Overcoming Ambient Drift and Negative-Bias Temperature Instability in Foundry Carbon Nanotube Transistors

Andrew C. Yu, Tathagata Srimani, Max M. ShulakerarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical reliability challenges of carbon nanotube field-effect transistors (CNFETs) for integration into modern electronics. By employing silicon nitride encapsulation to stabilize CNFETs against environmental drift and then characterizing Negative-Bias Temperature Instability (NBTI) under various stress conditions, they demonstrate that pulsed AC operation significantly enhances NBTI tolerance, paving the way for more robust CNFET-based circuits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the semiconductor industry pushes towards advanced scaling and explores novel materials for beyond-CMOS technologies, carbon nanotube field-effect transistors (CNFETs) have emerged as a promising candidate for back-end-of-line (BEOL) integration. CNFETs offer potential advantages in energy efficiency and performance. However, a major hurdle to their widespread adoption is their reliability, specifically their susceptibility to "ambient drift" (changes in electrical characteristics due to environmental factors like atmospheric moisture) and Negative-Bias Temperature Instability (NBTI). NBTI is a well-known reliability limiter in conventional silicon transistors, and its impact on CNFETs, especially those fabricated using silicon foundry processes, needs thorough characterization. Previous studies have often used non-standard fabrication methods or focused on less relevant device structures, leaving a gap in understanding NBTI in BEOL-compatible CNFETs. This paper aims to address this gap by stabilizing CNFETs and then systematically investigating their NBTI behavior under both DC and AC stress conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a silicon foundry-compatible fabrication flow for their CNFETs. To combat ambient drift, they utilized a passivation layer consisting of Al₂O₃ followed by silicon nitride (SiNₓ) and SiOx. This encapsulation was crucial for ensuring that subsequent NBTI measurements were not confounded by environmental influences.

For NBTI characterization, they employed a "relax-stress-measure" approach, which is a standard technique for BTI testing. They investigated both DC stress (continuous negative gate bias) and AC stress (pulsed negative gate bias) under varying conditions:

  • Gate Oxide Electric Field: Achieved by varying the gate bias (VGS,Stress).
  • Temperature: Tested at room temperature (25°C) and elevated temperature (125°C).
  • Equivalent Oxide Thickness (EOT): Devices with different EOT values were used.
  • Stress Frequency and Duty Cycle: For AC stress, frequencies from 1 kHz to 10 MHz and duty cycles from 20% to 50% were explored.

The measurements involved applying a stress bias for a defined period, followed by a relaxation period, and then measuring the device's threshold voltage (VT) shift. This was done "on-the-fly" to capture the dynamic behavior of NBTI.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization of fabricated devices rather than training on or evaluating against existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SiNₓ Encapsulation is Key for Stability: The silicon nitride encapsulation proved highly effective in mitigating ambient drift, reducing the median threshold voltage shift by over 8x compared to baseline devices after 90 days in ambient atmosphere. This stabilization is critical for reliable NBTI measurements.
  • AC Pulsed Operation is a Game Changer for NBTI: The most significant finding is that pulsed AC operation dramatically improves NBTI tolerance compared to DC stress. This is attributed to the relaxation periods between stress pulses, allowing trapped charges to de-trap and reducing the overall accumulation of VT shift.
  • Duty Cycle is Crucial for AC NBTI Mitigation: The benefit of AC operation is strongly dependent on the duty cycle. Lower duty cycles (more relaxation time) lead to substantially longer times-to-failure.
  • Frequency Independence of AC NBTI Benefit: Interestingly, the observed improvement in NBTI tolerance with AC stress was largely independent of frequency across the tested range (1 kHz to 10 MHz), suggesting a robust benefit for typical logic operations.
  • Temperature's Role: While temperature doesn't significantly increase the long-term magnitude of VT shift, it does cause the "peak" VT shift to occur sooner and lengthens the relaxation time.

Key Results

  • Ambient Drift Reduction: SiNₓ encapsulated CNFETs showed a median threshold voltage shift of approximately 54 mV after 90 days in ambient air, an ~8x improvement over baseline devices (median shift ~450 mV).
  • NBTI Time-to-Failure Enhancement: For a target |ΔVт| tolerance of 100 mV under a stress bias of -1.2 V at 125°C, AC operation with a 20% duty cycle at 10 MHz could extend the time-to-failure by over 10⁴ times compared to DC operation. Even with a 50% duty cycle, the improvement was significant.
  • NBTI Dependence on Electric Field: The magnitude of NBTI-induced ΔVт showed a linear dependence on the normalized oxide electric field (|ξox'|) for fields greater than 2 MV/cm.
  • Interface Trap Density: The estimated density of interfacial traps (Dit) in these CNFETs was found to be around 10¹³ cm⁻² eV⁻¹, which is significantly higher than in conventional silicon MOSFETs. This suggests that interface trap dynamics play a crucial role in CNFET NBTI.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the physical origin of NBTI in their CNFETs is speculated to be from oxide charge trapping, potentially facilitated by trap-assisted tunneling from interface traps at the CNT-oxide interface. While they provide evidence supporting this, further detailed investigations into the exact trapping and de-trapping mechanisms would be beneficial.

The paper suggests that the demonstrated methodology for operating CNFETs in pulsed logic workloads with sufficient duty cycling can overcome NBTI. This opens avenues for future work in developing more accurate circuit-level models for CNFETs, enabling circuit designers to co-design appropriate circuit-level tolerances and mitigations for CNFET behavior shift. Understanding the interplay between AC stress parameters (duty cycle, frequency) and device physics for a wider range of conditions and materials would also be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{yu2024overcoming,
  author = {Andrew C. Yu and Tathagata Srimani and Max M. Shulaker},
  title = {{Overcoming Ambient Drift and Negative-Bias Temperature Instability in Foundry Carbon Nanotube Transistors}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2409.11297},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.11297},
}

Loading related content...

Figure