OWA for Bipartite Assignments

Jabari Hastings, Sigal Oren, Omer ReingoldFORC 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and analyzes algorithms for optimizing "fairness" in resource allocation problems, specifically bipartite assignments. They propose efficient methods for optimizing welfare over specific segments of the population (intervals) and provide a simpler proof for a known result about optimizing fair ordered weighted averages (OWA) in these settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, a central planner must assign resources (e.g., jobs to workers, students to schools) to individuals, each of whom has different valuations for the available resources. A common goal is to maximize overall "social welfare" (the sum of all utilities). However, this can lead to unfair outcomes where individuals with high valuations disproportionately benefit, leaving those with lower valuations behind.

To address this, researchers have explored "fairness" objectives, such as the max-min objective (maximizing the utility of the least well-off individual). This paper tackles the challenge of finding a middle ground between pure efficiency and strict fairness. They investigate a class of objectives called Ordered Weighted Averages (OWA), which allow for a spectrum of fairness preferences by assigning different weights to individuals based on their rank in terms of utility. The core problem is how to efficiently find an assignment that optimizes these OWA objectives, especially when dealing with complex fairness criteria.

Methods

The paper introduces several algorithmic contributions:

  • Optimizing over a Single Interval: They present an efficient algorithm to maximize the welfare for a specific contiguous segment (interval) of the population, such as the bottom 20% or the middle 50%. This algorithm is shown to be nearly as efficient as standard maximum-weight bipartite matching.
  • Optimizing over Multiple Intervals: The authors explore scenarios where the planner cares about the welfare within several disjoint intervals. They show that optimizing a single interval can provide a logarithmic approximation to the optimal solution for multiple intervals, especially when the intervals are of equal size.
  • Simplifying Proof for Fair OWA: For a specific type of OWA called "fair OWA" (where weights are non-increasing), the paper provides a simpler proof that optimizing this objective belongs to the complexity class XP. This is achieved by adapting techniques from norm optimization, using proxy functions to approximate the objective and then solving a linear programming relaxation.
  • Proxy Functions: A key technique used in proving the XP membership for fair OWA is the design of "proxy functions." These functions approximate the original OWA objective in a way that is easier to optimize, often by transforming the problem into a maximum-weight bipartite matching problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithms and their complexity, using synthetic instances for illustration rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility in Fairness: The paper highlights that fairness isn't a single concept. By using OWA functions and focusing on specific population segments (intervals), planners can tailor their objectives to prioritize different groups or achieve a balance between efficiency and equity.
  • Interval Optimization as a Building Block: Optimizing welfare over a single interval is shown to be computationally efficient. This simple building block can then be used to approximate more complex objectives, like optimizing over multiple intervals or even general OWA functions.
  • Simpler Proof for XP Membership: The simplified proof for the fair OWA problem's XP membership is a significant contribution, making the result more accessible and potentially opening doors for further research in this area.
  • Trade-offs Between Efficiency and Fairness: The work implicitly demonstrates the inherent trade-offs. While maximizing social welfare is efficient, it can be unfair. Conversely, highly equitable objectives might sacrifice some overall efficiency. OWA functions offer a way to navigate these trade-offs.

Key Results

  • An efficient algorithm for optimizing welfare over any single interval in a bipartite assignment problem.
  • A logarithmic approximation guarantee for optimizing the union of multiple intervals by leveraging single-interval optimization.
  • A simplified proof that the fair OWA multiagent assignment problem belongs to the complexity class XP.
  • A lower bound showing that a single interval optimization can only achieve a logarithmic approximation for general OWA objectives in the worst case.

Limitations and Future Work

  • General OWA Complexity: While the paper provides an XP result for fair OWA, the problem with arbitrary OWA weights remains NP-hard. The paper suggests that a single interval optimization can only achieve a logarithmic approximation for general OWA objectives in the worst case, indicating the difficulty of finding exact solutions for arbitrary weights.
  • Aggregation of Private OWA Functions: The paper mentions that OWA operators with arbitrary weights might arise from aggregating private OWA functions held by stakeholders. An interesting future direction is to design and study aggregation functions for these private OWA functions, and to explore whether agents can be incentivized to truthfully report their preferences.
  • Other Fairness Notions: The authors suggest exploring how OWA operators can capture or approximate other notions of fairness, such as Nash social welfare.
  • Approximation for k-Intervals: While a logarithmic approximation is shown for k-intervals optimization, further research could aim for tighter bounds or exact algorithms for specific cases.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{hastings2025owa,
  author = {Jabari Hastings and Sigal Oren and Omer Reingold},
  title = {{OWA for Bipartite Assignments}},
  booktitle = {FORC},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.forc.2025.21},
}
Figure