Abstract
Background: Our centre introduced a pathway for the conservative management of large primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP) following increasing evidence to support this strategy in select individuals. Aims: To evaluate our local centre experience of conservatively managing large PSP, the process and outcomes. To identify any safety or operational concerns. Methods: Retrospect review of all pneumothorax referrals to pleural clinic from October 2020 – October 2022. Patients with large, unilateral PSP (≥2cm at level of hilar or ≥6cm combined measurement Collin’s method) were included for analysis. Results: 77 patients were referred with pneumothoraces during the 2-year period. 38 of which was primary (49%) with 15 quantified as large by above methods. 1 patient had large bilateral pneumothoraces and was excluded from analysis. In total, 14 patients had a large, unilateral PSP and were included for analysis. 9 met criteria for conservative management, with 4 as outpatients. 3 of the 9 patients managed conservatively required subsequent pleural intervention, 2 had history of previous pneumothorax. Of those managed as outpatients, all were reviewed in pleural clinic within 1 day of discharge and none required subsequent pleural intervention. Those initially managed conservatively had a significantly shorter length of stay compared those receiving pleural drainage. This benefit was lost if they were initially admitted for observation. Conclusion: Conservative management of large PSP is safe, with those suitable for outpatient management experiencing a significant reduction in length of hospital stay at the expense of doubling time to radiological resolution. Patients not suitable for outpatient conservative management should be considered for pleural drainage over inpatient observation as little clinical advantage is conferred with the latter. History of previous pneumothorax may be a risk factor for failure of conservative management. Further research in this area could aid future risk stratification.
Introduction
A Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax (PSP) occurs when air leaks into the pleural space in individuals without underlying lung disease. Traditionally, "large" PSPs—defined by the size of the air gap on an X-ray—were treated interventionally with needle aspiration or chest tube insertion. However, recent landmark trials, such as Brown et al. (2020), suggest that many stable patients heal effectively without invasive procedures. This study evaluates the safety and efficacy of a conservative management pathway in a real-world, inner-city tertiary center, specifically focusing on hospital resource utilization and patient outcomes.
Methods
Researchers conducted a retrospective review of pneumothorax referrals to the pleural clinic at Guy’s and St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust, London, between October 2020 and October 2022.
Inclusion Criteria: Patients with a large unilateral PSP, defined as a gap ≥ 2cm at the level of the hilum or ≥ 6cm using the Collin’s measurement method.
Management Pathways: 1. Interventional (G1): Immediate pleural drainage. 2. Conservative Inpatient (G2): Hospital admission for observation without immediate drainage. 3. Conservative Outpatient (G3): Immediate discharge with follow-up in the pleural clinic within 24 hours.
Results
Out of 77 total pneumothorax referrals, 14 patients met the criteria for large unilateral PSP and were included in the final analysis. The primary outcomes focused on Length of Stay (LOS) and the time required for radiological resolution.
Length of Stay (LOS)
The outpatient pathway (G3) demonstrated a significant reduction in hospital resource use, with a median LOS of 0 days. In contrast, the interventional group (G1) had a mean LOS of 7 days, while the inpatient observation group (G2) had a median LOS of 1 day. The difference in LOS between the two conservative groups (G2 vs. G3) was statistically significant (p=0.02).
Radiological Resolution
There is a clear trade-off between invasiveness and speed of recovery. Interventional management (G1) resulted in a median resolution time of 20 days. Conservative outpatient management (G3) roughly doubled this time, with a median of 47 days to full lung re-expansion.
Discussion
The "Observation Trap"
A key finding was that the resource-saving benefits of conservative management were largely lost if the patient was admitted for observation (G2) rather than discharged (G3). If a patient is not stable enough for immediate outpatient care, the data suggests that active intervention (G1) may be preferable to inpatient observation, as the latter offers little clinical advantage over drainage while still consuming hospital beds.
Predicting Failure
Conservative management was not successful for all patients; 33% (3 out of 9) of those initially managed conservatively eventually required a pleural drain. Notably, a history of previous pneumothorax appeared to be a risk factor, as 2 of these 3 "failures" had experienced a prior collapse.
Conclusion
Conservative management of large PSP is a safe and effective strategy that can eliminate hospital stays for suitable outpatients. While it results in a longer time to radiological resolution, the reduction in invasive procedures and hospital bed days is substantial. Future research should focus on better risk stratification to identify which patients are most likely to succeed with outpatient observation versus those who require early intervention.
References
- Brown SGA, Ball EL, Perrin K, Asha SE, Braithwaite I, Egerton-Warburton D, et al. Conservative versus Interventional Treatment for Spontaneous Pneumothorax. New England Journal of Medicine. 2020;382(5):405–15.
Summary updated