time-dependent electric field. Our primary motivation in examining backreaction has to do with applications to theoretical models of production of the quark-gluon plasma though we here address practicable solutions for backreaction in general. We review the application of the method of adiabatic regularization to the Klein-Gordon and Dirac fields in order to renormalize the expectation value of the current and derive a finite coupled set of ordinary differential equations for the time evolution of the system. Three time scales are involved in the problem and therefore caution is needed to achieve numerical stability for this system. Several physical features like plasma oscillations and plateaus in the current appear in the solution. From the plateau of the electric current one can estimate the number of pairs before the onset of plasma oscillations, while the plasma oscillations themselves yield the number of particles from the plasma frequency. We compare the field-theory solution to a simple model based on a relativistic Boltzmann-Vlasov equation with a particle production source term inferred from the Schwinger particle creation rate and a Pauli-blocking (or Bose-enhancement) factor. This model reproduces very well the time behavior of the electric field and the creation rate of charged pairs of the semiclassical calculation. It therefore provides a simple intuitive understanding of the nature of the solution since nearly all the physical features can be expressed in terms of the classical distribution function.
BibTeX
@article{kluger1993pair,
  author = {Yuval Kluger and J. M. Eisenberg and Benjamin Svetitsky},
  title = {{PAIR PRODUCTION IN A STRONG ELECTRIC FIELD: AN INITIAL VALUE PROBLEM IN QUANTUM FIELD THEORY}},
  journal = {International Journal of Modern Physics E},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.1142/s0218301393000121},
}

Loading related content...

Figure