OxyR Is a Convergent Target for Mutations Acquired during Adaptation to Oxidative Stress-Prone Metabolic States

Amitesh Anand, Ke Chen, Edward Catoiu, Anand V. Sastry, Connor A. Olson, Troy E. Sandberg, Yara Seif, Sibei Xu, Richard Szubin, Laurence Yang, Adam M. Feist, Bernhard Ø. PalssonMolecular 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the bacterial transcription factor OxyR is a frequent target for mutations during adaptation to oxidative stress. These mutations lock OxyR in an "on" state, leading to constitutive expression of protective genes, which in turn reduces DNA damage. However, this adaptation comes at the cost of slower growth, highlighting a trade-off between stress tolerance and metabolic efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aerobic metabolism, while efficient, inherently produces reactive oxygen species (ROS) that can damage cellular components. Bacteria have evolved sophisticated defense mechanisms to maintain redox homeostasis, with transcription factors like OxyR playing a central role in coordinating the response. While it's known that OxyR regulates genes involved in mitigating oxidative damage, the specific genetic adaptations that bacteria employ to thrive in environments prone to oxidative stress, particularly under conditions like iron overload, are not fully understood. This paper investigates how bacteria genetically adapt to such conditions and the consequences of these adaptations on their overall physiology and stress tolerance.

Methods

The researchers employed adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) to subject bacterial strains (Escherichia coli and Vibrio natriegens) to specific stress conditions (iron-replete media and peroxide exposure). Following ALE, whole-genome resequencing was used to identify the genetic mutations that arose. To understand the functional consequences of these mutations, they utilized independent component analysis (ICA) on transcriptome data to identify and quantify the activity of "i-modulons," which represent groups of co-regulated genes. This allowed them to assess the activity of the OxyR regulon and other stress response pathways like the SOS response (regulated by LexA). Additionally, genome-scale models of metabolism and macromolecular expression (ME-models) were used to estimate the proteomic cost of constitutive gene expression and its impact on growth rate. Finally, structural modeling and amino acid proximity analysis were used to infer the potential structural impact of the identified OxyR mutations.

Datasets

  • Genomic sequences: Whole-genome sequences of evolved E. coli and V. natriegens strains.
  • Transcriptomic data: RNA sequencing data from evolved and wild-type strains under various conditions.
  • Publicly available E. coli genomes: Used to search for naturally occurring OxyR mutations.
  • Protein structures: PDB entries for oxidized and reduced forms of OxyR were used for structural analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • OxyR as a convergent target: The same gene, oxyR, was repeatedly mutated in independent evolutionary experiments across different bacterial species and conditions, suggesting it's a highly favored target for adaptation to oxidative stress.
  • Constitutive activation of OxyR: Mutations in oxyR consistently led to its constitutive activation, meaning the protein is always in its "on" state, driving the expression of protective genes even in the absence of stress.
  • Structural basis for constitutive activity: Mutations were found to cluster in key regions of OxyR (redox active site, dimer interface, flexible redox loop), favoring the oxidized conformation and thus its continuous activity.
  • Reduced DNA damage as a primary benefit: Constitutive OxyR activity effectively reduced DNA damage, as evidenced by lower LexA i-modulon activity (indicating a less active SOS response).
  • The "fear-greed" trade-off: While gaining peroxide tolerance, the evolved strains experienced a reduced growth rate. This highlights a fundamental trade-off where resources are reallocated from growth ("greed") to stress defense ("fear").
  • Natural adaptation: The identification of similar oxyR mutations in natural E. coli isolates suggests that this adaptive strategy is not just a laboratory phenomenon but occurs in real-world environments.

Key Results

  • All four independent ALE replicates of E. coli in iron-replete conditions acquired mutations in oxyR.
  • V. natriegens ALE strains also acquired mutations in oxyR, leading to significantly increased tolerance to hydrogen peroxide.
  • The iron-evolved E. coli strains showed constitutive high activity of the OxyR i-modulon and were significantly more tolerant to hydrogen peroxide, exhibiting minimal growth retardation.
  • The SOS response (LexA i-modulon activity) was significantly lower in the iron-evolved strains compared to wild-type E. coli when exposed to peroxide, indicating reduced DNA damage.
  • Genome-scale modeling predicted that increased expression of OxyR-regulated genes leads to a decrease in overall growth rate, consistent with the observed phenotypes.
  • Seven E. coli natural isolates were identified with oxyR mutations similar to those found in the ALE strains.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Proteome allocation cost: While ME-models were used to estimate the cost of constitutive OxyR expression, the exact mechanisms and extent of proteome reallocation require further investigation.
  • Dual regulation of OxyR targets: The paper notes that some OxyR target genes can be regulated by both reduced and oxidized forms, suggesting a complex regulatory landscape that might be further perturbed by these mutations.
  • Environmental association of natural isolates: While similar mutations were found in natural isolates, their specific environmental associations and the precise selective pressures driving these adaptations are not fully elucidated. Future work could involve detailed ecological studies of these isolates.
  • Broader implications of constitutive OxyR: The study focuses on peroxide stress, but the implications of constitutively active OxyR in other contexts or for other types of oxidative stress could be explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

Oxidative stress is concomitant with aerobic metabolism. Thus, bacterial genomes encode elaborate mechanisms to achieve redox homeostasis. Here we report that the peroxide-sensing transcription factor, oxyR, is a common mutational target using bacterial species belonging to two genera, Escherichia coli and Vibrio natriegens, in separate growth conditions implemented during laboratory evolution. The mutations clustered in the redox active site, dimer interface, and flexible redox loop of the protein. These mutations favor the oxidized conformation of OxyR that results in constitutive expression of the genes it regulates. Independent component analysis of the transcriptome revealed that the constitutive activity of OxyR reduces DNA damage from reactive oxygen species, as inferred from the activity of the SOS response regulator LexA. This adaptation to peroxide stress came at a cost of lower growth, as revealed by calculations of proteome allocation using genome-scale models of metabolism and macromolecular expression. Further, identification of similar sequence changes in natural isolates of E. coli indicates that adaptation to oxidative stress through genetic changes in oxyR can be a common occurrence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anand2019oxyr,
  author = {Amitesh Anand and Ke Chen and Edward Catoiu and Anand V. Sastry and Connor A. Olson and Troy E. Sandberg and Yara Seif and Sibei Xu and Richard Szubin and Laurence Yang and Adam M. Feist and Bernhard Ø. Palsson},
  title = {{OxyR Is a Convergent Target for Mutations Acquired during Adaptation to Oxidative Stress-Prone Metabolic States}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1093/molbev/msz251},
}
Figure