P-Y Curve Correction of Shallow Seabed Formation Containing Hydrate

Haoyu Diao, Honghai Fan, Rongyi Ji, Bangchen Wu, Yuguang Ye, Yuhan Liu, Fei Zhou, Yixiang Yang, Zhi YanEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for accurate mechanical property evaluation of shallow seabed hydrate formations, which are crucial for safe offshore engineering. The researchers developed a novel method to correct P-Y curves (which describe the soil's resistance to lateral pile movement) for these hydrate-bearing soils, finding that existing API standards significantly underestimate their strength due to the reinforcing effect of hydrates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global demand for energy is driving increased interest in natural gas hydrates as a potential energy source. However, the exploration and development of these resources, as well as offshore engineering activities in hydrate-rich areas, pose significant challenges. Hydrate-bearing sediments have unique mechanical properties that differ from conventional soils, making accurate assessment of their behavior essential for preventing geohazards and ensuring operational safety. Specifically, understanding how these formations respond to lateral loads, such as those from offshore structures, is vital. P-Y curves are a standard tool for modeling this lateral soil-structure interaction, but existing P-Y curves, like those from the API standard, are based on conventional soils and may not accurately represent the enhanced strength and stiffness imparted by hydrates. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a corrected P-Y curve specifically for shallow seabed hydrate formations.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Hydrate Sample Preparation: A custom-built device was used to synthesize hydrate samples under laboratory conditions, mimicking in-situ formation. This involved controlling temperature, pressure, and gas saturation.
  • Triaxial Shear Testing: The prepared hydrate samples underwent triaxial shear tests to obtain stress-strain curves. These tests were conducted under various conditions of saturation, pore pressure, and temperature to understand their influence on mechanical properties.
  • Mechanical Parameter Calculation: Stress-strain data from the triaxial tests were analyzed to calculate key mechanical parameters like cohesion, internal friction angle, and Young's modulus.
  • Numerical Simulation (ABAQUS): A finite element model was developed in ABAQUS to simulate the behavior of shallow seabed formations containing hydrates. This model incorporated the experimentally determined mechanical properties.
  • P-Y Curve Generation and Correction: P-Y curves were generated from the ABAQUS simulations. These simulated curves were then compared to the existing API standard P-Y curves. Through iterative calculations and error analysis, a new, corrected P-Y curve method was proposed for hydrate-bearing formations.

Datasets

The study utilized laboratory-synthesized hydrate samples. The mechanical properties of these samples were characterized through triaxial shear tests. The data generated from these tests served as the basis for the numerical simulations and the subsequent development of the corrected P-Y curves. No pre-existing large-scale datasets were used for training or evaluation; instead, the researchers generated their own experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrates Significantly Enhance Soil Strength: The presence of methane hydrates acts as a cementitious agent, dramatically increasing the strength and stiffness of seabed sediments. This is a crucial finding, as it implies that standard soil models will underestimate the load-bearing capacity of these formations.
  • Saturation is Key: The mechanical strength of hydrate-bearing sediments is strongly dependent on hydrate saturation. Higher saturation leads to a more pronounced reinforcing effect and a more brittle, strain-softening behavior.
  • Temperature and Pressure Matter: Decreasing temperature and increasing pore pressure also contribute to increased sediment strength, though saturation appears to have the most significant impact.
  • API P-Y Curves are Inadequate: The study clearly demonstrates that the standard API P-Y curves, developed for conventional soils, are not suitable for hydrate-bearing formations. They consistently underestimate the lateral resistance, potentially leading to unsafe design of offshore structures.
  • A New Correction Method is Needed: The research successfully proposes a method to correct P-Y curves for shallow seabed hydrate formations, offering a more accurate tool for engineering design in these environments.

Key Results

  • The strength of hydrate sediments increased with increasing saturation, temperature decrease, and confining pressure increase.
  • For example, as hydrate saturation increased from 0% to 35%, Young's modulus increased from 43 MPa to 128 MPa, cohesion from 4.52 kPa to 295.01 kPa, and the internal friction angle from 29.92° to 38.01°.
  • Numerical simulations using ABAQUS showed that the maximum foundation reaction force (a key component of P-Y curves) clearly increased with saturation.
  • The error rate between the API standard P-Y curves and the simulated hydrate formation P-Y curves was found to be large, indicating the inadequacy of the standard.
  • A new correction method for P-Y curves was proposed based on extensive trial calculations and error rate analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Laboratory vs. In-Situ: The study used laboratory-synthesized hydrate samples. While efforts were made to mimic in-situ conditions, there may be differences in sample homogeneity and pore structure compared to natural hydrate deposits. The paper acknowledges that the porosity of their prepared samples was larger than that of real hydrate deposit samples.
  • Limited Saturation Range: While the study investigated various saturations, the authors noted that for low saturations (5%), the error caused by uneven hydrate distribution was significant, leading to the discarding of some data. The critical saturation value for strain hardening and transformation was identified as being between 15% and 25%.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further research is needed to validate the proposed P-Y curve correction method with more extensive field data and to explore the behavior of hydrate formations under more complex loading conditions and different geological settings. The authors also mention the potential for further refinement of the correction method.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the continuous growth in global energy demand, the exploration and development of hydrates has been the focus of increasing attention, and the accurate evaluation of the mechanical properties of hydrate layers has become particularly important. In this study, using a self-developed hydrate sample preparation device and hydrate triaxial seepage test platform, triaxial shear tests were carried out using the in situ synthesis method for hydrate sediment in the laboratory, and the stress–strain curves of hydrate sediment with different levels of saturation were obtained. By analyzing the stress–strain curve, the mechanical parameters of hydrate sediment were calculated and simulated using ABAQUS (2021, Dassault systemes, Vélizy Villacoublay France) finite element software. Several p-y curves were calculated and compared with the simulation results, and the p-y curve correction method of the hydrate layer in a shallow seabed was obtained. It was found that the strength of the hydrate sediment increased with an increase in saturation. At the same time, an increase in confining pressure and a decrease in temperature also increased the strength of hydrate deposits. Through comparison with the existing API (American Petroleum Institute) standard p-y curve, it was found that its strength is low because the existence of the hydrate improves the formation strength.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{diao2023p,
  author = {Haoyu Diao and Honghai Fan and Rongyi Ji and Bangchen Wu and Yuguang Ye and Yuhan Liu and Fei Zhou and Yixiang Yang and Zhi Yan},
  title = {{P-Y Curve Correction of Shallow Seabed Formation Containing Hydrate}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16073274},
}
Figure