P039: Potential impact on receiving hospital of a prehospital triage system for refractory cardiac arrest: a simulation study

Alexis Cournoyer, Éric Notebaert, Eli Segal, Luc de Montigny, Massimiliano Iseppon, Sylvie Cossette, Luc Londei‐Leduc, Yoan Lamarche, Judy Morris, Éric Piette, Raoul Daoust, J. Chauny, Catalina Sokoloff, Victoria Ross, Yiorgos Alexandros Cavayas, Dominique Lafrance, Jean Paquet, André DenaultCanadian 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study simulates the impact of a prehospital triage system for refractory cardiac arrest patients on their access to specialized extracorporeal resuscitation (E-CPR) centers. The findings suggest that such a system could significantly triple the number of eligible patients, highlighting the need for E-CPR centers to prepare for increased demand to improve survival rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of optimizing patient flow and access to specialized care for refractory cardiac arrest (OHCA) patients who could benefit from extracorporeal cardiopulmonary resuscitation (E-CPR). While E-CPR has shown promise in improving survival, its application is limited by the availability of specialized centers. Current prehospital triage systems have demonstrated success in improving outcomes for other acute conditions by directing patients to appropriate care facilities. However, the specific impact of a prehospital triage system on the proportion of OHCA patients who could potentially receive E-CPR has not been quantified. This study aims to fill that gap by simulating the effect of such a system on patient transport to E-CPR centers.

Methods

The researchers utilized a retrospective registry of adult OHCA cases from Montreal, Canada, collected between 2010 and 2015. They focused on patients experiencing non-traumatic witnessed OHCA refractory to 15 minutes of resuscitation. To simulate the impact of a prehospital triage system, they created three distinct scenarios with varying eligibility criteria for E-CPR:

  • Strict criteria: Age <60 years old, initial shockable rhythm.
  • Intermediate criteria: Age <65 years old, at least one shock given.
  • Inclusive criteria: Age <70 years old, initial rhythm not asystole.

Each scenario was compared to a baseline where patients would have been transported to the closest hospital. The proportion of patients who would have been redirected to E-CPR centers under each triage scenario was then compared to the baseline using McNemar's test. The study also calculated the sample size needed to achieve 99% power with a unilateral alpha of 0.83% (after Bonferroni correction), requiring at least 1000 patients.

Datasets

The study used a registry of adult OHCA cases collected between 2010 and 2015 from the city of Montréal, Canada. This dataset comprised 3136 patients. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study leverages existing OHCA data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The potential for significant impact: Even with relatively strict criteria, a prehospital triage system can substantially increase the number of patients reaching specialized E-CPR centers.
  • Scalability of E-CPR centers: The findings suggest that E-CPR centers may need to anticipate a considerable increase in patient volume if such triage systems are implemented, necessitating proactive planning.
  • Tailoring triage criteria: The study demonstrates how different levels of triage stringency can yield varying increases in access, implying that optimal criteria might need to be determined based on local resources and patient populations.

Key Results

The study included 3136 patients (2054 men, 982 women) with a mean age of 69 years (SD 15). The simulations showed a significant increase in the proportion of patients transported to E-CPR centers across all triage scenarios:

  • Pair 1 (Strict criteria): 1.3% (baseline) vs. 3.8% (triage) - a nearly threefold increase.
  • Pair 2 (Intermediate criteria): 2.6% (baseline) vs. 7.3% (triage) - an almost threefold increase.
  • Pair 3 (Inclusive criteria): 7.6% (baseline) vs. 29.8% (triage) - a nearly fourfold increase.

These increases were statistically significant (p<0.001 for all pairs).

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that this is a simulation based on historical data. The real-world implementation of such a triage system might encounter additional logistical challenges or variations in patient presentation and response. Future work could involve prospective studies to validate these simulated findings in practice and to explore the optimal implementation strategies for prehospital triage systems aimed at improving access to E-CPR. The authors also suggest that centers with E-CPR capabilities should prepare for the potential increase in patient numbers to effectively improve survival following OHCA.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cournoyer2017p,
  author = {Alexis Cournoyer and Éric Notebaert and Eli Segal and Luc de Montigny and Massimiliano Iseppon and Sylvie Cossette and Luc Londei‐Leduc and Yoan Lamarche and Judy Morris and Éric Piette and Raoul Daoust and J. Chauny and Catalina Sokoloff and Victoria Ross and Yiorgos Alexandros Cavayas and Dominique Lafrance and Jean Paquet and André Denault},
  title = {{P039: Potential impact on receiving hospital of a prehospital triage system for refractory cardiac arrest: a simulation study}},
  booktitle = {Canadian},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1017/cem.2017.241},
}
Figure