Abstract
In the present study, we examined whether social categorization based on university affiliation can induce an advantage in recognizing faces. Moreover, we investigated how the reputation or location of the university affected face recognition performance using an old/new paradigm. We assigned five different university labels to the faces: participants' own university and four other universities. Among the four other university labels, we manipulated the academic reputation and geographical location of these universities relative to the participants' own university. The results showed that an own-group face recognition bias emerged for faces with own-university labels comparing to those with other-university labels. Furthermore, we found a robust own-group face recognition bias only when the other university was located in a different city far away from participants' own university. Interestingly, we failed to find the influence of university reputation on own-group face recognition bias. These results suggest that categorizing a face as a member of one's own university is sufficient to enhance recognition accuracy and the location will play a more important role in the effect of social categorization on face recognition than reputation. The results provide insight into the role of motivational factors underlying the university membership in face perception.
Introduction
Psychologists have long observed the "Own-Group Bias" (OGB), where individuals demonstrate superior recognition for faces perceived as belonging to their own social group (e.g., same race, religion, or institution). While well-documented, the specific motivational triggers for this memory boost remain a subject of debate. This study isolates two potential factors: reputation (prestige-driven attention) and location (physical proximity-driven relevance). By examining these variables, the research aims to refine the social cognitive model, which posits that mental effort is selectively allocated to "individuate" socially relevant others.
Methods
The study recruited 150 Chinese undergraduates from Zhejiang Sci-Tech University (ZSTU). The experimental design employed a standard "old/new" face recognition paradigm consisting of a learning phase and a recognition phase.
Stimuli and Procedure
The stimulus set comprised 60 Chinese hairless full-front faces with neutral expressions, edited to remove identifying marks. During the learning phase, participants viewed 30 faces, each paired with a university label. In the recognition phase, they identified "old" versus "new" faces from a set of 60.
The "out-group" labels were manipulated across a 2x2 matrix relative to ZSTU:
- Same Location / Same Reputation (HZDU)
- Same Location / Higher Reputation (ZJU)
- Different Location / Same Reputation (TYUT)
- Different Location / Higher Reputation (TSU)
A control group viewed faces with color-coded backgrounds but no university labels to isolate the effect of social categorization.
Results
The data revealed several key findings regarding the triggers of OGB:
- The Label Effect: Social categorization significantly improved recognition. Faces with university labels yielded a higher sensitivity index ($d' = 0.63$) compared to the no-label control group ($d' = 0.35$).
- Location as a Primary Driver: A robust own-group bias emerged only when the out-group university was geographically distant. Participants recognized ZSTU faces ($d' \approx 0.70-0.83$) significantly better than distant-university faces ($d' \approx 0.34-0.47$). This distance gap was statistically significant ($p = 0.002$).
- Negligible Impact of Reputation: Academic prestige did not influence recognition accuracy ($p = 0.94$). Even labels from elite institutions like Tsinghua University failed to motivate participants to individuate faces more effectively than labels from their own school.
Discussion
The findings suggest that geographical proximity is a more potent motivator for facial individuation than academic reputation. In the East Asian cultural context, where social groups are often viewed as networks of interpersonal relationships, local peers may be perceived as "potential" connections, making them socially relevant.
Our brains appear to act as "cognitive misers," expending the energy required for detailed facial memory only when a social label signals immediate relevance. Future research should explore whether these results hold in Western cultures, which may prioritize individual status and reputation differently, or if the "likelihood of future interaction" is the true underlying mechanism behind the location effect.
Summary updated